Mace Windu, Dooku, & Qui-Gon vs Darth Maul, Yoda, & Obi-Wan

Battle takes place in a Geonosian arena. All combatants are in their prime.

Which team takes this?

Give Yoda better teammates.

As it stands, team two gets mauled.

Obi-wan's not bad, he'd beat Qui-gon.

But whoever Maul goes against beats him.

Originally posted by Harbinger
Give Yoda better teammates.

As it stands, team two gets mauled.

Originally posted by Naga Sado
Yoda could win this solo.But with to highly aclaimed swords men they could do this blind folded, on one leg,and with a 5 minute bomb set in their mouths

This is going to be close. No way in Hell that Yoda could solo this. Mace vs. Yoda is very likely a toss-up. Dooku is quite a bit better than Kenobi, and Maul is quite a bit better than QGJ. So this fight very likely comes down to can Maul beat Qui-Gonn faster than Dooku can beat Kenobi?

Originally posted by truejedi
This is going to be close. No way in Hell that Yoda could solo this. Mace vs. Yoda is very likely a toss-up. Dooku is quite a bit better than Kenobi, and Maul is quite a bit better than QGJ. So this fight very likely comes down to can Maul beat Qui-Gonn faster than Dooku can beat Kenobi?

No way is Mace vs Yoda a "toss-up." Yoda wins every time. But agreed that Yoda won't be soloing in this one. However, team 2 still wins.

proof that Yoda would "win every time" against Mace?

From what we have seen I believe Dooku would beat Kenobi quicker than Maul would beat Qui-Gon.

I agree with that.

Originally posted by truejedi
proof that Yoda would "win every time" against Mace?

We can play this game. Here, how about this: Proof that a contest between the two is a "toss-up"

Proof that shut up.

there is no game, me saying proof is when you would present a reason why you think that Yoda would beat Mace "Every time". (Every time being the key words here)

If you want an argument as to why it is a toss-up: I'll give you:

1. Mace's showing in CWC as proof he can at least compete with Yoda in the force.

2. Mace beat Sidious, Yoda merely stalemated....

There, that's enough to establish that they are on a similar tier. you need to form a basis for your claim that, "Yoda beats Mace every time."

Don't you guys belive in the 'Greatest foe of darkness line?'

Or does Mace not count what with being black and all?

Is Mace "darkness?"

Ooooh, I'm not falling for that one. Not touching that with a 10-mile pole.

Though if Yoda is the greatest foe of darkness, then Mace is therefore a lesser foe of darkness.

does "greatest foe of darkness" means he wins "every time" over someone who is a "less foe of darkness" when that lesser foe has proven himself to be not much lesser?

I don't think think he'd win every time, but I think that there is a bigger disparity than you are making out. Mace beat Sidious because of Vaapad, something he will not benefit from as much here. Yoda could keep up with Sids on his own, he did not require a boost to do so. And being able to 'compete' isn't really much. Yoda's own CWC feat eclipse Maces.

Originally posted by truejedi

2. Mace beat Sidious, Yoda merely stalemated....

Toss up? Rather not. Yoda wins every time? Rather not.
He wins a clear majority though.

But not quickly enough imo. Dooku wll join in eventually.