Frank Castle vs Steve Rogers

Started by Dum Dum Dugan3 pages

Originally posted by Deadline
Yeah sure.

yea sure what? I asked two direct question and yea sure doesent answer either of them.

Listen man I'm done. I'm not really feeling a debate right now.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
would probly win? It wouldent even be a fight, daken dident even uses his pheramones the first time and was toying with him.
daken rarely uses his pheromones, or people have learned how to work around them. Daken is plagued by CIS, so yes it would be a fight.

Originally posted by Deadline
Listen man I'm done. I'm not really feeling a debate right now.

why even respond back then? seems rather poinless, either debate or don't.

Originally posted by Trackz
daken rarely uses his pheromones, or people have learned how to work around them. Daken is plagued by CIS, so yes it would be a fight.

actaully he uses them all the time, it only when hack writers uses him during a guest spot is when there ignored.

Hell they were even stated in his recent fight with Frank.

He does uses them and it would make for a very easy win against human castle.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
why even respond back then? seems rather poinless, either debate or don't.

Don't waste my time then.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
actaully he uses them all the time, it only when hack writers uses him during a guest spot is when there ignored.

Hell they were even stated in his recent fight with Frank.

He does uses them and it would make for a very easy win against human castle.

No he doesn't use them all the time and its not even a foregone conclusion it would work.

Originally posted by Deadline
Don't waste my time then.

No he doesn't use them all the time and its not even a foregone conclusion it would work.


your such a child sometimes.

actaully they would work, there zero reason to assume they won't, he even made a point of stating that phermones don't work on castle new body, implying they worked on his old one.

He uses them when he fighting at his peak which is what he be doing on forum battle. He also uses the phermones all of the time he very rarely doesent uses them.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
your such a child sometimes.

Sure.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan

actaully they would work, there zero reason to assume they won't, he even made a point of stating that phermones don't work on castle new body, implying they worked on his old one.

Um no that doesn't neccsarily mean that.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan

He uses them when he fighting at his peak which is what he be doing on forum battle. He also uses the phermones all of the time he very rarely doesent uses them.

Nope I can think of quite a few times when he hasn't.

Originally posted by Deadline
Sure.

Um no that doesn't neccsarily mean that.

Nope I can think of quite a few times when he hasn't.


to assume they wont work on castle is really rediculous. what castle all of a sudden became a mutant who sole power is immunity to daken pheramones?

he wouldent be at his peak so why would it be assume daken would not fight to the best of his ability? also thoses few times are out wade by the majority of times when he does uses them, they also are his quest apearences by hack witers who dident even realize his third claw was coated with magical blade.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
actaully he uses them all the time, it only when hack writers uses him during a guest spot is when there ignored.

Hell they were even stated in his recent fight with Frank.

He does uses them and it would make for a very easy win against human castle.

then where did they go against Ronin, Wolverine, or Frank (first fight and second fight)? Those are just the ones that come right to mind.

Originally posted by Trackz
then where did they go against Ronin, Wolverine, or Frank (first fight and second fight)? Those are just the ones that come right to mind.

becuase the writer of ronin fight was a hack, also why would you even try using that as an example when in the same fight his third claws magical blade mas magically gone...........yes great evidences there champ.

He did uses it against wolverine it was even stated.

Frank he was toying with which was obvious.

He tried using it vs frankin castle but it dident work.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
becuase the writer of ronin fight was a hack, also why would you even try using that as an example when in the same fight his third claws magical blade mas magically gone...........yes great evidences there champ.

He did uses it against wolverine it was even stated.

Frank he was toying with which was obvious.

He tried using it vs frankin castle but it dident work.


his muramasa claw has nothing to do with his senses, and it is possible the fight took place before he got it

Originally posted by Trackz
his muramasa claw has nothing to do with his senses, and it is possible the fight took place before he got it

if the righter for got one thing pretty big thing about a character why would using him as evidences help you? guy clearly was not up to date on his knolwedge. No it not possible it took place before. Because Daken got his magical claws prior to jioining osborn team.

he already had the claws in various other stories why would the one story be a back story in the MU... especially when it takes place during a time in MU history where daken already had the claw and had chosen to join the dark avengers?

facepalm2

Originally posted by King Castle
he already had the claws in various other stories why would the one story be a back story in the MU... especially when it takes place during a time in MU history where daken already had the claw and had chosen to join the dark avengers?

facepalm2


becuase he got nothing and he reaching.

Originally posted by King Castle
he already had the claws in various other stories why would the one story be a back story in the MU... especially when it takes place during a time in MU history where daken already had the claw and had chosen to join the dark avengers?

facepalm2

happens all the time, like frank being human in shadowland

Originally posted by Trackz
happens all the time, like frank being human in shadowland

He's not human in Shadow Land, he was human in a Shadow Land promo. There has only been mention of him in Shadow Land, and it mentioned that he was Frakencastle.

Good to hear.

Optimistically Frank is going take a minimum of three hits for every one he lands. Now, while I personally believe that Frank is hands down, absolutely the most durable street level human (and I include Cap in that list), I don't think his edge is enough to make up being hit 3:1 by a stronger, faster and more skilled opponent.

Statistically Frank would lose this fight every time if it was run in a simulation. The thing is though, he knows that and being the crafty guy he is, he can play his own weaknesses to his advantage. Knowing he is going to tire and slow down long before Captain America, he can play it up, pretending to tire and slow down a bit faster then normal. Secretly keeping something in reserve for perfectly timed strike, while Cap thinks he is running on fumes, he could potentially take Cap by surprise and pull out a win.

Steve Rogers.