The most underrated...

... Among this characters:

But first and foremost, keep it civil.

Superman
Nova
Kyle Rayner
Batman
Darkseid
Puck
Hulk
Silver Surfer

Try to explain your answer (although I know most of you won't 🙂 )

darkseid is the only underatted there
everone else is over rated at times

Depending on who you ask... Each character on your list has fans that wank for and against them...
Puck doesn't have many fans... But his history as a coward and his use of the space gem wasn't at all imaginative or indicative of a powerhouse...

Originally posted by rotiart
Depending on who you ask... Each character on your list has fans that wank for and against them...
Puck doesn't have many fans... But his history as a coward and his use of the space gem wasn't at all imaginative or indicative of a powerhouse...

Puck is a coward? He had the Space Gem? 😖

Mixing Puck and Pipe up

underrated by who... the fans, or amongst other comics book characters?

Fans: based on some of the match-ups people put him in around here, I'll say Surfer.

comic characters: of course, it's Batman.

Originally posted by iceman24567
Mixing Puck and Pipe up

Though so, Pip is ever scarcer at the forums than Puck (not counting tournaments here).

Originally posted by marwash22
underrated by who... the fans, or amongst other comics book characters?

Fans: based on some of the match-ups people put him in around here, I'll say Surfer.

comic characters: of course, it's Batman.

I was asking about here in the forums, but a general impression of comic readers would be cool too.

Right answer: Hulk.

If he was half as helpless as posters here thinks he is against foes that he's pitted against regularly on KMC, he wouldn't have lasted twenty issues in comics.

Pip.... Ohhhh oops haha then I have no idea who the heck puck is

gotta say, for KMC it's Hulk, though I think it's more as a by-product of the Thor-love.

Originally posted by janus77
gotta say, for KMC it's Hulk, though I think it's more as a by-product of the Thor-love.

Thor is loved indeed, likely one of the highest rated characters in the forum.

I think that's why Hulk is reviled by so many and basic "givens" of the character's powerset are seen as up for contention. like the forums myth of a limit on his anger (in the mistaken belief that it would thus imply a limit to his strength) that conveniently falls firmly within whatever character he's pitted against's capacity to out last.

unlike any other character talked about here, the dislike becomes evident quickly and then turns obstinant and heated...

Darkseid. His low showings are taken as his norm, and he is not looked upon (in KMC) as one of DC's major cosmic villains as he was meant to be.

I say Hulk. The second one would be Nova. And another one would be Wonder Woman.

Originally posted by BerserkersRage
Darkseid. His low showings are taken as his norm, and he is not looked upon (in KMC) as one of DC's major cosmic villains as he was meant to be.

Originally posted by Bouboumaster
I say Hulk. The second one would be Nova. And another one would be Wonder Woman.

Oh, Wonder Woman. We have one or two people who overrate her, a reasonable that get her right, and then there's the all too common "What do you mean someone who goes toe-to-toe with Superman often, has multiple trans to low skyfather levels in her rogues gallery, and is a member of DC's Trinity is actually deserving of her high herald spot?". Ditto for her villains- Cheetah's probably one of the most misjudged by people either under or overrating her.

Nova used to be underrated but I think recent campaigns by pro-Novites have gotten a better view of him. Hulk, Darksied... yea.

Originally posted by BerserkersRage
Darkseid. His low showings are taken as his norm, and he is not looked upon (in KMC) as one of DC's major cosmic villains as he was meant to be.

DS is and has been a threat to all that is in the DCU. Definitely under-rated on KMC.

Originally posted by Bentley
But first and foremost, keep it civil.

ha. good luck.

Thanos is underrated. 😄

Originally posted by BerserkersRage
Darkseid. His low showings are taken as his norm, and he is not looked upon (in KMC) as one of DC's major cosmic villains as he was meant to be.