Hogwarts Vs Anthony, Professor X, and Obiwan

Originally posted by Nephthys
🙄

Hogwarts only mate. OP has clarified. Just Hogwarts.

7) When the thread starter makes a new thread, it is very important to cement the conditions of the scenario in the first few posts. This is to avoid confusion and frustration among the other posters. It will not be acceptable for the thread starter to randomly change the conditions of the thread at random intervals. Once the settings/weapons/gear/handicaps/abilities/etc have been cemented in the first few posts of the thread, that is how they will stay. Therefore, be very sure and for certain of how you want your thread to be constructed.

When the thread starter makes a new thread, it is very important to cement the conditions of the scenario in the first few posts. It will not be acceptable for the thread starter to randomly change the conditions of the thread at random intervals. Once the settings/weapons/gear/handicaps/abilities/etc have been cemented in the first few posts of the thread, that is how they will stay.

We're damn near 6 pages in, far beyond a few posts. I am perfectly within my rights to choose that the fight takes place during GOF.

When the thread starter makes a new thread, it is very important to cement the conditions of the scenario in the first few posts. It will not be acceptable for the thread starter to randomly change the conditions of the thread at random intervals. Once the settings/weapons/gear/handicaps/abilities/etc have been cemented in the first few posts of the thread, that is how they will stay.

Emphasis mine. He isn't changing anything. He is just clarifying what the OP meant, that this is Hogwarts only. Nothing has changed.

We're damn near 6 pages in, far beyond a few posts. I am perfectly within my rights to choose that the fight takes place during GOF.

Bull. Shit. The thread starter doesn't get to choose the incarnation so you do? Lol, **** off with that shit! 😆

Originally posted by Nephthys
Emphasis mine. He isn't changing anything. He is just clarifying what the OP meant, that this is Hogwarts only. Nothing has changed.

Bull. Shit. The thread starter doesn't get to choose the incarnation so you do? Lol, **** off with that shit! 😆

No, the OP said "The Wizards in Hogwarts." Now that I have an argument that guarantees wizard victory, he decides to change it.

His fault for not being specific enough. His spite thread is now turned on him. Again.

No, the OP said "The Wizards in Hogwarts." Now that I have an argument that guarantees wizard victory, he decides to change it.

His fault for not being specific enough. His spite thread is now turned on him. Again.

No, its when we asked for clarification and when the topic became relevent.

And since when are dementor's wizards. 😉

No, seriously, you do not get to decide jack shit about this thread. Either the OP decides, a mod will, or we'll just have to accept that we won't have clarification.

Originally posted by Nephthys
No, its when we asked for clarification and when he topic became relevent.

And since when are dementor's wizards. 🙂

No, seriously, you do not get to decide jack shit about this thread. Either the OP decides, a mod will, or we'll just have to accept that we won't have clarification.

Clarification= Change. The OP is what it is.

If the mod decides to side with what you are saying, he'll be going against his own rules. Pretty sure he wouldn't, though, especially since this thread itself goes against forum rules.

Doesn't really matter, dementors are overkill. The hall of prophesies will warn of the attack and the wizards will have knowledge of the attack.

Clarification= Change. The OP is what it is.

If the mod decides to side with what you are saying, he'll be going against his own rules. Pretty sure he wouldn't, though, especially since this thread itself goes against forum rules.

No it isn't and no he won't. The very definition of clarification is to make an already existing object or idea clear and intelligible. Not changing anything, just clarifying.

Doesn't really matter, dementors are overkill. The hall of prophesies will warn of the attack and the wizards will have knowledge of the attack.

The wizards were not given prep.

When the thread starter makes a new thread, it is very important to cement the conditions of the scenario in the first few posts.

He didn't. He can clarify during the first few posts, not 6 pages in.

He failed to do so. He is now trying to clarify since I said it takes place during GOF, using high end screen feats, which is what we do here.

He started a HP spite thread and it got turned back on him, yet again.

When the thread starter makes a new thread, it is very important to cement the conditions of the scenario in the first few posts.

He did cement the bloody conditions. It's just you nitpicking the freaking wording of the OP and trying to gimp the thread in your favour. Again. The OP clearly says 'Hogwarts'. It does not say 'Hogwarts and 2 other fricking schools plus representatives of the ministry of magic and dementors.' Only Hogwarts. Just let it go and stop trying to gimp the thread to the only scenario where the wizards stand a chance. Let it go.

He failed to do so. He is now trying to clarify since I said it takes place during GOF, using high end screen feats, which is what we do here.

That isn't the high-end screen feats of Hogwarts. The real high-end feats would be in the sixth movie, as this is the incarnation in which the most spells have been revealed to the audience and are within the characters skillset and the movie in which Slughorn has an entire cauldron of Felix Felicus in his dungeon. That is the high-end screen feat of hogwarts. Your reasoning that GOF is the high-end is flawed because it isn't Hogwarts, getting the 'feats'. The other schools are completely seperate from Hogwarts as are the ministry representatives and the dementors. They are in no way affiliated with Hogwarts whatsoever.

j/k.

Nah.

You know, technically I'm right. Impediment, being the diplomatic mod of the people, will probably say the clarification is fine. But if we go by MVF rules, I'm right.

Moot point, Xavier can't mind rape someone on the other side of the world.

TROLL! TROLL IN THE FORUM!

Just thought you should know. *pretends to pass out on the floor*

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
You know, technically I'm right. Impediment, being the diplomatic mod of the people, will probably say the clarification is fine. But if we go by MVF rules, I'm right.

Moot point, Xavier can't mind rape someone on the other side of the world.

You're in the wrong here, RJ.

No, I'm not. Here's what happened...

Sadako started a spite thread.

We debated for 5 pages.

I took the OP and stated a way for the wizards to win.

sadako saw this, and altered the OP.

This is the precise reason Mattie decreed that the OP can be altered for only a few posts.

Dude all the Mac threads, the SW/HP threads YOU created or perpetuated needlessly from butthurt...?

You're the last person on earth to be able to level that statement at someone.

You just don't like it because this is another thread that the Wizards have been shown to be beaten in.
You dont like it because it shows how a man in a wheelchair, a boy and a Jedi that the boy pulled out of SW have just killed all the HP the wizards.
You dont like it because it shows the irrationality of your constant insistance that the Wizards trump anyone with real capability.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No, I'm not. Here's what happened...

Sadako started a spite thread.

We debated for 5 pages.

I took the OP and stated a way for the wizards to win.

sadako saw this, and altered the OP.

This is the precise reason Mattie decreed that the OP can be altered for only a few posts.

Not that the Internet would demand any less...

crylaugh And all you have to offer in the wizard threads is "The wizards were dead a long time ago."

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
You've got to admit though: your intense love of the Harry Potter universe (as stupid as it is) has a tendency to bring out a miasma of fanboyism and arrogance in you.

Not that the Internet would demand any less...

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Fanboyism? You do know that I love SW far more than HP, yes? Me thinking that wizards beat SW all day every day is literally the opposite of fanboyism.

Nope. I do say that but it was backed up by fact and agreed with by the majority of peers here.

Ratification and validation was got.

The notion that HP beats Sw was laughed at when looked at closely.
And rightly so.