Sentinel Alan Scott vs. Thanos

Started by Starscream M6 pages

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I don't think Thanos could have owned the combined JLA/JSA rosters as efficiently as Alan did.
it really depends on the plot. plot often dictates how well someone does.

Originally posted by Naija boy
lulz, actually saying what happened on-panel=/= to downplaying. Im actually giving details of what happened as opposed to *he owned the JSA* (the line up wasnt exactly awe inspiring... ) bypassing the actual details of the fight and expecting it to mean something. He was put down by an attack that many herald levellers would shrug off....let alone someone on the level of thanos. To use Alan's fight with him as a basis for him beating thanos is far fetched to say the least.
Nicely done. You owned him.

Originally posted by Starscream M
it really depends on the plot. plot often dictates how well someone does.

In Alan's case, he tapped into a larger portion of the Starheart than he had ever had before. Considering he's since tamed that choatic energy and is literally the most powerful he's ever been, I don't think Thanos is going to have an easy time with him at all. Even non-Sentinel Alan has incredible feats to justify him fighting Thanos in a prolonged battle.

Originally posted by nimbus006
Thanos's energy blasts have put down Galactus (briefly), Surfer, and Thor, and impressed the hell out of Odin.

His shields have withstood blasts from Galactus, Surfer, and Magus

He's matched strength with Drax, Champion, Hulk, and Thor.

He's durable enough to take shots from Odin, Galactus, Mar-vell, Hulk, Fallen etc...

My vote goes to Thanos for majority.

Sentinel possibly takes 1-2/10.

The only ones of those who wouldn't get stomped by Sentinel Alan are Galactus and Odin. And "impressing" Odin is not necessarily an impressive feat.

Alan takes the majority, but definitely not 10/10

Originally posted by Cogito
The only ones of those who wouldn't get stomped by Sentinel Alan are Galactus and Odin. And "impressing" Odin is not necessarily an impressive feat.

Alan takes the majority, but definitely not 10/10

I believe Magus should be included in that list.

Surfer would also put up a decent fight against Alan, although he would lose.

And my point was that he's taken on the best at their respective "games", so to speak, (physical shots from Hulk, Thor and Champion, energy blasts from Galactus, Surfer and Odin etc...) and come out on top, for the most part.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I don't think Thanos could have owned the combined JLA/JSA rosters as efficiently as Alan did.

I don't think Alan would've lasted as long as Thanos did against Odin or Tyrant.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
I don't think Thanos could have owned the combined JLA/JSA rosters as efficiently as Alan did.

I agree with you there,...if it was Thanos most of them would have ended up dead.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
I don't think Alan would've lasted as long as Thanos did against Odin or Tyrant.

Considering Alan tends to hang with Mordru, I'd say he has a decent shot.

Alan nowadays would beat Thanos. 6 or 7/10. His battle with JLA/JSA, Scythe, and Mordru proves he can hang with Thanos.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
In Alan's case, he tapped into a larger portion of the Starheart than he had ever had before. Considering he's since tamed that choatic energy and is literally the most powerful he's ever been, I don't think Thanos is going to have an easy time with him at all. Even non-Sentinel Alan has incredible feats to justify him fighting Thanos in a prolonged battle.

Do you know how many people that Thanos would annihilate that has soloed the entire JLA? That's not a valid argument. Despero soloed the jla as well and he would get his wind pipe crushed by Thanos.

That's not a good argument. What else ya got?

Like who?

Originally posted by carver9
Do you know how many people that Thanos would annihilate that has soloed the entire JLA? That's not a valid argument. Despero soloed the jla as well and he would get his wind pipe crushed by Thanos.

That's not a good argument. What else ya got?

Enlighten me, Carv.

Despero would get his windpiped crushed by Thanos? The same one who fought off Cap and Superman and Power Girl with sheer physical might?

Originally posted by carver9
Do you know how many people that Thanos would annihilate that has soloed the entire JLA? That's not a valid argument. Despero soloed the jla as well and he would get his wind pipe crushed by Thanos.

That's not a good argument. What else ya got?

This is more appropriate...

Originally posted by Prep-Man
This is more appropriate...

This hand surely looks like Carvers... 😄

Hahahah!

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Enlighten me, Carv.

Despero would get his windpiped crushed by Thanos? The same one who fought off Cap and Superman and Power Girl with sheer physical might?

You mean that same despero that in the same arc.. got one shot ko'd by Supermans HV? Lets face it despero's durability is far below thanos.. Despero brings other tools to the table i.e. TP, Strength, h2h combat skills that makes it a good fight. However, lets not kid ourselves here.. Thanos wins that fight because his durability is above Despero's with many other things being pretty close or equal.

Thanos at least 7/10 .

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
You mean that same despero that in the same arc.. got one shot ko'd by Supermans HV? Lets face it despero's durability is far below thanos.. Despero brings other tools to the table i.e. TP, Strength, h2h combat skills that makes it a good fight. However, lets not kid ourselves here.. Thanos wins that fight because his durability is above Despero's with many other things being pretty close or equal.

And nothing about Thanos or that same Despero suggest that Thanos is going to shit all over him or "crush his windpipe". It's just Carv being Carv.

Originally posted by Nihilist
Thanos at least 7/10 .

👆

With full access of the Starheart? How does Thanos win?