Jason Todd Vs Frank Castle

Started by Uriel0054 pages

my bad lol not awake at the moment.

what are their starting weapons.

Originally posted by Mindset
Dick thinks of jason like a brother, otherwise he would rape him everytime

agreed.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Jason Todd. Frank might be tougher, but Jason has more skill, and is just as ruthless imo.

I think you be hard pressed to prove jason more skilled, let a lone to the point it gives him the win.

why do you believe he more skilled? Also in what way do you believe he more skilled?

I agree with both you and mind that Dick holds back against him.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
I think you be hard pressed to prove jason more skilled, let a lone to the point it gives him the win.

why do you believe he more skilled? Also in what way do you believe he more skilled?

I agree with both you and mind that Dick holds back against him.

His pure h2h skill is what i'm talking about. His h2h both as Robin and as Red Hood do more than convince me that he's good enough when you think about who he's fought.

Plus, when you consider the people he's held his own against and how well they've done and the amount of times he's done it, it says a lot about him.

Dick, Tim, Batman etc.

Originally posted by -Pr-
His pure h2h skill is what i'm talking about. His h2h both as Robin and as Red Hood do more than convince me that he's good enough when you think about who he's fought.

Plus, when you consider the people he's held his own against and how well they've done and the amount of times he's done it, it says a lot about him.

Dick, Tim, Batman etc.

but he doesn't have a gun here...also he's never faced a pain soaker like castle before

Originally posted by Starscream M
but he doesn't have a gun here...also he's never faced a pain soaker like castle before

i never said anything about guns.

he's fought batman.

Originally posted by -Pr-
i never said anything about guns.

he's fought batman.

castle can take more punishment than batman

Originally posted by Starscream M
castle can take more punishment than batman

even if he could, batman still has insane damage soak.

Originally posted by -Pr-
His pure h2h skill is what i'm talking about. His h2h both as Robin and as Red Hood do more than convince me that he's good enough when you think about who he's fought.

Plus, when you consider the people he's held his own against and how well they've done and the amount of times he's done it, it says a lot about him.

Dick, Tim, Batman etc.


Why would you assume it go h2h? This are two guys who start off quite a bit away from eachother and have loads of weapons.

also no one on that list is more impressive then the people Punisher has hung with.

like Daredevil, Kraven, Wolverine ect.

Originally posted by Starscream M
but he doesn't have a gun here...also he's never faced a pain soaker like castle before

yes he does have a gun here.....why would you assume he doesent?

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Why would you assume it go h2h? This are two guys who start off quite a bit away from eachother and have loads of weapons.

also no one on that list is more impressive then the people Punisher has hung with.

like Daredevil, Kraven, Wolverine ect.

Oh, they have guns too? That makes it more interesting...

I'd consider Batman to be superior to those three, and Dick to be the equal or at least close to equal to a couple of em.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
yes he does have a gun here.....why would you assume he doesent?
cuz OP didn't specify...then what does castle get?

Originally posted by -Pr-
Oh, they have guns too? That makes it more interesting...

I'd consider Batman to be superior to those three, and Dick to be the equal or at least close to equal to a couple of em.


yes I mean it part of there standard gear.

wait a sec based on what? did you just try and say batman is superior to wolverine melee setting? Dick is equal to him and DD? are you kidding me?

Originally posted by Starscream M
cuz OP didn't specify...then what does castle get?

They get there standard gear, like always..........

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
They get there standard gear, like always..........
whats frank's standard gear?

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
yes I mean it part of there standard gear.

wait a sec based on what? did you just try and say batman is superior to wolverine melee setting? Dick is equal to him and DD? are you kidding me?

i thought someone said it was just h2h. my bad.

in skill, i believe batman is superior to wolverine, yes, though i am not about to turn this in to a batman vs wolverine thread.

and i was talking about kraven and dd.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan

wait a sec based on what? did you just try and say batman is superior to wolverine melee setting? Dick is equal to him and DD? are you kidding me?

batman is superior to wolverine in skill...

Originally posted by -Pr-
i thought someone said it was just h2h. my bad.

in skill, i believe batman is superior to wolverine, yes, though i am not about to turn this in to a batman vs wolverine thread.

and i was talking about kraven and dd.


yea I dont get why everyone been assuming that despite it never being stated, but I can see why you think that based on a lot of people responses.

well you be dead wrong. Both DD and Wolverine have feats of skill to match batman and in some cases more impressive ones. also based off Logan powerset and skill combind it be a shit load harder to hang with him in melee range then Batman.

Kraven meta human, but yes Dick is more skilled, more of a threat in h2h? debatable. Dick is not on DD level. DD feats easily match Batmans own. You are soorely under playing DD.

Originally posted by Starscream M
batman is superior to wolverine in skill...

prove it.