KuRuPT Thanosi
Senior Member
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
^ You not bothering to see how it started and how it deteriorated into pure trolling justifies your narrow opinion of a single post?He has no argument. He insists that at one point, Thanos was disoriented two issues before the event in question. I haven't argued that. But apparently, I need to reminded of it and berated for acting like I argued against that fact over and over repeatedly over several pages. Whatever argument he's got is a negative proof fallacy: it isn't 100% sure that it would work.
It's not 100% sure that it wouldn't work. That isn't my argument, that's just me throwing his negative proof fallacy back at his face. I want no part of that fallacious horsepoo but I don't mind illustrating how fallacious it is to rebut someone trolling me with it. At some point maybe this discussion might turn back to the viability of anti-matter working. We haven't reached that point.
We're still at Raging Bleeding Butt Defcon 4.
False again… You said it DID work on Thanos.. but left off the fact that he was weakened.. a very very key factor here. You and others said.. Thanos was also vulnerable to anti-matter.. again false.. that is proven… you acting like stuff is a fact, when it's not, is why I'm here correcting you. A weakened Thanos being killed by an anitmatter device DOESN'T prove a normal Thanos is vulnerable nor that it would work. Your assumption and speculation is why I'm here, not the other way around. You are the only one use a no limits fallacy and negative proof fallacy. You acting like he's vulnerable isn't true.. there is zero proof he is vulnerable because he was weakened.
Your fallacies come into play when you say he was recovered enough… how do you know this.. yes he was recovering that doesn't mean he was FULLY recovered does it? An actually, we have a statement RIGHT BEFORE the blast which favors my side over yours. You lack of reading comprehension doesn't change that fact. It said he recovered ENOUGH.. not fully recovered… not at full strength.. he's recovered enough.. then only a tool like you would go… see he was recovering.. duh you twit.. nobody is disputing this fact and I certainly never have. Recovering is A LOT different then being at 100%. So.. the statement right before the blast favors me and that he wasn't at 100% still. What further favors me is when he did come back she could still read his mind and sense his pain and emotions… We've seen moondragon with the mind gem not even be able to penetrate his mind when he's at normal levels. Yet, she could read it that easy… That would also favor my theory. Thanks for playing though. Now onto why it probably wouldn't work..
1. We've seen Thanos take A LOT more than this little device in his history. I won't waste time listing the times but it's clear he can take much more. Now then, why would this be.. hmmm he's weakened is a very good possiblity as to why… Actually, his durability was even said not to be at normal levels which is separate than his physical and mental state which were also compromised. If Thanos has taken a gas giant, a black hole and countless shots from exponentially more powerful people than this little device.. I think it's clear why it worked… he was weakened and his durability isn't at normal levels as stated on panel.
2. Now why would your mental state be a factor here… well… Thanos is one of the smartest in marvel.. he has won countless fights by outsmarting people.. Yet if this is compromised is he going to fight at peak levels… nope.. In fact, if he was the device might not have ever been placed there in the first place. Lets continue that line of thought.. When you have total control of your molecular structure.. how do you go about using that ability and making any necessary repairs that might need doing.. hmmmmm…. lets think.. your mind huh? That would be a key factor in utilizing this ability wouldn't it.. Well if his mind is compromised and not at full power.. this would mean this ability that could've prevented this wasn't working at full power. We've seen him at the nexus of realities and his body constantly repairing itself… Not only do we have a healing factor which could've been comprised via his weakness.. we have his durability which was flat out stated to be compromised… we also have his mental state not all being there.. even if it was recovering we have a specific on panel statement saying THAT universe makes it hard for him to concentrate. There is zero indication this had to do with his weakened state, in fact, it could just be how that universe would also affect him. So if his mental state is compromised… he won't fight as well.. and won't be able to use a key ability that might have prevented him from being killed.