Sentinel Alan Scott vs. Thanos

I know he can't die, but he can still be KO'd. Alan has the power to do it.

Originally posted by Galan007
Worst. Argument. Ever.

Originally posted by Galan007
Worst. Argument. Ever.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
The "he can't die argument"? I would agree because I'm pretty sure by rules that temp death would still count.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
The "he can't die argument"?

Thanos wins by having a greater output, being more physically formidable( strength and durability) and overall more powerful. Not by the sole fact that he is deaths avatar.

its true just the same

Originally posted by Naija boy
Thanos wins by having a greater output, being more physically formidable( strength and durability) and overall more powerful. Not by the sole fact that he is deaths avatar.

having more output is debatable since we havent seen alans true potential. he always holds back. he just built an entire city on the moon and can manipulate time. alan right now is on a whole nother level.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
With full access of the Starheart? How does Thanos win?

not convinced.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
not convinced.

Originally posted by 753
facepalm maelstrom, the avatar of oblivion, identified drax as an avatar of life. lord mar-vell, another life avatar, felt drax's death in the cancerverse and referred to him as an avatar of life.

all abstracts can be said to warp reality

thanos has zero feats implying he has abstract level power or "death's power".

Its not hard to understand that that only reason they was killed was because death had returned ie Thanos.

lol

Originally posted by quanchi112
Who's the most powerful person Alan has beaten ?

He gave Mordru some trouble. That's pretty impressive, considering even any given Legion of Super Heros roster struggles against him (And I highly doubt Thanos can take a good LOSH team..)

Originally posted by Naija boy
Thanos wins by having a greater output, being more physically formidable( strength and durability) and overall more powerful. Not by the sole fact that he is deaths avatar.

This.

I think it's a great fight, but ultimately, Thanos wins.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
having more output is debatable since we havent seen alans true potential. he always holds back. he just built an entire city on the moon and can manipulate time. alan right now is on a whole nother level.

Just as the "he can't die argument" is really bad.

So is the "we haven't seen his true potential argument" 🙁

I'd probably give the nod to Thanos here. Both have about the same power output--even though Alan has a larger well to draw from in the Starheart and could potentially tap into more. Thanos' shielding is going to be indispensable here, and that, combined with his durability, should allow him to take a slight majority, 6/10 or so.

Originally posted by Nihilist
Are you thick? i never said he had abstract lvl power, he did have the power of death proven we he killed things that couldnt die as there was no death at all in their universe and life had won.

Its not hard to understand that that only reason they was killed was because death had returned ie Thanos.

Originally posted by Harbinger
I'd probably give the nod to Thanos here. Both have about the same power output--even though Alan has a larger well to draw from in the Starheart and could potentially tap into more. Thanos' shielding is going to be indispensable here, and that, combined with his durability, should allow him to take a slight majority, 6/10 or so.

I could see Alan getting through the shields through some magical attack.