Movie Thor vs. X-Men 3 Magneto

Magneto is plotting the destruction of humanity, while in Asgard Odin is greatly displeased with Thor, with his pride and impetuousness. So, in his august wisdom, he banishes Thor from Asgard. Thor cannot return until he has defeated Magneto. Odin grants him Mjolnir.

Just as Magneto is about to assault Warren labs, the clouds, the very heavens are torn asunder and Thor lands on the battlefield. Magneto, believing himself the superior being, gives battle to Thor. The humans and lesser mutants stand back to observe this battle of kings.

Thor is armed with Mjolnir and demigodlike powers around the end of his movie when he fought that big metallic thing. He is not fully restored to God status, but is still very powerful.

Magneto is as is in X-Men Last Stand.

Who wins?

Thor wearing armor? Magneto wins.

Can he affect heavenly armor though? Do the laws of electromagnetism apply?

Is this on the bridge. If so I give this to Magneto.

Originally posted by Robtard
Thor wearing armor? Magneto wins.

Nahhhh.

Mjolnir and Thor's armor are enchanted and defy the laws of nature.

Mjolnir is made of Uru forged in a dying star. Stacked with enchantments.
His armor as stated by Odin himself is his legacy. Made from pure energy.

Film Magneto feared the plastic rifles the military made in Xmen3.
He needed a vibrative mutant to shatter them before his arrival less he got pelted with plastic bullets.

Thor's hammer and armor are far beyond plastic.

Thor blasts then smashes Magneto's old head in.

Originally posted by the ninjak
Nahhhh.

Mjolnir and Thor's armor are enchanted and defy the laws of nature.

Mjolnir is made of Uru forged in a dying star. Stacked with enchantments.
His armor as stated by Odin himself is his legacy. Made from pure energy.

Film Magneto feared the plastic rifles the military made in Xmen3.
He needed a vibrative mutant to shatter them before his arrival less he got pelted with plastic bullets.

Thor's hammer and armor are far beyond plastic.

Thor blasts then smashes Magneto's old head in.

The hammer, maybe.

Where was it shown or stated that the metal of Thor's armor "defies the laws of nature" and is not affected by a magnetic field? Scene?

Magneto feared the plastic guns because he can't specifically affect plastic and those guns had the anti-mutagen serum. Your comparison is nonsense.

Originally posted by Robtard
Magneto feared the plastic guns because he can't specifically affect plastic and those guns had the anti-mutagen serum. Your comparison is nonsense.

He feared the plastic guns because if a plastic bullet hit him he would die, he was imprisoned in a plastic tomb.

The serum was just ammunition that gave him a fate worse than death. Lol.

Originally posted by Robtard
The hammer, maybe.
Where was it shown or stated that the metal of Thor's armor "defies the laws of nature" and is not affected by a magnetic field? Scene?

The armor as stated by Odin was his legacy. Part of the Odin Force.
When Thor proved his worthiness he regained the armor along with the hammer. Obviously both have the same origin hence the accomplishment.

Originally posted by the ninjak
He feared the plastic guns because if a plastic bullet hit him he would die. The serum was just ammunition that gave him a fate worse than death. Lol.

WTF... no, you need to watch that shitty X3 movie again. Those guns didn't fire bullets, they shot syringes full of the anti-mutagen; he feared being turned into a normal human, which is what happened when he was hit with one.

Anyhow, this "plastic" angle of yours has nothing to do with Thor. Thor's armor isn't made of plastic, it's metal.

Originally posted by Robtard
WTF... no, you need to watch that shitty X3 movie again. Those guns didn't fire bullets, they shot syringes full of the anti-mutagen; he feared being turned into a normal human, which is what happened when he was hit with one.

Anyhow, this "plastic" angle of yours has nothing to do with Thor. Thor's armor isn't made of plastic, it's metal.

It has everything to do with your point.

Plastic projectiles can enter Magneto's influence and penetrate his flesh. Hence Hank jumping onto him and stabbing him with it. Pathetic.

Bullets or needles it doesn't matter. Odin's enchantments easily override simple plastic. The hammer was his creation so was the armor, accept it!

Uru and enchantments that's whats made Mjolnir. The armor would be no different. Do you think he made it of simple steel? No. He made it of his legacy.

Originally posted by the ninjak
It has everything to do with your point.

Plastic projectiles can enter Magneto's influence and penetrate his flesh. Hence Hank jumping onto him and stabbing him with it. Pathetic.

Bullets or needles it doesn't matter. Odin's enchantments easily override simple plastic. The hammer was his creation so was the armor, accept it!

Uru and enchantments that's whats made Mjolnir. The armor would be no different. Do you think he made it of simple steel? No. He made it of his legacy.

No, not at all actually.

Magneto's powers affect metal. So plastic, wood, flesh, rock etc are out of his scope. This has nothing to do with a weakness of his powers. It's just outside of his scope.

Your 'Thor's armor > plastic' so it won't be affected is complete nonsense. It's metal, it's in Magneto's field to manipulate.

Unless you have some evidence that this "enchantment" renders it immune to a magnetic field, you have no point. So name the scene?

Do you know what "legacy" means? Odin was saying saying the armor is a gift, [possibly] passed down from father to son. eg From his ancestors. None of this "he made it of his legacy", which makes zero sense.

It makes complete sense.

Once Thor became worthy of Mjolnir and his armor it bonded to him. Resurrected him.

The element isn't created from the same thing as the items we are used to on Earth. Uru + Enchantments. Described as stone but hard as and looks like metal. But not metal.

If this debate boils down to you assuming that Uru is metal then this argument will go nowhere. Both are magical. Both defy the laws of nature. Magic is an undiscovered form of science therefore beyond such base assumptions.

Show me film feats of Magneto manipulating magical based elements. You can't. He got defeated by plastic. Which is crap compared to Uru or enchanted elements.

Originally posted by the ninjak
It makes complete sense.

Once Thor became worthy of Mjolnir and his armor it bonded to him. Resurrected him.

The element isn't created from the same thing as the items we are used to on Earth. Uru + Enchantments. Described as stone but hard as and looks like metal. But not metal.

If this debate boils down to you assuming that Uru is metal then this argument will go nowhere. Both are magical. Both defy the laws of nature. Magic is an undiscovered form of science therefore beyond such base assumptions.

[b]Show me film feats of Magneto manipulating magical based elements. You can't. He got defeated by plastic. Which is crap compared to Uru or enchanted elements. [/B]

More illogical conclusions.

Not discussing Mjolnir, as that certainly has certain variables we know of. Only Thor (and Odin) being able to wield etc.

You're basing your argument on the comic book, this is why you fail here. Movie feats only.

Show me in the film where Thor's armor was stated to not be metal and/or immune to a magnetic field? Because by all appearances, it looks/acts like metal.

Your "defeated by plastic!" argument is nonsense. Adamantium > plastic too, yet Magneto could affect adamantium and we know that shit is "virtually indestructible."

And for the record, Magneto was able to shield himself against a Mjolnir (made of Uru) and send it back at Thor in the comics.
http://media.comicvine.com/uploads/4/47816/1127050-magfiresstonesshield7jj.jpg. So you're wrong from a comic-book angle too. Know BEFORE you argue.

Originally posted by Robtard
Thor wearing armor? Magneto wins.

👆

This magic armor isn't effected by magnetic fields is RJ level fanboyism.

Bahhh!

His enchanted metal/stone/element defies all physics. It's magic is therefore beyond such base feats/manipulations.

LoL, fanboyism rage.

going by what i have seen while watching Thor and X3 Mags.. Thor won't be afraid of plastic baubles the same way Mags was.. also i don't see Mags stopping Mjolnir from knocking him out

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
going by what i have seen while watching Thor and X3 Mags.. Thor won't be afraid of plastic baubles the same way Mags was..

also i don't see Mags stopping Mjolnir from knocking him out

Thor wouldn't fear those plastic guns because he's not a mutant.

Thor would have to throw Mjolnor first, can't do that when he's being held/crushed by his own armor under tons and tons of pressure.

Originally posted by Robtard
LoL, fanboyism rage.

You out of stuff to say?

Show me feats of Magneto manipulating enchantment based elements.

Originally posted by Robtard
Thor wouldn't fear those plastic guns because he's not a mutant.

Originally posted by Robtard
Thor would have to throw Mjolnor first, can't do that when he's being held/crushed by his own armor under tons and tons of pressure.

Originally posted by the ninjak
You out of stuff to say?

Show me feats of Magneto manipulating enchantment based elements.

He wouldn't feay any plastic unlike Magneto. Who can be hit with any mineral based on metal. Unfortanately for him Uru is beyond such limitations.

You've yet to counter any of my points and are still dodging. Show me where this "enchantment" renders Thor's armor immune to magnetic fields? By all appearances, it is metal. So the burden is on you.

And that has nothing to do with Thor's armor, as it isn't made of plastic. I also showed you how you were wrong from a comics standpoint too, because this is what you're basing your fanboyish argument on.

http://imageshack.us/f/174/journeyintomystery10910lw1.jpg/
See, you're wrong yet again with your comic-book angle.

Originally posted by Robtard
You've yet to counter any of my points and are still dodging. Show me where this "enchantment" renders Thor's armor immune to magnetic fields? By all appearances, it is metal. So the burden is on you.

And that has nothing to do with Thor's armor, as it isn't made of plastic. I also showed you how you were wrong from a comics standpoint too, because this is what you're basing your fanboyish argument on.

No I'm not.

You can't supply me with a feat of Magneto manipulating magical based elements. So you're dodging the argument.

Magic/Science, a fine line blurs the two. One that is certainly beyond plastic.

My arguments are not comic based as you state. Just logical to the fact that Thor and Odin have been fighting threats for hundreds of years if not more from all coners of the universe. Magnetism would be no surprise.

And lol how that scan shows Thor + armor breaking through Mag's efforts.