Darth Maul and Darth Sidious vs. Jedi Galen Marek and Rots Obi Wan

Who wins?

Palpatine would floor Obi-Wan and Marek would overwhelm Maul. Leaving Palpatine to once again mop up Marek. Sith win.

Or, Palpatine would slowly work down Marek (again), while Obi-Wan eventually defeats Maul. Obi pulls a Deus Ex out of his utility belt and throws his lightsaber at Palpatine before he can deliver a mortal blow to Marek, who subsequently uses the distraction to surprise-stab/zap Palpatine in to death/submission.

If it's the latter, Obi-Wan pulls a Kota and advises him not to kill Palpatine, and the Force Unleashed ending happens all over again.

The later as of above.I think ob1 would kill maul allowing him to aid Galen who was keeping palpatine at bay(according to force unleash game play 1)But from there I cannot say.ob1 is defensive while marek is offensive.This will be a hard chioce...

It really depends which version of Sids is this.

If it's RotS Sidious, then this is a close match-up (though I give an edge to the Sith team).
If this is OT+ Sidious, Sith win handily.

^ 👆

This is a good match. I'd probably give ROTS a slight edge over Marek and the same (or larger, wtevr) for Obi-Wan over Maul.

Yeah, definately depends upon which incarnation this is.

This is clearly Sidious as he was at ten years old, in which case Obi-Wan scolds him for using a lightsaber, and Marek gets killed by Maul.

Whether Obi Wan was around to assist GM or not doesn't matter. Kenobi is a complete non-factor when it comes to dealing with Sidious. Sidious was clearly toying w/ GM in their duel on the Death Star - any time Sidious chooses to end GM, he will.

....... If its OT Sidious.

^ I concur.

I don't see RotS Sidious toying with SK.
Sids will ultimately win, but not as easily as his older, more powerful self.

All-out: Sith team wins.

I could see Marek ragdolling Maul with the Force and Sidious doing the same to Obi-Wang.

Whcih will lead to Sids vs. Marek once again, which Sids will eventually win.

I'm going with the Jedi. Close match though.

As stated before, Obi Wan in a non-factor for Sidious (RotS OR OT).

Especially OT.

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
As stated before, Obi Wan in a non-factor for Sidious (RotS OR OT).

Why? Sids would win handily but I'm not sure why he should be destroyed in seconds.

IMO Starkiller also would be able to effortlessly destroy Maul.

Also if Starkiller engages Sids and Maul engages Kenobi I don't see the Sith escaping that one alive. Sk should be able to hold of Sids until Kenobi finshes of Maul at which case the two double team Sids.

Originally posted by ares834
Why? Sids would win handily but I'm not sure why he should be destroyed in seconds.

IMO Starkiller also would be able to effortlessly destroy Maul.

Also if Starkiller engages Sids and Maul engages Kenobi I don't see the Sith escaping that one alive. Sk should be able to hold of Sids until Kenobi finshes of Maul at which case the two double team Sids.

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
Obi Wan's inability to defend against Sidious' FL and TK attacks will render him a non-factor.

When has Sidious ever resorted to TK immediatly upon entering a fight? Also Kenobi is shown to have the abilty to defend against lightning, Sidious would be able to eventually overcome him but not immediatly.

First of all, he doesn't have to resort to TK as soon as the fight begins, but I'll tell you that whenever he chooses to do so, Kenobi is gone.

Second, Dooku's FL =/= Sidious' FL. While not a gimme, I'd surmise that Kenobi would have FAR greater trouble holding off Sidious' FL than he would have w/ Dooku.

Third, Kenobi STILL has done nothing to indicate (to me at least) that he can defend against Sidious' swordplay.

Windu could barely hold back Sidious' FL. I doubt the physically and Force strengthally inferior Kenobi could so much as replicate that.

Originally posted by Jinsoku Takai
[B]First of all, he doesn't have to resort to TK as soon as the fight begins, but I'll tell you that whenever he chooses to do so, Kenobi is gone.

In which case Kenobi would not be a non-factor.

Second, Dooku's FL =/= Sidious' FL. While not a gimme, I'd surmise that Kenobi would have FAR greater trouble holding off Sidious' FL than he would have w/ Dooku.

Sure. Which is why I said he would eventually be overcome.

Third, Kenobi STILL has done nothing to indicate (to me at least) that he can defend against Sidious' swordplay.

Kenobi is perhaps the most skilled maste rof Soresu ever. He also managed to take on AniVader in a fight. Sidious will defeat him but it's not going to be instantly.