Superman vs Silver Surfer (No Weakness Exploitation)

Started by JakeTheBank5 pages
Originally posted by Starscream M
its true jake, neither of them ever faced a creature like HP DD for one

They've both faced worse than HP DD. Superman himself has faced worse than HP DD.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Don't get carried away, now.

I am not joking. When thor and surfer sing out an entity which was dragging multiverse down with it and punch out from inside of his own death's avatar (Superman:where is thy sting) tell me about it. Comics superman>>>>forum superman.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor's faced worse than DD. Surfer has faced worse than DD as well. Come on, bruce.

Mangog? Kurse? Uni Lord? WOL Morg? Tyrant?

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
They've both faced worse than HP DD. Superman himself has faced worse than HP DD.
like who? 🙄

Originally posted by abhilegend
I am not joking. When thor and surfer sing out an entity which was dragging multiverse down with it and punch out from inside of his own death's avatar (Superman:where is thy sting) tell me about it. Comics superman>>>>forum superman.

baka

It would help if you knew everything that Thor and Surfer have done as well, just so you know.

Originally posted by Starscream M
like who? 🙄

Mangog, Galactus, Celestials, Infinity (crazed Odin), Thanos, Surtur, Ymir, Uni-Lord, T & A, etc.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Mangog, Galactus, Celestials, Infinity (crazed Odin), Thanos, Surtur, Ymir, Uni-Lord, T & A, etc.
guess what, wolverine faced a majority of those villains too, does that make him on par with superman now? 🙄

Straight up trolling

Originally posted by Starscream M
guess what, wolverine faced a majority of those villains too, does that make him on par with superman now? 🙄
Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Straight up trolling

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
baka

It would help if you knew everything that Thor and Surfer have done as well, just so you know.


I know about their high end feats, jake and I even give surfer 6-6.5/10 against superman and Thor an even split against superman but with his weaknesses removed he would pummel both. Most of his low showings are with his weaknesses. He has the most insane durability showings on herald levels.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
neither thor nor surfer ever had a foe as daunting as what dd represented to superman

Originally posted by Starscream M
neither thor nor surfer ever had a foe as daunting as what dd represented to superman

Superman has had villains more daunting to him than what DD represented back then.

Is starscream serious or is he just trolling?

Originally posted by abhilegend
I am not joking. When thor and surfer sing out an entity which was dragging multiverse down with it and punch out from inside of his own death's avatar (Superman:where is thy sting) tell me about it. Comics superman>>>>forum superman.
Context, please go find it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I know about their high end feats, jake and I even give surfer 6-6.5/10 against superman and Thor an even split against superman but with his weaknesses removed he would pummel both. Most of his low showings are with his weaknesses. He has the most insane durability showings on herald levels.

If you knew about their high end feats, you wouldn't say Superman has done and faced things they can't even dream of because they have. They've also done things that Superman cannot just like Superman has done things they can't.

Funny, because I don't factor in Surfer or Thor exploiting Superman's weaknesses at all when I consider them beating him. Surfer's powerful enough to damage Superman without exploiting Kryptonite or red solar energy, which, to be frank, I don't see him resorting to typically, anyway. Thor's also powerful enough to damage Kal and I don't think the magic aspect of Thor's offensive capabilities would utterly decimate him, save something extreme and out of the norm like a Godblast.

Case in point, neither of them need to resort to exploiting Superman's weaknesses to hurt him or even beat him.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Superman has had villains more daunting to him than what DD represented back then.
who?

Originally posted by Starscream M
who?

Darkseid, Dominus and even Lex have represented graver threats to Superman on a psychological level than DD did.

Physically, there's still Darkseid and the likes of Imperiex.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank

Funny, because I don't factor in Surfer or Thor exploiting Superman's weaknesses at all when I consider them beating him. Surfer's powerful enough to damage Superman without exploiting Kryptonite or red solar energy, which, to be frank, I don't see him resorting to typically, anyway. Thor's also powerful enough to damage Kal and I don't think the magic aspect of Thor's offensive capabilities would utterly decimate him, save something extreme and out of the norm like a Godblast.

I also generally don't factor in weakness exploit as I don't think they would use it.

I would say superman beat surfer because he is a better fighter, and stronger and more durable.

and he would win majority against thor due to a much superior speed advantage.

Energy Eradicator outclassed him more than DD.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Darkseid, Dominus and even Lex have represented graver threats to Superman on a psychological level than DD did.
I don't remember superman ever being scared of lex or ds as much as he was of dd, of course you have read more than me, so maybe you're right. my impression was that dd was superman's ultimate foe, the only one to have 'killed' him.