Starkiller (TFU II) vs Luke Skywalker (ROTJ)

A question has been in my mind for a while now since I've seen TFU II come along, If the Starkiller in TFU II would meet and fight Luke Skywalker from Return of the Jedi...Who would win?... Personally I'm rooting for Starkiller especially since he was also trained by Yoda for a bit but I want to know what the rest of you people think.

Location: Degobah Swamp

(If this is a topic that has been posted in the past I apologize and request a link to it. Thank you. 😄)

So you think Starkiller would win because he was trained Yoda. And you think RotJ Luke would lose... because he was trained by Yoda?

I like it when people smile. We should smile more on the internets.

😄

Anyway Starkiller in an ungodly stomp.

Yeah, Starkiller rolls with ridiculous ease.

Does he actually get training from Yoda?

From the scenes I've seen he just goes to Degobah meets Yoda, then goes into that DarkSide cave to have a vision. Id hardly call that training. Unless theres a scene I've missed??

Either way he destroys Luke as of ROTJ.

Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Does he actually get training from Yoda?

From the scenes I've seen he just goes to Degobah meets Yoda, then goes into that DarkSide cave to have a vision. Id hardly call that training. Unless theres a scene I've missed??

Either way he destroys Luke as of ROTJ.

the training montage with the rocks and the running. and yoda riding along.

Originally posted by truejedi
the training montage with the rocks and the running. and yoda riding along.

... 😐

He's talking about Starkiller... But yes, he did get training, one phrase of advice= training.

I see where the OP fails with his logic about Yoda's training though. 😄 😄 😄

Yes. The common sense around here is... lacking at times.

Anyways, Starkiller wins in a roflstomp.

Make it NJO Luke and we have a fight.

No, I meant to say that I feel Starkiller would win even though he AND Luke received training from Yoda. I apologize for my wording.

and Ok then, lets make it NJO Luke then. What do you all think? I personally don't know on this one, it's a bit close to call.

Well NJO Luke obviously wins this, as a weaker version of Luke was close to a much stronger version of Sidious who is more powerful than Starkiller.

Btw, Starkiller didn't get any training from Yoda.

..I guess I was wrong about the training then, sorry for the ignorance.

anyway, how do you get that Starkiller is weaker than Sidious? he pretty much went toe to toe against him when they fought on the Death Star until they got into the Force Lightning Lock and only lived because Kota stopped him from killing Sidious.

Theres a source that directly states that Starkiller is no match for the Emperor.

There's sources and visual proof. If Lucas tells me Starkiller is no match then I'm fine with that. but for now I stand by the fact of what I saw in The Force Unleashed.

Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
There's sources and visual proof. If Lucas tells me Starkiller is no match then I'm fine with that. but for now I stand by the fact of what I saw in The Force Unleashed.

I saw Palpatine holding back. What did you see?

Here is the source: Official Star Wars Databank

You may actually be surprised by this, but the databank trumps the games cutscene in canonicity.

Very well then, NJO Luke Wins. I stand corrected. *Bows* 😄 Thank you for your input.

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
Here is the source: Official Star Wars Databank

You may actually be surprised by this, but the databank trumps the games cutscene in canonicity.

The Star Wars databank says that Yoda culdnt beat Dooku on Geonosis.

Just saying 🙂

He couldn't. Thats why Dooku got away. 🙂