Hogwarts vs G1 Transformers movie TFS

Originally posted by Placidity
If that potion literally does as described, it would've been the ultimate weapon, and as such I think would've been better guarded.

There is a weakness with the potion: if the user does not listen to the "perfect choice" then they can fail. So if the lucky voice prompts the person to go left but they, for whatever strange reason, go right, it fails.

So it is not infallible.

On top of that, it is "banned" from anything that would constitute cheating, it is very rare (apparently, extremely hard to make and it takes 6 months to do so and even slight failures can be very poisonous).

Finally, we really only have one vial of the potion ever seen. Out of all the crap that happened, only one existed. This speaks of its utter rarity. The three kids that took the rest of Potter's FF potion also survived an impossible situation against several death eaters: it should have been sure death for them but not a single spell made contact with them.

Finally, if it can be brewed and sold like nothing, then it speaks volumes about the one of many plot holes created by magical fiction stories.

Originally posted by Placidity
The point about there being a time limit doesn't work out. If I were Dumbles, I would just make it my goal to permanently wipe out all evil forever within minutes, and according to Slugboy, he would succeed.

Also, Slughorn is an idiot.

That should work, though. He could easily apparate to every single Death Eaters location and cast the killing curse and do so in less than a minute. That's exactly what the potion should allow him to do.

But herein lies a major CIS moment for Dumbles: he doesn't do that kind of stuff and he steers clear of most dark magic. The only instance I can think of, and it is just speculation (but strongly supported by the movie) is the Fiendfyre he seemingly cast in movie six against the zombies.

You should be able to think of a million and 1 other scenarios, just like that.

There's also the argument that felix felicis was being used by Volde and others during the war but they nulled each other.

LOLZ when Bombshell commands Voldemort to unleash the spell on the wizards

*LOL's even harder when Snape uses legilimens first*

Nah theyre crap at programming robotic beings.

"Besides Soundwave hears Snape thinking it and blasts him before he can act." is another perfectly good answer.

Yeah, RJ, even you have to see that legilimens won't work on a robot.

Actually there maybe a lot of their spells that won't work on them. After all Giants are able to take Wizard spells on essence of being extremely tough skinned.

Vanishing spells should work just fine. Transfiguration.

And you can prove that?

Do you even know what they are?

The spells or the Transformers?

Vanishing spells (The art of vanishing something. I know, I can see how you would think I'd struggle to grasp that concept.) havn't vanished anything bigger than a rat in the movies. Transfiguration (To transform, or transfigure something.) has never worked on anything as large or as durable as a Transformer.

Transformers are robots obviously.

Originally posted by Nephthys
The spells or the Transformers?

Vanishing spells havn't vanished anything bigger than a rat in the movies. Transfiguration has never worked on anything as large or as durable as a Transformer.

OK, that's gonna be the way it is?

K. Was this mind raping TF ever shown consuming Earth?

No. Probably because Unicron is the planet eater, and doesn't mindrape people.

And what, exactly, makes you think that a wizard will have trouble vanishing or changing them? Or freezing them with Immobulus?

They're too big and durable. And probably too strong to be held by Immobulus.

This entire conversation is pointless btw, the wizards have nothing to combat Unicron. Do you need me to post him eating a planet again?

Originally posted by Nephthys
They're too big and durable. And probably too strong to be held by Immobulus.

This entire conversation is pointless btw, the wizards have nothing to combat Unicron. Do you need me to post him eating a planet again?

So the TF's can't take the wizards on toe to toe, directly, so they attack with some planet eating thing? They have to destroy the planet to win? Funny, the thread isn't titled "TF vs Earth."

There are no stipulations that they cannot destroy earth while battling Hogwarts. Unicron om nom nom's tonight!

And Unicron is a Transformer. So obviously Transformer's >>> Wizards.

So like I said, the TF's can't take the wizards on toe to toe, directly, so they attack with some planet eating thing?

That "Some planet eating thing" is a Transformer.

Ergo its still a TF kicking ass Hand to Hand. 🙂

YouTube video

Mhm, and CQC it gets vanished by a fourth year.

In Close Quarter Combat it punches through the planet. 😬

And bullshit can something larger than a planet get vanished! Ron struggled to vanish a bloody rat, no way is anyone making anything more than Unicron's big toe go a shade paler.