Originally posted by ares834
Yeah, I've heard of these scales before. IIRC he also gave Mace Windu a 9. Regardless, I don't know what he gave Obi-Wan, but I agree with you. Anakin was surely winning most of the fight hence why I called the battle a "major upset". Still, Kenobi held his own against Anakin and while I think he would usually lose a battle it would clearly take awhile.
No, he gave Mace an "outside the scale" rating. My take on that was Mace is generally as strong as his opponents due to Form VII. There would be a limit to that, IMO. I don't think he could just become as strong as anyone no matter how strong...that doesn't make sense.
Other than that, yeah: Anakin losing doesn't make much sense...but Neph explained it and it makes more sense as that ties in perfectly with Anakin acting like a retard right at the very end.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Report away, I was kidding.
This was like...the same exact reason that was given you were banned, last time. To paraphrase, even joking, it's not acceptable. However, I think we are adults and we should be able to say whatever we want as long as the intended recipient is okay with it.
But a report threat about an insult to Nephthys? Yeah right: there's no way he'd report. I think he was just joking because of how gigantically hypocritical it would be.
Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
No one is giving Maul any respect. He held his own against two Jedi, dude.
respect is one thing. adoration and highballing is another.
it was an obi-wan inferior to the current one and qui gon, whose skills were only tested in those two fights.
being a jedi doesn't automatically make you a wizard with a lightsaber. Look at the other episodes...
Originally posted by -Pr-
being a jedi doesn't automatically make you a wizard with a lightsaber. Look at the other episodes...
I disagree. That's exactly what it means. You're obviously speaking in relative terms to other Jedi and I'm speaking in absolute (technically, it's all relative terms) terms.
Originally posted by Nephthys
I think he meant GG as in Good Game.