Cross Genre Nominations #17

Started by Dum Dum Dugan15 pages

Originally posted by marwash22
this is animated Star Wars?

star war clone war mini is cannon and take places between movie 2 and 3.

Honestly people need to understand that even in the movies, jedi were suposes to be moving well beyond human standards, it just hard to potray, much like in high lander.

Originally posted by illadelph12
That Wolverine qualifier made me laugh, btw.

?

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I veto the SW vs. spiderman thread.

Any particular reason?

Originally posted by illadelph12
Isn't it all canon? I remember Galan posting a Star Wars Canon table around here somewhere.

There levels of cannon, somethings arnt cannon, becuase they contradict, lucas. Star wars mini is directly sanction by Lucas him self.

However the new star wars clone wars (not the mini) is not cannon, becuase directly contrdicts Lucas own words and story.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Any particular reason?
I don't think its a good match.IMO both those jedi are just beyond the spiders leagues.

G Canon is the highest, this includes the Six movies and direct statements made by Lucas in interviews and commentary.

T Canon is the second highest and includes both Star Wars Clone Wars TV series and the upcoming Live Action series.

C Canon is Expanded Universe: novels, comics, and certain game cinematics.

I forget the rest.

Originally posted by Black bolt z
I don't think its a good match.IMO both those jedi are just beyond the spiders leagues.

Don't veto it, since there are plenty of people who will disagree with that notion. The purpose of the veto is to keep troll threads and dud threads from making the cut. IMO this one is neither.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
star war clone war mini is cannon and take places between movie 2 and 3.

Honestly people need to understand that even in the movies, jedi were suposes to be moving well beyond human standards, it just hard to potray, much like in high lander.

no.

I don't care if Lucas considers it canon or not, animation and live action are two completely different types of Jedi. Animated Jedi do things that put them on tier with mid-level mutants. Live action Mace could barely hold off force lighting... animated mace was moving like a low level speedster. if you wanna use animated versions, you need to specify you're doing so.

Second show is not T, it actaully far lower on the list, becuase it dirrectly conflicts with the movies. Also the clone wars mini is boarderline G cannon, becuase it was create and sanction by Lucas and it suposes to tell the story of what happens between movies 2 and 3.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Second show is not T, it actaully far lower on the list, becuase it dirrectly conflicts with the movies.

Not this bullshit again. Find a statement that supports this from Lucas or anyone of authority, because I've seen no such distinction.

The CGI Clone Wars fills in the gaps between the timeskip of the original Clone Wars series.

Originally posted by marwash22
no.

I don't care if Lucas considers it canon or not, animation and live action are two completely different types of Jedi. Animated Jedi do things that put them on tier with mid-level mutants. Live action Mace could barely hold off force lighting... animated mace was moving like a low level speedster. if you wanna use animated versions, you need to specify you're doing so.


Yes it cannon, I dont give a rat ass what you care about. It cannon, it part of the character. Mace barly deflected force lightning? He was able to not only deflect it but turn it against the strongest sith . Palp was able to speed blizt three of the most powerful jedi in exsistences. There fight was taking place at extreme speed and the shock wave of there fight blasted ever single window in the office at onces when they collided. You should try reading the actual script some time.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Not this bullshit again. Find a statement that supports this from Lucas or anyone of authority, because I've seen no such distinction.

The CGI Clone Wars fills in the gaps between the timeskip of the original Clone Wars series.

No it doesent. Dude I don't need to. One of the main characters doesent even exsist in Lucas world. It not cannon. It dirrectly contradicts the movies fact.

Here it is:

* T-canon,[2] or Television Canon[3], refers to the canon level comprising the feature film Star Wars: The Clone Wars and the two television shows Star Wars: The Clone Wars and the Star Wars live-action TV series.[4][5] It was devised recently in order to define a status above the C-Level canon, as confirmed by Chee[6].

So anyhow as you can see there are two ways you can interpret that, either its saying that the CGI movie and subsequent series are canon and implicitly including the older series or it doesn't include the series because the older series is non-canon.

So the idea that the earlier series is canon while the newer is non canon is completely baseless.

People hate Ahsoka so much that they construct this idea that the series is non-canon.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
Here it is:

* T-canon,[2] or Television Canon[3], refers to the canon level comprising the [b]feature film Star Wars: The Clone Wars and the two television shows Star Wars: The Clone Wars and the Star Wars live-action TV series.[4][5] It was devised recently in order to define a status above the C-Level canon, as confirmed by Chee[6].

So anyhow as you can see there are two ways you can interpret that, either its saying that the CGI movie and subsequent series are canon and implicitly including the older series or it doesn't include the series because the older series is non-canon.

So the idea that the earlier series is canon while the newer is non canon is completely baseless. [/B]


or that post could all be bullshit statement you found on the internet with no official backing? which is what it is.

No it not, becuase the older series does not make up a completely new main character. that was never refferenced onces in any of the movies but some how magically apeared. Anakin padwan exsistences contradicts Lucas own works, which in it self makes it not T cannon.

anything that contrdicts Lucas own works is consider not cannon for Lucas world.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
or that post could all be bullshit statement you found on the internet with no official backing? which is what it is.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Canon#cite_note-2

It's a statement from the Holocron Continuity Database operated by Leland Chee. He's pretty high up in Lucasfilms, Lucas himself tasked him with constructing the canon ladder.

Just stop talking already.

Originally posted by Omega Vision
http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Canon#cite_note-2

It's a statement from the Holocron Continuity Database operated by Leland Chee. He's pretty high up in Lucasfilms, Lucas himself tasked him with constructing the canon ladder.

Just stop talking already.


I just went to the sight, the link wiki gives, is to forum page, and guess what? it says nothing about that at all on that page given as evidence.....what a shocker wiki full of shit

http://forums.starwars.com/thread.jspa?threadID=152583&start=01779

so dont tell me to stop talking when your own evidences is garbage wiki page.

el oh el. a shockwave!?

I thought the glass broke because they hit it with their sabers... but hey, you're the fanbo... err, expert.

At the very best the newest TV events perhaps are cannon, but any part in which anakin padawan is a part of would not be cannon to Lucas world. Because it would directly contradict Lucas films.

Originally posted by marwash22
el oh el. a shockwave!?

I thought the glass broke because they hit it with their sabers... but hey, you're the fanbo... err, expert.

There light sabre never touch the glass. script and commentary both back that it was energy that destroy the widow when the collided. That they were fighting at extreme speeds.

sorry that you dislike that it cannon, but deal with it.

When did i say i didn't like that it was canon? 😬

Perhaps you should spend less time jerkin' it to Star Wars dvds and more time improving your reading comprehension skills. What i said was that, if you're using animated versions, you need to specify you're doing so because what animated character's are capable of, exceeds what live action characters are capable of.

Animated Mase would pwn live Action Mase based on feats.

So it's Mace Windu Vs Iron Spider-man with the stip that Mace can not use the force offensively, only to amp his own physical attributes.

Also we, with the same stipulations, Mace Windu and Darth Vader Vs. Iron Spider-man and Venom.