Shiva better in skills.... but Cap's overall better and he will win.
RAD
Radarock1971Member
i say shiva because even batman has stated she might be the best fighter alive and in the amalgam comics batman beats cap and batman never beat shiva
JOE
joesha28Asgard's Advocate
Don't take crossovers as a fact... crossovers... superman and Bat never loses... cos DC won't let them
TRI
TricksterPriestRenegade Timelord
Let me put it this way. Can Cap beat Iron Fist in a straight fistfight? Can Cap beat Iron Fist in a fight where he has his shield?
And.........I honestly don't know either way. Just like this fight. Shiva is among the best on DC earth in terms of martial arts. I think it's too hard to call.
JOE
joesha28Asgard's Advocate
To answer ur question...Cap can beat Iron Fist with or without his shield thanks to his sss...unless Iron Fist amps himself.
TRI
TricksterPriestRenegade Timelord
No. Iron Fist beat Cap, while he was exhausted.
DDD
Dum Dum DuganSenior Member
Originally posted by TricksterPriest No. Iron Fist beat Cap, while he was exhausted.
He dident beat capt.
Not sure how IF is relevent, he would destroy Shiva.
Q99
Q99Senior Member
Shield or no shield?
DDD
Dum Dum DuganSenior Member
Captain America wins shield or not, though he wins a lot more solidly with the shield.
PRE
Prep-ManSenior Member
Probably with shield.
DDD
Dum Dum DuganSenior Member
If Capt has the shield, I dont really see how anyone could argue shiva the majority.
PRE
Prep-ManSenior Member
Is this a dojo type setting?
DDD
Dum Dum DuganSenior Member
if not stated, it assumed it a featureless environment
BUS
BUSTER1Senior Member
I say Cap ftw. Shiva may be regarded as the most skilled MA on DC Earth, but Cap has also been described as the Marvel Earth's best fighter. So skill wise they're on the same level-but Steve has better stats, because of the SS and this will give him the edge.
SM
Silent MasterSenior Member
Originally posted by TricksterPriest No. Iron Fist beat Cap, while he was exhausted.
No, he didn't.
DAR
Daredevil1Senior Member
Originally posted by Silent Master No, he didn't.
Your right. IIRC Cap had the advantage on Pre-power up Danny. As for this fight I think due to Cap's heavy stat set and high skill set.
Cap 6-7/10.
RAD
Radarock1971Member
Cap isnt necessarily a better fighter because shiva actually knows deadly techniques while cap doesnt kill
RAD
Radarock1971Member
With or without the shield i say it doesnt matter because shes faced deadly masters and learned new techniques from them one by one while cap remained the same
JUK
Juk3nDevils Advocate
Originally posted by Radarock1971 With or without the shield i say it doesnt matter because shes faced deadly masters and learned new techniques from them one by one while cap remained the same
by the 'same' i'll just assume you mean 'the best'