Sentinel Alan Scott vs. Thanos

Started by Nihilist6 pages

Originally posted by Prep-Man
I could see Alan getting through the shields through some magical attack.
And then doing what exactly?

Ko through the Starheart. Back when Alan was new, he mentioned he could probably destroy the solar system. He's much more powerful now.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
Ko through the Starheart. Back when Alan was new, he mentioned he could probably destroy the solar system. He's much more powerful now.
Starlord could only just ko a badly weakand Thanos with a cosmic cube, so i doubt Alan could with the Starheart(and going on what people said, it was stated the cube still had enough power to make Starlord God.

You could say Alan was god like as well. Starheart so far has no limits to its power. Starheart vs cosmic cube would be an interesting thought.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
You could say Alan was god like as well. Starheart so far has no limits to its power. Starheart vs cosmic cube would be an interesting thought.
God like! the cube makes you God of the universe like when Thanos was the universe with the cube.

And all the energy/magic the Starheart can draw could make him just as powerful. Has Thanos ever harmed someone that was intangible?

Originally posted by Nihilist
Starlord could only just ko a badly weakand Thanos with a cosmic cube, so i doubt Alan could with the Starheart(and going on what people said, it was stated the cube still had enough power to make Starlord God.

The cube was just about burned out, good for only "one or two shots, maybe" according to Starlord, and they never show the fight (Unless there's new material, but it doesn't happen in the Thanos Imperative series.)

Originally posted by Prep-Man
And all the energy/magic the Starheart can draw could make him just as powerful. Has Thanos ever harmed someone that was intangible?
A weaker Thanos clone one shotted Vision tryin to go intangable on him.
Originally posted by cdtm
The cube was just about burned out, good for only "one or two shots, maybe" according to Starlord, and they never show the fight (Unless there's new material, but it doesn't happen in the Thanos Imperative series.)
That was at the end of Imperative, im talking about when he hit him with the cubes power in Thanos Imperative:Ignition

He might be able to do it to Alan, but Alan has far greater power than Vision.

Originally posted by Prep-Man
He might be able to do it to Alan, but Alan has far greater power than Vision.
And that clone was far weaker than the real Thanos

Alan Scott can just trap Thanos in a time loop or freeze time.

In Crisis Times Five he used the green flame to speed up time on a race and watched it evolve and go into extinction in less time then it takes to finish a cup of coffee.

Alan can draw on various magic, right? He can tap into Fate's spells, Zatanna's, etc... Alan has more choices than Thanos, I believe.

The only thing that I am seeing about Alan is nothing but "if" and potential. What has he actually done on panel to suggest that he could beat Thanos?

Originally posted by Prep-Man
Alan can draw on various magic, right? He can tap into Fate's spells, Zatanna's, etc... Alan has more choices than Thanos, I believe.

Er, not really. The Starheart is the conduit for DC magic, and arguably its strongest magical presence, but can't actively tap other powers. He's not Black Alice with a power ring, after all.

Originally posted by carver9
The only thing that I am seeing about Alan is nothing but "if" and potential. What has he actually done on panel to suggest that he could beat Thanos?

He's got enough to make it a conversation. A couple ridiculous raw power feats, legit teambuster status, etc. Personally I don't think he'd pull it off, but that's me. Despite being among his biggest fans on KMC, I've never been at the very front of the Alan power level bandwagon.

Originally posted by Nihilist
That was at the end of Imperative, im talking about when he hit him with the cubes power in Thanos Imperative:Ignition

They didn't show that fight either, and Quill claimed it could barely stun Thanos because it was so drained.

Originally posted by cdtm
Alan Scott can just trap Thanos in a time loop or freeze time.

In Crisis Times Five he used the green flame to speed up time on a race and watched it evolve and go into extinction in less time then it takes to finish a cup of coffee.

Scans of alan freezing time on an opponent ever? Surfer was able to suspend a woman in time by encasing her in a floating cosmic limbo, but in a CIS on battle this would not be a tactic that i would use to give him the win against thanos.

Additionally most of the stuff brought forth on the Alan side has been speculative or far fetched extrapolation.

Thanos kills him.

Originally posted by carver9 The only thing that I am seeing about Alan is nothing but "if" and potential. What has he actually done on panel to suggest that he could beat Thanos?

hang with mordru. and mordru would destroy thanos.

Originally posted by cdtm
They didn't show that fight either, and Quill claimed it could barely stun Thanos because it was so drained.

They showed the fight in Guardians of the Galaxy. Gamora commented that Starlord could of used the cube to be god.

Originally posted by Naija boy
Scans of alan freezing time on an opponent ever?

Don't you mean, scans of Alan freezing time in any situation, in or outside of a combat scenario? Since forgetting to use powers in a fight is usually PIS, not CIS?

According to the board rules, even if Flash doesn't use his speed to win 99% of his fights in the comics, he'll use them to win all of his fights on the boards. That's because Flash not using his speed to win fights is PIS, not CIS.

I interpret that to mean if a character possesses a power he rarely, if ever, used in a combat situation in comics, it's because of PIS, not CIS. CIS is more if a character is simply lacking in intelligence or skill.

Or, Grundy having no combat skills is CIS, because he's dumb. Thor not using his hammer as a guided missile to blitz everyone is PIS, because that would make most of his fights uninteresting and be bad for plot.