Top Tier/Herald Class: Who is the #1 p4p?

Started by Sundipped17 pages
Originally posted by Sin I AM
i know i just wanted to get off superman/thor/surfer......that argument has grown stale

That's basically why I haven't posted in this thread. Its really a Superman vs. Thor vs. Surfer duplicate which I've seen a 100 times.

exactly...and there are other heralds that are just as good

Originally posted by Sin I AM
exactly...and there are other heralds that are just as good

Agreed. The other heralds won't get much mention due to the popularity/massive feat count of the 3 mentioned above.

Originally posted by Sundipped
Agreed. The other heralds won't get much mention due to the popularity/massive feat count of the 3 mentioned above.

personally, who do u feel is p4p a #1 contender....excluding the big three

Majestic?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
personally, who do u feel is p4p a #1 contender....excluding the big three

Captain Marvel (Billy)
Hulk
Black Adam
Gladiator (barring cis)
Orion

Just to name a few.

Genis
Shaman Nate Grey
Cyborg Supes
Majestic

Originally posted by Sundipped
Captain Marvel (Billy)
Hulk
Black Adam
Gladiator (barring cis)
Orion

Just to name a few.

i agree with u save hulk. Now don't get me wrong statistically speaking he is up there. His strength, resilience, durability, and stamina in some instances transcend the high herald category. His intelligence is definitely up to the task, however its his lack of flight, or rather the ability to return to the battle field under his own power that phucks him. If I was Thor and you were Hulk, during our initial attack i would simply grab u, put u n a headlock and throw u outer space. Once your in zero gravity u would be helpless imo.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
i agree with u save hulk. Now don't get me wrong statistically speaking he is up there. His strength, resilience, durability, and stamina in some instances transcend the high herald category. His intelligence is definitely up to the task, however its his lack of flight, or rather the ability to return to the battle field under his own power that phucks him. If I was Thor and you were Hulk, during our initial attack i would simply grab u, put u n a headlock and throw u outer space. Once your in zero gravity u would be helpless imo.

You are underestimating the propulsive power of Gamma Farts!

Originally posted by Mshinu
You are underestimating the propulsive power of Gamma Farts!

lol...true

s/n nate grey is depowered correct?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
lol...true

s/n nate grey is depowered correct?

For now yep

Just out of curiosity where would u guys put someone like sinestro on a list with some of others mentioned here.

high herald, probably higher depending on how much juice he has at any given time

Originally posted by Mshinu
You are underestimating the propulsive power of Gamma Farts!

a classic blunder

...

Seriously though, there's a point here. I was in a tournament, facing Juggernaut who had been amped to holy hell. But he wasn't given flight, so he was essentially just jumping at us while we did things to him or his team around him. The vote was a landslide. We know how comics are written, so they're never going to have Surfer chillin' in space taking potshots at Hulk because it's boring writing. But that's the big knock on Hulk against most of these guys.

Sinestro would be High Herald easily, imo. Currently, he's likely the top Green Lantern. Hal has more raw willpower to tap into when the situation calls for it, but Sinestro displays more skill and finesse with his ring.

Originally posted by Digi
a classic blunder

...

Seriously though, there's a point here. I was in a tournament, facing Juggernaut who had been amped to holy hell. But he wasn't given flight, so he was essentially just jumping at us while we did things to him or his team around him. The vote was a landslide. We know how comics are written, so they're never going to have Surfer chillin' in space taking potshots at Hulk because it's boring writing. But that's the big knock on Hulk against most of these guys.

do u have a link ? Everyone knows thats not how it would happen in comics but thats essentially how i feel he would be when stacked against heralds...

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Sinestro would be High Herald easily, imo. Currently, he's likely the top Green Lantern. Hal has more raw willpower to tap into when the situation calls for it, but Sinestro displays more skill and finesse with his ring.

exactly...Sinestro to me is superior to Hal with willpower being the exception, now if he were written as a hero then that would change imo

Originally posted by Digi
We know how comics are written, so they're never going to have Surfer chillin' in space taking potshots at Hulk because it's boring writing.
Wouldn't be the first time... 😖hifty:

Originally posted by Sin I AM
i agree with u save hulk. Now don't get me wrong statistically speaking he is up there. His strength, resilience, durability, and stamina in some instances transcend the high herald category. His intelligence is definitely up to the task, however its his lack of flight, or rather the ability to return to the battle field under his own power that phucks him. If I was Thor and you were Hulk, during our initial attack i would simply grab u, put u n a headlock and throw u outer space. Once your in zero gravity u would be helpless imo.

Reason I gave Hulk the benefit of doubt is because he is the most uber brick minus flight. Give him at least sol (speed of light) flight or something close to it, & he'll no doubt be interchangeable with the top 3.

Originally posted by carver9
Naah, that was someone else...wasn't me.
Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Oh Carver, you and your lies

--

Originally posted by Sin I AM
personally, who do u feel is p4p a #1 contender....excluding the big three

Hal Jordan, imo.

Hal should definitely be considered, especially when pre-crisis feats are canon for him too.