Morlun vs. Rulk

Started by JakeTheBank5 pages

Morlun.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Since when was secondary adamantium malleable enough to make into a net? Secondary is just less durable, not super malleable.
Suspension of disbelief

If it was secondary adamantium, it would have been called secondary.

cue big argument

👆

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Since always. thats the advantage of it, it far more malleable, cheaper and much easier to come by.

No it wouldent of. Secondary is the most common and is often referred to as simply adamatium.

No need for a big arguement. It the most common type and it malleable. there zero reason to assume it the most rare type that is not malleable at all but some how got magically turned into a net. your simply reaching.


Jake how about reading my post instead of simply ignoring it an reposting a reply I already answered.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Since always. thats the advantage of it, it far more malleable, cheaper and much easier to come by.

No it wouldent of. Secondary is the most common and is often referred to as simply adamatium.

No need for a big arguement. It the most common type and it malleable. there zero reason to assume it the most rare type that is not malleable at all but some how got magically turned into a net. your simply reaching.

And it's malleable enough to make a net... IYO? And don't so "yes because it's been made into a net", because I'll just use the same logic to say that primary is malleable enough to make into a net because it happened.
Primary isn't malleable enough to make into a net. Secondary isn't malleable enough to make into a net. However it happened. Deal with it.
Suspension of disbelief makes things much more enjoyable.

Secondary is referred to as secondary.
"Hey guys, they invented a term to weaker adamantium, and here's the kicker, they must have invented it so they never had to use the term again! So obviously all adamantium that ever gets broken ever... even by skyfather level power is obviously secondary adamantium... because they invented the term!"
"Did they use the term?"
"No... but it was broken, so therefore it was secondary."
"..."

You're reaching. You have no proof it wasn't primary besides "malleable" and secondary is referred to as "adamantium". All this overwhelming proof that it was secondary is so overwhelming that it made me overwhelmed.

And... done here. Let's see how this turns out.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Jake how about reading my post instead of simply ignoring it an reposting a reply I already answered.

I did read it.

Originally posted by JakeTheBank
Morlun.

👆

You're wise beyond your years Jake

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
You're wise beyond your years Jake

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
Because they basically are two different characters. Morlun that fought spiderman was significantly less powerful. they gave him a big boost. If he fought Rulk at the level he was when he foguht Spiderman he get beasted. There be little he could do. However since his boost in power the fight a lot more interesting. (yes I undertsand there the same character but it very clear he was not originally intended to possess the level of power he did in black panther issue in contrast with his spiderman apaearances. Similar to how sabre-tooth classic is the same character technically, buthave very different levels of power. Same goes for numerous other characters)

I am not that impressed by vibranium missles and I think Rulk could in a single bunch exceed that out put.

But how do you know he wasn't that powerful then? Maybe he wasn't intended to be but we don't KNOW that. He basically no sold everything Pete threw at him. Nothing wrong with the fact that Pete put up a fight. ST was officially upgraded. Morlun wasn't. We just didn't see his upper limit in SM issues. IMO walking through missiles like that shows he can take anything Rulk can throw at him.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
And it's malleable enough to make a net... IYO? And don't so "yes because it's been made into a net", because I'll just use the same logic to say that primary is malleable enough to make into a net because it happened.

My arguement was never that it was made into a net so that why it more malleable, it because it is more malleable which is why it was made into a net. It has always been malleable while Primary adamatium is not. Fact your ignorant of this is not fault of mine.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb

Primary isn't malleable enough to make into a net.

I know it isent, i been telling u this repeatedly and yet you insist that it primary adamatium.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Secondary isn't malleable enough to make into a net. However it happened. Deal with it.
Suspension of disbelief makes things much more enjoyable.

Except it is malleable enough to make into net. You keep stating it not, just portrays your ignorance.

Omega red tentacles are made from a form of secondary adamatium, they very much as malleable as a net would be. So what were u saying again?

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
Secondary is referred to as secondary.
"Hey guys, they invented a term to weaker adamantium, and here's the kicker, they must have invented it so they never had to use the term again! So obviously all adamantium that ever gets broken ever... even by skyfather level power is obviously secondary adamantium... because they invented the term!"
"Did they use the term?"
"No... but it was broken, so therefore it was secondary."
"..."

except thats not my logic moron. Secondary adamatium is often refferred to as adamatium. It the most common type. the fact you think anything stated as adamatium means it the most rare type just makes u an idiot.

Object made out of primary adamatium have been stated as primary adamatium.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb

You're reaching. You have no proof it wasn't primary besides "malleable" and secondary is referred to as "adamantium". All this overwhelming proof that it was secondary is so overwhelming that it made me overwhelmed.

yes i do. It was not stated as primary. the most common type of adamatium is secondary. Primary adamtium is not malleable, but secondary is and has proven to be. Oh and then there the fact primary adamtium has held up to people like the Hulk repeatedly, but black panther assumed his net would be broken. Which again suggest it was not primary adamatium. While secondary adamatium has a track record of failing against class 100's.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
And... done here. Let's see how this turns out.

badly for you I wager

I think everyone's in agreement that Morlun wins.

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
I think everyone's in agreement that Morlun wins.
Originally posted by JakeTheBank

Originally posted by SamZED
But how do you know he wasn't that powerful then? Maybe he wasn't intended to be but we don't KNOW that. He basically no sold everything Pete threw at him. Nothing wrong with the fact that Pete put up a fight. ST was officially upgraded. Morlun wasn't. We just didn't see his upper limit in SM issues. IMO walking through missiles like that shows he can take anything Rulk can throw at him.

becuase there was clear difference in how he was potrayed. Sam common now u can't honestly tell me there is not a significant different in how he was potrayed in his fight with spiderman and wankadan.

ST was not official upgraded. He was reconnt just like morlon. he went form only have anamalictic nature into having superhuman attributes and a healing factor. marvel never one officially upgraded him from classic version into wolverine villain. They did it much like with morlun, they jsut made him way more powerful with out stating a reason.

How is walking throw missles make him be able to take what Rulk throws at him? you do understand that all those missiles combined fail in comparison to class 100 attacks right?

rulk dies.

Originally posted by Dum Dum Dugan
becuase there was clear difference in how he was potrayed. Sam common now u can't honestly tell me there is not a significant different in how he was potrayed in his fight with spiderman and wankadan.

ST was not official upgraded. He was reconnt just like morlon. he went form only have anamalictic nature into having superhuman attributes and a healing factor. marvel never one officially upgraded him from classic version into wolverine villain. They did it much like with morlun, they jsut made him way more powerful with out stating a reason.

How is walking throw missles make him be able to take what Rulk throws at him? you do understand that all those missiles combined fail in comparison to class 100 attacks right?

But that's the thing, Morlun wasnt retconned. I agree there was a diffeference. In BP issues he simply showed his upper limit of durability. And since his upper limit was never shown in his fight with SM (and since there was no official retcon) we HAVE to assume he always was that durable even if he originally wasnt intended to. Dont get me wrong, Dum Dum. I just dont see a point in seperating the character when one showing doesnt controdict the other. And im just saying that the fact that Spider-man put up a fight against him doesnt mean he was less powerfull. Spider-man has a history of putting up fights against characters on that level.

Hmm.. maybe 100 vibranium missiles sound beter on paper.. but I always assumed they'd make more damage than ordinary punches. Even class 100 ones. Also Morlun can go intangible (vanish or whatever that thing he does)

Was there anything brought up about Morlun ripping "secondary" adamantium or is this a KMC myth because they don't like the fact that people are strong enough to rip adamantium?

Originally posted by carver9
Was there anything brought up about Morlun ripping "secondary" adamantium or is this a KMC myth because they don't like the fact that people are strong enough to rip adamantium?
It was pretty much the same as when Nuul ripped the net (although not as easy).

And they're trying to take that away Carver.

Originally posted by carver9
Was there anything brought up about Morlun ripping "secondary" adamantium or is this a KMC myth because they don't like the fact that people are strong enough to rip adamantium?
The book just said "adamantium", nothing about it being secondary. There are reasons why people believe its secondary, but tbh I dont believe the writer cared much, he simply wanted to show that the character is crazy powerful and decided "Hey, why dont I have him rip an adamantium net, that'd be cool and impressive". Sooo...

But if it isn't stated on panel as being secondary adamantium, then wouldn't it be judged as Primary until stated otherwise. We can't just go off of an assumption because we don't like it. And why in the hell would one of the richest peeps (Black Panther) buy secondary adamantium? WTF. That's like saying his Vibranium was made out of a coffee shop..kind of disrespectful if you ask me.

Originally posted by carver9
But if it isn't stated on panel as being secondary adamantium, then wouldn't it be judged as Primary until stated otherwise. We can't just go off of an assumption because we don't like it. And why in the hell would one of the richest peeps (Black Panther) buy secondary adamantium? WTF. That's like saying his Vibranium was made Umar coffee shop..kind of disrespectful if you ask me.
I agree. 👆 until stated otherwise, its primary.

Originally posted by carver9
But if it isn't stated on panel as being secondary adamantium, then wouldn't it be judged as Primary until stated otherwise. We can't just go off of an assumption because we don't like it. And why in the hell would one of the richest peeps (Black Panther) buy secondary adamantium? WTF. That's like saying his Vibranium was made Umar coffee shop..kind of disrespectful if you ask me.
Im actually thinking to write a letter and find out for sure from the writer. Cant be that hard.
But yeah, I dont beieve he intended for it to be secondary adamantium. For all we know he didnt know the IS such thing as secondary adamantium. He only cared about making Morlun seem like an unstopable threat, that's why he had him rip through adamantium net. So yeah, I guess we have to assume that it is until proven otherwise. Like you said.

Originally posted by carver9
But if it isn't stated on panel as being secondary adamantium, then wouldn't it be judged as Primary until stated otherwise. We can't just go off of an assumption because we don't like it. And why in the hell would one of the richest peeps (Black Panther) buy secondary adamantium? WTF. That's like saying his Vibranium was made out of a coffee shop..kind of disrespectful if you ask me.
Carver, I agree with you 100%

👆