Bill wins, imo.
If Majestic can cut through the shielding/armor of Eradicator (in full fortress-mode) with HV, then surely blasts from Stormbreaker could tear through the shielding/armor of the even weaker version of Erads specified in this match -- As for the offensive blasts Erads can utilize, they'd be easily deflected or absorbed via Stormbreaker -- As for a physical melee, Bill has cracked Galactus' helm and shattered planetoids (to name a few) with strikes from his hammer... And I've seen Erads smacked to the wayside by a casual backhand from Majestic, and KO'd (almost killed) by a single strike from an OMAC.
Originally posted by Galan007
Bill wins, imo.If Majestic can cut through the shielding/armor of Eradicator (in full fortress-mode) with HV, then surely blasts from Stormbreaker could tear through the shielding/armor of the even weaker version of Erads specified in this match -- As for the offensive blasts Erads can utilize, they'd be easily deflected or absorbed via Stormbreaker -- As for a physical melee, Bill has cracked Galactus' helm and shattered planetoids (to name a few) with strikes from his hammer... And I've seen Erads smacked to the wayside by a casual backhand from Majestic, and KO'd (almost killed) by a single strike from an OMAC.
The Omac version was an extremely weakened and sunlight starved version of Erads. The whole reason Supes/Steel/Superboy even showed up was bc Erads put out a faint distress signal.
The same Erads that was backslapped was about to crush Majestic with one hand. Majestic then told Erads later "You almost killed me."
BRB's blasts could also be absorbed/redirected by by Eradicator. I'd wager that Eradicator has a hell of a lot more powers than Bill does.
Let's not forget that BRB was beat up by the same version of Champion that She-Hulk easily beat if we really want to go after "low" feats.
Originally posted by Avlon
The Omac version was an extremely weakened and sunlight starved version of Erads. The whole reason Supes/Steel/Superboy even showed up was bc Erads put out a faint distress signal.The same Erads that was backslapped was about to crush Majestic with one hand. Majestic then told Erads later "You almost killed me."
BRB's blasts could also be absorbed/redirected by by Eradicator. I'd wager that Eradicator has a hell of a lot more powers than Bill does.
Let's not forget that BRB was beat up by the same version of Champion that She-Hulk easily beat if we really want to go after "low" feats.
Yep. Eradicator is a bit more versatile than Bill, IMO.
Originally posted by AvlonI don't know where you got this from, but it sure wasn't from the same issue where an OMAC KO'd Eradicator (Superman #220.) Steel is the one who initiated a JLA distress signal, and that was because Erads had gone berzerk and owned him. Additionally, that issue never mentions Erads being "sunlight starved" -- in fact, all of his battles took place in the sunlight.
The Omac version was an extremely weakened and sunlight starved version of Erads. The whole reason Supes/Steel/Superboy even showed up was bc Erads put out a faint distress signal.
Originally posted by AvlonThe only time Erads was able to subdue Majestic at all was when he went 'full' fortress mode:
The same Erads that was backslapped was about to crush Majestic with one hand. Majestic then told Erads later "You almost killed me."
But even with those upgrades, Majestic was still able to cut through his armor with HV (a point which you neglected to address):
http://img844.imageshack.us/i/erad2.jpg/
Sorry, but if Majestic's HV can cut through Eradicator's upgraded armor that easily, then Bill's blasts could as well.
Originally posted by AvlonHas Eradicator absorbed high-level, magic-based attacks (of which Stormbreaker produces)? I only remember him absorbing energy from the FoS, and the sun. If he has, can you please provide a source?
BRB's blasts could also be absorbed/redirected by by Eradicator. I'd wager that Eradicator has a hell of a lot more powers than Bill does.
And your opinion that Eradicator has more powers than Bill is moot whether he does or not. Why? Because regardless of how many powers Erads has, Bill has shown, time and time again, that he is able to block/shield against high-level attacks from the likes of Surfer, Thor, Stardust, the Skrull Godkiller, etc. Furthermore, Bill has shown the offensive capability to take down B&T Thor (who owned Surfer with ease) after he got angry/serious. So yeah...
Originally posted by Prep-ManThere wasn't much he could do even if he knew it was coming. 1) The board can travel as fast as it wants 2) Bill was already blocking Surfer's attack from the front.
Too bad Bill didnt have a Spidey sense. Spider-Man> Bill 😄
Surfer also noted that he cannot match his power... I don't think Bill ever had a chance there.
Bill.
Originally posted by kgkg
There wasn't much he could do even if he knew it was coming. 1) The board can travel as fast as it wants 2) Bill was already blocking Surfer's attack from the front.Surfer also noted that he cannot match his power... I don't think Bill ever had a chance there.
If he knew it was coming, he could have probably extended his shielding to a 360 radius.
Lol.
Originally posted by amnesiaBill has made a 360 shield to hold a blast capable of destroying 1/5 of the universe? I wasn't aware scan?
So a shield that is capable of holding a blast that could take out 1/5 of the universe isn't capable to hold against surfer?
Even if the shield could hold Bill will still always be on the defense if Surfer used a similar tactic. Considering a close of shot from Strombreaker did absolutely nothing to hurt the Surfer.
