RoTS Yoda vs Half-Blood Prince

Originally posted by dadudemon
1. That's dumbledore: the most powerful and well-rounded wizard current generation and one of the most powerful of all time. Hardly a good comparison. 😉

2. Movie blunders do not trump the higher canon source: the books. Only in the MVF do we have stupid sh*t like that happening.

3. Do you honestly think Dumbles didn't have the ELDER WAND on him? Obvously, he did. 🙂

4. Fred and George had their wands on their person, just the same as Dumbles. 🙂 Prove that their wand was upstairs or wherever else you say it was, other than their person.

Indeed. But let me know when the fight will last long enough for Snape to "fly" at top speed. It's painfully obvious that the fight will be over in less than 5 seconds with either Yoda dead or Snape dead.

hmm

I see your point. Okay, you win.

Force Jump and force speed don't count? 🙂

teehee

PWNED!

I've already done it, John. 🙂

I won't bring it up in the thread because I want the others to stop the HP hate and actually use their knowledges.

Originally posted by dadudemon

I've already done it, John. 🙂

I won't bring it up in the thread because I want the others to stop the HP hate and actually use their knowledges.

As for a wizard needing a wand to apparate....You really think a wizard needs their wand in their pocket just to apparate? Explain that.

potentially, the only thing that beats magic is other magic or divinity. I'm not saying that is the case here because none of the Potter wizards are unstoppable but from what we've seen from the potter-verse there is nothing in the star wars universe that can defend against that magic. Yoda might get lucky but 99/100 times Yoda goes down and hard. There is no way he is going to dodge an avada kedavra spell.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No, you haven't. Please do though, as I said, I welcome it.

I have and you don't remember. That, or you're still in denial.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
As for a wizard needing a wand to apparate....You really think a wizard needs their wand in their pocket just to apparate? Explain that.

I already have. Go back and read if you forgot already.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
How dare you use my real name here. How dare you.

😆

Brings back memories of a certain banned douche.

Originally posted by dadudemon
I have and you don't remember. That, or you're still in denial.

I already have. Go back and read if you forgot already.

😆

Brings back memories of a certain banned douche.

Nothing.

Nothing.

Bewbz.

OK boys and girls, prepare to be raped.

Here is a scene from THBP:

YouTube video

Harry is chasing Snape after Snape killed Dumbledore. At :15, Harry casts Incarcerous. Snape blocks it.

At :18, Bellatrix casts a non verbal spell that hits Harry instantly.

At :43, Harry casts sectumsempra at Snape. Snape turns, blocks the scetumsempra, and casts a non verbal spell back at Harry, knocking Harry on his back. This all happened in about one second. Snape's back was turned, Harry cast the spell, it reached Snape, Snape turns to face Harry, blocks the spell, AND cast a spell back at Harry. All in less than a second. And no, Snape did not rebound the sectumsempra back at Harry. How do we know this? Because Harry was not sliced to ribbons. Snape's reaction time here is greater than any Jedi. All 4 spells in the video travel at least as fast, probably faster than blaster bolts.

Precog was fine during ROTS. What was affected was the Jedi ability to see brief glimpses of the future, as Luke did in ESB. Battle precog was faulty at best.

Verdict? Wizards>>>>>>>>>>>>Jedi, all day, every day, without fail.

Any more questions? I'll copy/paste this into the Snape/Sidious thread.