Darth traya vs yoda

Nephthys
Except from, y'know, not being from her perspective in the slightest.

Were you and Zampano recently anointed by Borbarad as Most Esteemed Arbiters of Canon, those imbued with the power to establish, reestablish, or undo continuity by sheer fiat?

If so, I'm really jealous.

Anyways, as you point out: The narration is clearly from her perspective. Why would the images be any different?

In comics narration and imagery can be so far apart that its absurd. Like when Spiderman's narrating about what a wonderful day it is and then it transitions to his house getting bombed, or Aunt May getting kidnapped. Obviously that isn't from his perspective, because he's on the other sith of the city, but the narration is.

Originally posted by Nephthys
In comics narration and imagery can be so far apart that its absurd.

Thank you for explaining what is possible in the comic book world. Now, if you'd be so kind as to provide evidence as to why this is the case here other than your say-so.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Also I don't have to prove they aren't from her perspective, you need to prove they are.

I don't have to do anything other than defeat your points. You say the narration makes it all from her perspective, I show why that not true. Try again.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I don't have to do anything other than defeat your points. You say the narration makes it all from her perspective, I show why that not true. Try again.

No, you show why it might not be from her perspective. To which I counter why it might.

What you fail to grasp is that our roles are reversed: You want to use the comic as incontrovertible proof. All I need do is cast doubt on it.

Mission accomplished.

No, you show why it might not be from her perspective. To which I counter why it might.

You'll need to do better than that it 'might' be. The entire of KOTOR 2 might be one huge fever dream and be totally non-canon. Are you going to ask me to prove that that isn't the case? 😬

What you fail to grasp is that our roles are reversed: You want to use the comic as incontrovertible proof. All I need do is cast doubt on it.

Yeah, no. I have actual visual proof. Thats as much proof as I need. You need to prove thats faulty. I don't need to prove it isn't. Again, see above example.

Your visual proof is nonexistent. The visuals in the comic follow/match with Visas's narration. Suffice it to say, this simply could be the product of her imagination; her mind's depiction of the devastation on Katarr.

Your visual proof is nonexistent. The visuals in the comic follow/match with Visas's narration.

But not her perspective.

Suffice it to say, this simply could be the product of her imagination; her mind's depiction of the devastation on Katarr.

Again with the baseless speculation.

Originally posted by Nephthys
But not her perspective.

Nephthys
Again with the baseless speculation.

Oh, life's little ironies. 😂

😂

I guess she was actually in space looking at the planet when it happened then huh? The images are not from her viewpoint.

I wish KOTOR had been like fallout where your companions can actually die. That always made that game seem more real.

Originally posted by Nephthys
😂

I guess she was actually in space looking at the planet when it happened then huh? The images are not from her viewpoint.

Me
The fact that the images depict events/occurrences that Visas is not perceiving does not preclude the possibility that the images are simply depicting what she's imagining.

I guess people can only imagine that which is directly in front of their eyes. 😂

The fact that the images depict events/occurrences that Visas is not perceiving does not preclude the possibility that the images are simply depicting what she's imagining.

Again with the baseless speculation.

Oh I love the reasoning sometimes.

"Sidious can whip up a Force storm on his toes because he said he could"

"Visas and Traya are entirely unreliable and full of bullshit."

Selective with our sources much?

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
"Visas and Traya are entirely unreliable and full of bullshit."

Who in the world said that?

Originally posted by Stealth Moose
Oh I love the reasoning sometimes.

"Sidious can whip up a Force storm on his toes because he said he could"

"Visas and Traya are entirely unreliable and full of bullshit."

Selective with our sources much?

But Sidious proved how fast he can whip one up, which was right after Luke chopped his hand off. I am guessing it happened instantly since it had began devouring entire capital ships before Luke and Leia looked out to fleet.

BTW Gideon, what would having Unseen, Unheard be from Visas' perspective achieve exactly?

Without Unseen, Unheard, you can't really prove how long it took for N. to drain the entire planet.

And making it from her perspective cpmpletely vaporises the source does it? 😬

It puts the source in question.