Top Tier/Herald Class: Who is the #1 p4p?

Started by -Pr-17 pages
Originally posted by h1a8
Hal should definitely be considered, especially when pre-crisis feats are canon for him too.

Even if they weren't, I'd still have him up there.

Originally posted by h1a8
Hal should definitely be considered, especially when pre-crisis feats are canon for him too.

Him having his pre-crisis fts puts him at high skyfather.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
personally, who do u feel is p4p a #1 contender....excluding the big three

Classic Drax, Sersi.

Barring Thor, Superman, Surfer:

-Hal Jordan/Kyle Rayner/Sinestro
-Quasar
-Wonder Woman (+ gear)
-Firelord
-Orion

Bump.

mmm

Superman, Surfer, Thor, Hal

The traditional top 3 are Surfer, Superman, and Thor.

Personally I think it's Plutonian, Voidtry, and Photon (Genis)

Voidtry and Photon aren't really high heralds.

Pre-Flashpoint Firestorm. 🙂

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Voidtry and Photon aren't really high heralds.

We agreed Photon was High Herald. It was one of the last modifications before the tier list got closed.

The thing with Photon is that he has no real lows to speak of... He might be the only Herald who can make such a boast.

Originally posted by janus77
#1 - Surfer for the sheer awesomeness of his potential and the speeds at which he can (and sometimes does) operate. Surfer can also take beatings from Celestial level beings, for an extended period of time, which sort of helps.

#2 - Hulk, as "one dimensional" as he is, he is literally unending in his ability to pour on more power, more force, more strength, that makes him virtually un-killable. Frequently collapsing dimensions with mere by-products of his blows are feats that I've not seen any of his 'rivals' do. Still, Surfer is much faster, much better at range and has the tools to nullify much of Hulk's attacks.

#3 - Sentry, made Asgard his *****, made Thor cry and only lost when he got freaked out by his own patheticness.

others.

👆

Hyperion

#1 The Silver Surfer

Just powers up the the as#

1. Thor
2. Quasar / Surfer
3. Superman

Would place Plutonian above these guys:

1. Thor
2. Quasar / Surfer
3. Superman

Have a nagging feeling about some old Firestorm and Hal Jordan stuff, but cant remember feats.

Originally posted by Horrificus
Would place Plutonian above these guys:

1. Thor
2. Quasar / Surfer
3. Superman

Have a nagging feeling about some old Firestorm and Hal Jordan stuff, but cant remember feats.


Eh, Quasar? What has he done to be placed that high?

Originally posted by abhilegend
Eh, Quasar? What has he done to be placed that high?
i think we've had this "talk" before. But, i guess it's been a few years.

Let me dig into my bag of scans...

Originally posted by Horrificus
i think we've had this "talk" before. But, i guess it's been a few years.

Let me dig into my bag of scans...


Ok, I don't think we have.

He has done nothing that places him above mid heralds.