Revan + The Shans vs Skywalker Duo

Started by Toshi4 pages

Revan + The Shans vs Skywalker Duo

Which family line wins? This is redeemed Revan right after KOTOR, not nerfed, pussified Revan but when he was still epic. Bastila after KOTOR and Satele at the beginning of TOR. They are up against Zonakin and DE Luke. Who wins?

Skywalkers walk over them.

We still have to wait for Revan...

This would be a good fight, but the Skywalkers prevail.

DE Luke would defeat Satele and Bastila and assist Zonakin in taking down Prodigal Knight.

Not even fair, Skywalkers would win by doing some weird "godlike" ability and win.

Originally posted by GenomeFrozener
[b]Not even fair, Skywalkers would win by doing some weird "godlike" ability and win. [/B]

Sorry but I own't accept something "godlike" unless that godlike thing is specified...

If Bastila sits out using her extremely good battle meditation then its a powered up Satele and Revan against Zonakin and Luke. It might even impact Zonakin more since his mental state is effed up and Anakin is absolutely pathetic with emotions and a peaceful state of mind... So in that case the Skywalkers still win but it's OMG EPIC STOMP.

Some sources have certain Jedi using battle meditation in combat and if we use that then the Shans and Revan win a difficult battle.

Originally posted by Toshi
Some sources have certain Jedi using battle meditation in combat and if we use that then the Shans and Revan win a difficult battle.

Good thing Bastilla has never been shown to do so then.

Both the Shans are a MASSIVE weak link to Revan here regardless. Other than her battle meditation, I doubt Bastila has any real good feats to back herself up.

Advent would disagree with you there. Shes been somewhat successfully argued against Obi-Wan.

Good thing Bastilla has never been shown to do so then.

All she has to do is sit down and concentrate. 😬

Originally posted by Nephthys
All she has to do is sit down and concentrate. 😬
Originally posted by Toshi
Some sources have certain Jedi using battle meditation in combat and if we use that then the Shans and Revan win a difficult battle.

He's talking about her using BM while fighting at the same time.

I am positive the Skywalkers would sense a power boost and draw the obvious conclusion that the Jedi sitting in the corner is the cause. One Electric Judgement should interrupt the BM.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Advent would disagree with you there. Shes been somewhat successfully argued against Obi-Wan.

All she has to do is sit down and concentrate. 😬

If by this, you mean Advent got mad and left because she was wrong about everything, then... yes. yes indeed.

truejedi
If by this, you mean Advent got mad and left because she was wrong about everything, then... yes. yes indeed.

😂

Originally posted by Korto Vos
I am positive the Skywalkers would sense a power boost and draw the obvious conclusion that the Jedi sitting in the corner is the cause. One Electric Judgement should interrupt the BM.

Luke possibly, and I refuse to believe that Anakin isn't anything but a dumbass. Even while Zonakin.

Originally posted by Toshi
Luke possibly, and I refuse to believe that Anakin isn't anything but a dumbass. Even while Zonakin.

Anakin might be a dumbass around Palpatine, but he is a seasoned warrior.

Both Skywalkers won't allow Bastila to sit in a corner and do BM.

Revan and Satele will try and make it hard for them to interrupt.

Btw, having not played TOR, only read the comics, is this young Satele like when she fought Malgus the first time, Grand Master Satelele...?

Originally posted by truejedi
If by this, you mean Advent got mad and left because she was wrong about everything, then... yes. yes indeed.

I thought you guys ganged up on her and she just stopped replying.

Re: Revan + The Shans vs Skywalker Duo

Originally posted by Toshi
Which family line wins? This is redeemed Revan right after KOTOR, not nerfed, pussified Revan but when he was still epic. Bastila after KOTOR and Satele at the beginning of TOR. They are up against Zonakin and DE Luke. Who wins?

I've underlined your problem. "Zonakin" is Anakin at the exact moment he's tapping his fullest potential, which argues like this:

- Anakin has best potential evah, because of GL quote ballooned into blanket statement.

- Anakin in teh zon3 is tapping this potential, which we already assumed was infinite etc., and thus cannot be beaten conclusively.

- Only true evidence of this is Anakin tapping his potential briefly and defeating Dooku, who was technically head and shoulders above Anakin at this point.

- Thus, we are assuming two things when we argue Zonakin: that he is consistently uber and unbeatable because his potential is absolutely better than everyone elses (even though canonically we can only compare him to PT Jedi, not Sith or pre-PT characters at all), and Zonakin is somehow verifiable in fighting maneuvers beyond the 20 seconds we see of him swinging at Dooku.

Consider that Zonakin doesn't throw one offensive Force power.

Anakin and Luke stomp them into next week.

Originally posted by GenomeFrozener
[b]Both the Shans are a MASSIVE weak link to Revan here regardless. Other than her battle meditation, I doubt Bastila has any real good feats to back herself up. [/B]

You serious?

I wouldn't consider Satele a weak link. For what we have seen of her in the videos, she is no pushover and is very strong in the Force.

She can handle DE Luke alone. And before someone comes up with the argument that DE Luke stood up to Palpatine, it is useless. DE Luke got assistance from some of his companions in his struggle against Palpatine and that counts a lot. He was no match for Palpatine in a fair contest by this point.

For this contest; I believe it can go either way. The side which makes smart judgements will gain advantage and win.

In Star Wars, powers are not everything as I have come to know by reading many sources. Tactics and decisions can make a lot of difference.

Palpatine regardless of his great power, lost in the end. Same can be said about Nihilus and so on....

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
She can handle DE Luke alone.

😆