Battlezone challenge---I'd rep Voldemort vs.

Started by quanchi1123 pages

Battlezone challenge---I'd rep Voldemort vs.

This is an open ended challenge to anyone who wants to argue movie versions only with no references allowed from the eu or from the potter books.

I'd like to face off against someone repping Darth Sidious aka Palpatine aka Emperor but if you'd rather represent Yoda, Windu, Anakin(Darth Vader), Odin Wan, Darth Maul, Cont Dooku, etc. I'd definitely accept and be fine with that.

Once someone accepts please close this down and we can decide on the time limit, judges/voting system, and all other rules of our one on one movie debate.

Can you explain to me exactly what a Battlezone is? Ive seen them around the board, but never participated.

It's two posters each agreeing to a time limit, set of debating guidelines, and judges or whatever method they deem appropriate for a winner. No one else posts until the closing arguments are given. Then anyone outside the judges or we could even do this popular vote though I'd have objections because of socks voting to determine the winner. Each side provides evidence of why their character or whatever wins or prevails and the goal is to convince the majority of the judges.

We each select one character to represent and debate until the timelimit is up and then let the judges decide and others weigh in on it. It's fun.

Here's a link to a battlezone I did with the rules and guidelines of desaad and myself debating.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=473261&pagenumber=1

Battlezone Guidelines

Welcome to the Revised KMC Battlezone, where some of the best and brightest of the Vs Forum come to prove their dominance over the opposition. Battlezone Matches are formal debates and are intended for members who're interested in solo debates with a bit more structure than is normally found in the threads of the Vs Forum.

The rules that govern the Battlezone are fairly simple and are as follows...

*Please note, the following are simply the "Default" Rules for Battlezone Matches to provide some initial structure that sets Battlezone matches apart from the Vs Forum. The stipulations and rules of individual matches are subject to change at the participants discretion. However, I STRONGLY suggest that any changes to the rules are noted and agreed upon by both parties before the match begins because trying to change the rules mid match shows bad form and is a BAD idea.

1. DO NOT POST IN SOMEONE ELSES MATCH. Debates are between the people actually involved with the match in question, so don’t chime in with your opinion or random spam. "Do unto others..." and all that junk.

2. The participants must fight “in character”. For the most part what constitutes “in character” will be determined by the judges, but as a good rule of thumb if they’ve never done it in combat then it’s probably not in character for them to do so.

3. The characters AVERAGE showing is what matters, no the high or low end. Both high and low end feats are likely to come up over the course of the debate, and it’s for the judges to decide which is the better depiction of the character.

4. The characters go into Battlezone fights "Battle Ready". This means that they begin the fight just as they normally would in a comic. They have standard equipment, no unusual power ups or empowerment's, and any powers that are consistently used in combat are assumed to be in effect at the start of the match. That means that if the match features the someone like Invisible Woman they'll begin the match with their Force Field raised, if it features someone like Superman they'll begin the match already in flight mode. Just picture the panel BEFORE the big fight where the characters are posed and squaring off .

5. Matches last exactly one week, starting at the time of the first argument is made(as opposed to the opening post).

Setting up a match.

I figured I’d go ahead and spell this out to avoid a bunch of unnecessary PM’s asking how to do it, so pay attention because setting up a match is a fairly simple process….

Step 1. Poster A challenges Poster B to a match. This can be through direct challenge on Poster B’s team thread, PM, a post in the Battlezone discussion thread, or even an open call on the Off Topic thread for all I care.

Step 2. If Poster B accepts, the two decide on the specific type of match they want and any match conditions they both feel are appropriate(I.E. the battle location, no speedblitze, prep time, no Godblast, etc.)

Step 3. After the conditions are decided, 3 judges for the match are agreed upon and asked to judge the match.

Step 4. Someone(be it one of the judges or one of the participants) post the opening for the match thread(listing any and all match conditions), at which point the match can begin.

Step 5. After one week the judges vote on the match in question, deciding on a winner.

Potential Battlezone match types-

*Some of these were just copied from the ICT Faq at herochat and some were modified.

Flat-Footed- Characters are normally assumed to be "Battle Ready" when the match begins,.adding this stipulation puts both characters on the ground with defenses down.

Slugfest- The characters take turns trading punches until one goes down, relying ONLY on strength and durability.

H2H- Hand to Hand fighting only. This is a fight where opponents pit their physical attributes(strength, speed, ect.) and martial skill against one another without weapons or exotic powers like energy attacks, flight, or transmutation. Move-reading, enhanced senses, and mind-reading(provided the character uses it primarily for physical fights and not communication[Mr. X-Fighting]) are allowed, as are "amping" abilities. This is any form of hand-to-hand combat, not just Asian martial arts. Dodging and giving ground for tactical regrouping is allowed.

Equal Bodies- The two opponents are in physically equal bodies. If the fighters are of opposite genders, then they are placed in exactly equal bodies of their own gender. They are equal in every physical stat, with no special powers(energy blasts, etc.) to speak of.

Slobberknocker- Known as "CBR Style" to some, a slobberknocker is an all out fight to the finish between two or more combatants. For whatever reason, the characters are enraged enough that they want their opponents to die horribly at their hands(even if it's extremely out of character), and will use any available means at their disposal to do it. They don't hold back or screw around at all, they go for the quickest win possible.

Judges Wanted- A match were the winner is determined by the forum at large rather than a selected panel of judges. Anyone who's been a member for 6 months and has at least 200 posts can vote

And with all of that being said, I wish everyone good luck and I hope you all have a good time.

Thank you Darthgoober.

These can all be amended by the two participants in the negotiation phase but were the original/general guidelines for the comic vs. battlezone.

I'll be happy to judge. I'm not enough of a Potter/Warsie fan to compete though.

Someone has finally accepted and this will take place next week. Unsure of whether my opponent will be repping Yoda or Darth Sidious from the movies at this point.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Someone has finally accepted and this will take place next week. Unsure of whether my opponent will be repping Yoda or Darth Sidious from the movies at this point.

Cool, nice to see some progress on this forum.

I haven't given too much thought to this fight, but I would pick Sidious over Yoda simply because he has access to more offensive powers, i.e Lightning and choke.

Really looking forward to this 🙂

Who's the challenger?

Originally posted by Placidity
Cool, nice to see some progress on this forum.

I haven't given too much thought to this fight, but I would pick Sidious over Yoda simply because he has access to more offensive powers, i.e Lightning and choke.

Really looking forward to this 🙂

I hope he picks Palpatine/Sidious as well due to being evil and more comparable to Voldemort anyways.
Originally posted by the ninjak
Who's the challenger?
Korto Vos. A poster who disappeared apparently like 4 years ago to finally return.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/member.php?s=&action=getinfo&userid=85120

Is EU allowed?

Originally posted by Utrigita
Is EU allowed?
No, movies only.

A suggestion: Establish the rules of the force.

I had an interesting conversation about combat regarding an elite vs. a human Jedi knight. One critical point in our debate was the influence of midichlorians (or the force) over my respective Sangheili warrior. It was a crucial aspect because it determined whether or not the Jedi could influence my Sangheili in anyway. I argued that, like the yuzon vong, my Sangheili was extra galactic and was not anatomically contaminated or conditioned by midichlorians. He agreed and the Jedi was only allowed to use force abilities on himself or (selective) objects around him.

It doesn't do much towards a fight if you can argue that the Jedi could rip the earth from under my Elite and squash him like a pancake 😛

Like I said, it's just a suggestion. 🙂

Originally posted by the ninjak
I'll be happy to judge. I'm not enough of a Potter/Warsie fan to compete though.

Also, I'd be happy to judge. I am a huge fan of Voldemort and would love to see how any force wielder responds to such magical notoriety!

I propose that Quan and I start posting from Tuesday, till the end date.

And yes, arguing for Star Wars with movie-only evidence will be slightly challenging, but it'll be fun I think, whatever the outcome.

Originally posted by Korto Vos
I propose that Quan and I start posting from Tuesday, till the end date.

And yes, arguing for Star Wars with movie-only evidence will be slightly challenging, but it'll be fun I think, whatever the outcome.

Just remember, if you chose Palpatine, he did take out Jedi Masters Saesee Tiin, Agen Kolar, and Kit Fisto all under 30 seconds. That alone should speak to the prowess of his abilities...

Activate order 666.

Originally posted by Korto Vos
I propose that Quan and I start posting from Tuesday, till the end date.

And yes, arguing for Star Wars with movie-only evidence will be slightly challenging, but it'll be fun I think, whatever the outcome.

Cool have a blast.

Originally posted by King of Blades
Just remember, if you chose Palpatine, he did take out Jedi Masters Saesee Tiin, Agen Kolar, and Kit Fisto all under 30 seconds. That alone should speak to the prowess of his abilities...
More like 10 seconds.

It's ON like Donkey Kong! To the first of many battles ! =D

Korto has chosen Yoda instead of Palpatine. The debate begins tomorrow and ends when we both agree it's over.

Originally posted by King of Blades
Just remember, if you chose Palpatine, he did take out Jedi Masters Saesee Tiin, Agen Kolar, and Kit Fisto all under 30 seconds. That alone should speak to the prowess of his abilities...

If this debate included EU, this would have been more of a killer point.