Comic book battles

Surfer vs supes is tough. If he's acting as an invader I see him winning first time around and supes coming back for round two and it looks like a thanos vs. surfer glass jaw moment. On the reverse if it was just an encounter in Marvel I see glass jaw surfer on a chance encounter with a "transdimensional" being coming through getting clocked in the jaw which has that damn power cosmic bug where it turns into softer materials. They fight for a while but eventually talk and resolve the situation. Either way Surfer will not preform at his best because honestly I don't see him taking a physical fight with supes in comic and because it's superman they won't dick him out with a solar energy/kryptonite drain so Surfer fights handicapped.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Thor
Hulk
Spider-Man
Superman
Gladiator
Depends on writer
Batman
Captain America
Superman

Each character will "find a way" if they don't just win straight up, which some of them can.

Only thing I outright disagree with is Glads beating Wonder Woman.

I don't think that would happen ever. Gladiator is a B list character. Wonder Woman is B List in reader relevancy but easily A List in importance and in icon status.

Batman beating Wolverine is iffy too. But that's like 50/50 as their popularity is somewhat comparable in conjunction with Wolverine's outright physical superiority, which would ensure that Bruce would not lose face even if he lost.

WW is like D list.

She has Ds that's for sure.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Pretty much.

IIRC he said would have Thor win if he were writing Thor's book at the time, and would have Orion win if he were scripting that character instead.

basically.

Originally posted by carver9
If these fights were in a comic... who do you think would win?

Thor vs Orion
HP Doomsday vs Hulk
Spiderman vs Deathstroke
Superman vs Surfer
Wonder Woman vs Gladiator
Darkseid vs Thanos
Wolverine vs Batman
Deathstroke vs Captain America
Superman vs Sentry (no void)

How would these fight turn out in a comic and how do you think each would win?

Depends on the writer. And the pis he feels like today

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Only thing I outright disagree with is Glads beating Wonder Woman.

I don't think that would happen ever. Gladiator is a B list character. Wonder Woman is B List in reader relevancy but easily A List in importance and in icon status.

Batman beating Wolverine is iffy too. But that's like 50/50 as their popularity is somewhat comparable in conjunction with Wolverine's outright physical superiority, which would ensure that Bruce would not lose face even if he lost.

I could just see them Worf-effecting Diana to show how tough Gladiator is. In a straight up fight I could see him giving her trouble too.

Logan's physical superiority is all well and good, but it's not like Batman hasn't faced anything like that before. Added to the fact that Bruce winning leaves both men better off than Logan winning, at least imo.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Thor
Hulk
Spider-Man
Superman
Gladiator
Depends on writer
Batman
Captain America
Superman

Each character will "find a way" if they don't just win straight up, which some of them can.

Thor
HP Doomsday
Deathstroke
Superman
Wonder Woman
Darkseid vs Thanos. Could go either way
Batman
Captain America
Superman

Thor vs Orion
I think this battle would take place in asgard. Like orion coming out of nowhere with a boomtube then they just go at it. Lot of Asgard turns to rubble but after a insane fight Thor wins.

HP Doomsday vs Hulk
They fight in Metropolis, Would imo beat the piss out of hulk until DD does some move where Hulk gets pushed away. But then Hulk comes back madder than ever and is healing nearly as fast as DD if delivering the blows. Not sure how it will end but Hulk will win.

Spiderman vs Deathstroke
I think Deathstroke will smack him around for a bit but i think parker will start using his brain and beat Deathstroke some how.

Superman vs Surfer
Both would be resistant to get into a fight. I think the fight takes place in space. Supes imo will get the upperhand in the beginning but when surfer starts to falter he will start pulling out the big guns intense energy blasts and mind****ing and other exotic shit. But imo i think it would be a inconclusive fight.

Wonder Woman vs Gladiator
Gladiator would win but I think they will have WW pulling every trick in the book but still losing. If glad does lose it would be some bs with the lasso.

Darkseid vs Thanos
Thanos

Wolverine vs Batman
Batman would win via some environmental method. Like kicking wolverine in front of a train or something.

Deathstroke vs Captain America
Captain, it would be a sweet fight just straight up asskicking.

Superman vs Sentry (no void)
Superman Bests him but Sentry puts up a mighty good fight.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I could just see them Worf-effecting Diana to show how tough Gladiator is. In a straight up fight I could see him giving her trouble too.

Logan's physical superiority is all well and good, but it's not like Batman hasn't faced anything like that before. Added to the fact that Bruce winning leaves both men better off than Logan winning, at least imo.

-I don't. She's a herald leveler. And a woman at that. It's politically correct to give her the win especially against someone who isn't remotely important like Gladiator.

-And it's not like Logan doesn't regularly face people above Batman or even himself either. When the popularity disparity is not huge--and it isn't here at all, the most realistic person to win in a comic is the one who realistically has the most advantages.

I'm not sure how you reckon Bruce winning leaves them both better off either.

(p.s. why did you call it a fact and then say imo?)

Originally posted by Lord Feron
Thor vs Orion
I think this battle would take place in asgard. Like orion coming out of nowhere with a boomtube then they just go at it. Lot of Asgard turns to rubble but after a insane fight Thor wins.

HP Doomsday vs Hulk
They fight in Metropolis, Would imo beat the piss out of hulk until DD does some move where Hulk gets pushed away. But then Hulk comes back madder than ever and is healing nearly as fast as DD if delivering the blows. Not sure how it will end but Hulk will win.

Spiderman vs Deathstroke
I think Deathstroke will smack him around for a bit but i think parker will start using his brain and beat Deathstroke some how.

Superman vs Surfer
Both would be resistant to get into a fight. I think the fight takes place in space. Supes imo will get the upperhand in the beginning but when surfer starts to falter he will start pulling out the big guns intense energy blasts and mind****ing and other exotic shit. But imo i think it would be a inconclusive fight.

Wonder Woman vs Gladiator
Gladiator would win but I think they will have WW pulling every trick in the book but still losing. If glad does lose it would be some bs with the lasso.

Darkseid vs Thanos
Thanos

Wolverine vs Batman
Batman would win via some environmental method. Like kicking wolverine in front of a train or something.

Deathstroke vs Captain America
Captain, it would be a sweet fight just straight up asskicking.

Superman vs Sentry (no void)
Superman Bests him but Sentry puts up a mighty good fight.

Good post.

I pictured these fight while reading your post. I also agree with Glads but lately Marvel has been giving him some major props... can't really see him losing to many physical fights, especially with everything Marvel has been writing about him recently.

Originally posted by carver9
Good post.

I pictured these fight while reading your post. I also agree with Glads but lately Marvel has been giving him some major props... can't really see him losing to many physical fights, especially with everything Marvel has been writing about him recently.

Unless of course Glads gets in the way of Thanos and his plans.. then you will seem him swatted away like a flee. Against most heralds.. you're right.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Thor
Hulk
Spider-Man
Superman
Gladiator
Depends on writer
Batman
Captain America
Superman

Each character will "find a way" if they don't just win straight up, which some of them can.

only thing i'd add is the thanos/darkseid thing might be a stalemate so nobody loses face...matterfact the superman/silver surfer one would be like that also (or surfer wins), the fanboys would flood the mailroom about that

edit* wonder woman would beat gladiator

Originally posted by CosmicComet

Batman beating Wolverine is iffy too. But that's like 50/50 as their popularity is somewhat comparable in conjunction with Wolverine's outright physical superiority, which would ensure that Bruce would not lose face even if he lost.

Wolverine can win simply by cornering Batman and doing the ole middle claw tease while Bat's head is stuck against a wall and give a threatening talk routine.

the "do you feel lucky punk?" routine happening to batman would be breaking some sort of rule, batman does that to people, he doesn't receive it. (pause)

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Unless of course Glads gets in the way of Thanos and his plans.. then you will seem him swatted away like a flee. Against most heralds.. you're right.

Thanos gets treated like all of the other Heralds gets treated when facing Glads. Get that ass whipped.

Originally posted by carver9
Thanos gets treated like all of the other Heralds gets treated when facing Glads. Get that ass whipped.

Originally posted by carver9
Thanos gets treated like all of the other Heralds gets treated when facing Glads. Get that ass whipped.

Originally posted by -Pr-
I could just see them Worf-effecting Diana to show how tough Gladiator is. In a straight up fight I could see him giving her trouble too.

Logan's physical superiority is all well and good, but it's not like Batman hasn't faced anything like that before. Added to the fact that Bruce winning leaves both men better off than Logan winning, at least imo.