ROTS Sidious & ROTS Dooku vs TFU Marek & TFU Vader

Started by truejedi5 pages

Actually DE: Wookie is NOT a source, and you know this.

Secondly: Force push wouldn't work in space if it was just the air being moved.

A force push isn't a gust of air. If it was then you would see more than just the person get pushed by it.

I think there is a version of it that might be compressed air. There's a scene in the old Clone Wars cartoon where Greivous "dodges" a force push, and the spot that he was standing in a moment before he moves gets "hit" by it and depresses.

I always thought that was cool and at the same time retarded. How do you outrun the force?

well tk and that kind of force push are probably different.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
See I always thought (part in thanks to the video-games' animations), that a Force Push was a concentrated or semi-concentrated "ball" of Force energy that moved everything in it's path, the air included. Hence the "wind" effect.

I would go with that. Jedi use energy blast that also pushes the air in its way, not that they use air itself to push sth.

Originally posted by truejedi
Actually DE: Wookie is NOT a source, and you know this.

Secondly: Force push wouldn't work in space if it was just the air being moved.

I'm inclined to take their word above yours personally. They list their sources at the bottom.

When has anyone used a Force push in space?

StarWars.com does not appear to have a databank section on The Force. 😐

😐

facepalm2

Originally posted by Nephthys
I'm inclined to take their word above yours personally. They list their sources at the bottom.

When has anyone used a Force push in space?

Then you can list the source here... ?

Force push in space? The Jedi and their shadow-bombs? Pushing them into the enemy ships?

Originally posted by truejedi
Then you can list the source here... ?

Force push in space? The Jedi and their shadow-bombs? Pushing them into the enemy ships?

* Star Wars: Power of the Jedi (It might be in this one)
* The Jedi Academy Sourcebook
* Tales of the Jedi Companion
* "The Sith Compendium"—Star Wars Gamer 5
* Star Wars Gamemaster Screen, Revised
* Jedi vs. Sith: The Essential Guide to the Force (it might be in this one)
* Star Wars Roleplaying Game (First identification of Force Flight)
* The Dark Forces Saga [1]
* Star Wars Insider 87
* Hero's Guide
* Manaan: Depths of History on Wizards.com (original article link, backup links 1 2 on Archive.org, 1 2 on Google cache)
* "Classic Moment"—Star Wars Insider 101
* "Classic Moment"—Star Wars Insider 105
* "Ask Lobot"—Star Wars Insider 106
* "Sound Unleashed"—Star Wars Insider 106
* "Classic Moment"—Star Wars Insider 107
* The Clone Wars Campaign Guide
* The Complete Star Wars Encyclopedia (See Force grip) (it might be in this one)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – Champions of the Force (Card: Force Throw)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – Champions of the Force (Card: Force Choke)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – Champions of the Force (Card: Strangulation) (Picture only)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – Squadrons Over Corellia (Card: Grip)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – Galactic Hunters (Card: Grasp)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – The Shadow Syndicate (Card: Force Repulse)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – The Shadow Syndicate (Card: Telekinesis)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – The Shadow Syndicate (Card: Whirlwind)
* Star Wars Galaxies Trading Card Game – The Nightsister's Revenge (Card: Force Crush)
* The Jedi Path: A Manual for Students of the Force

😎

Thats just guiding them so that they hit. Manipulating the bombs. Its not a Force Push.

Originally posted by Nephthys
When has anyone used a Force push in space?

Plo Koon did in one of the episodes of CW, the one when clones and Koon escaped in a lifepod, and are attacked by a squad of droids. 😎

So are you saying that all of those sources say "A force push moving the air to hit an opponent?"

Found it. Episode "Rising Malevolence."
There is a nice force push in a vacuum of space.

See 5:05 and 6:10

http://fliiby.com/file/359287/g8h4rzmw67.html

Clearly force push is not a pressurized air, rather an energy blast.

well done axel. and in T-Canon too. : )

Yep, no way around it 😎

Originally posted by axel_jovan
Found it. Episode "Rising Malevolence."
There is a nice force push in a vacuum of space.

See 5:05 and 6:10

http://fliiby.com/file/359287/g8h4rzmw67.html

Clearly force push is not a pressurized air, rather an energy blast.

Who says he didn't redirect some of his "bodily functions".

💃

There is no indication that that was a Force push, it is just as likely Koon pulled the droid backwards or manipulated the droid directly.

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
Who says he didn't redirect some of his "bodily functions".

💃

Or simply manipulated the structure of the universe, so that there was an illusion that the droid is pushed, seems just as likely 😄

Originally posted by Nephthys
There is no indication that that was a Force push, it is just as likely Koon pulled the droid backwards or manipulated the droid directly.

There goes Occam's razor, eh?

Originally posted by axel_jovan
Or simply manipulated the structure of the universe, so that there was an illusion that the droid is pushed, seems just as likely 😄

That's possible indeed. Especially considering it's the PLO KOON.

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
That's possible indeed. Especially considering it's the PLO KOON.

👆

I would like the two sides of this argument to try to explain their position without using the phrase "force push." Explain exactly what you expect to happen, and then we'll be able to tell if you are arguing semantics (that is, arguing about what should qualify as a "Force Push"😉 or if there is an actual difference in expected result.

nah

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
That's possible indeed. Especially considering it's the PLO KOON.

Right on!

Originally posted by Zampanó
I would like the two sides of this argument to try to explain their position without using the phrase "force push." Explain exactly what you expect to happen, and then we'll be able to tell if you are arguing semantics (that is, arguing about what should qualify as a "Force Push"😉 or if there is an actual difference in expected result.

Originally posted by Nephthys
nah