Pre-Crisis Superman VS Worldbreaker Hulk

Started by carver912 pages
Originally posted by Justforaminute
world breaker hulk is kinda of a joke...actually the hulk in general is a joke

I agree. Hulk wins the majority.

Originally posted by abhilegend
If it were carver saying these things, I couldn't care less. It bothers me when galan007, one of the most respected poster and creator of pc superman respect thread lefts context

He just left a small detail

http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/DC_Comics_present032.jpg

I could care less about half of those things. I was just goofing around in that thread as I admitted but you even made a bait thread for me and challenged me for a battlezone and you are lecturing me on taking this too zealously. Real nice jake, real nice. Oh and doom would lose 10/10 to PC lex. He may take -[b]1/10 against post crisis lex.😏 [/B]

Such blasphemy!😏

Originally posted by Justforaminute
why is carver9 such a hulk dick sucker...regular superman would already break hulk in half..


Originally posted by Justforaminute
captain america beat hulk, so superman would one shot him.

When did Captain America fight World War Hulk or World Breaker Hulk? Scans.

Originally posted by carver9
When did Captain America fight World War Hulk or World Breaker Hulk? Scans.
I don't think Cap fought Butt Breaker Hulk.

Originally posted by Justforaminute
world breaker hulk is weaker then green scar hulk who spiderman one shotted

Lol...just like I thought. Concession accepted.

Originally posted by carver9
PreCrisis Supes really don't have many combat speed fts. It all revolves around his space flight.

There's a decent enough share of feats that aren't just flying in space.

My favorite is this one:

Originally posted by carver9


Year one superman who killed the undead in two punches.

Originally posted by cdtm
There's a decent enough share of feats that aren't just flying in space.

My favorite is this one:

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/CDTM3000/SuperboytheLegionofSuperheroes245-14.jpg

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v330/CDTM3000/SuperboytheLegionofSuperheroes245-15.jpg

Is that young Kal-El or young Kal-L?

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Is that young Kal-El or young Kal-L?

Kal El. Stories painted Superboy as Earth 1 Superman.

Silver age supes takes this.

Originally posted by cdtm
Kal El. Stories painted Superboy as Earth 1 Superman.
So no PC Superboy feats belong to Kal-L?

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
So no PC Superboy feats belong to Kal-L?

Kal L didn't even exist until the 1960's. People think of Kal L as golden age Superman, but he really isn't, he's a separate character designed to explain plot holes...

Kal L didn't have Superboys (Or Earth 1 Supermans) power levels.. He had trouble handling an exploding nuke without Alan Scott and Wonder Woman's support, and still got knocked for a loop when he detonated.

Originally posted by cdtm
Kal L didn't even exist until the 1960's. People think of Kal L as golden age Superman, but he really isn't, he's a separate character designed to explain plot holes...

Kal L didn't have Superboys (Or Earth 1 Supermans) power levels.. He had trouble handling an exploding nuke without Alan Scott and Wonder Woman's support, and still got knocked for a loop when he detonated.

Not that I disagree with anything you've said... but you don't think it odd that Kal-L was basically the ultimate hero during Crisis on Infinite Earths while Kal-El took second billing? Even when Kal-El was supposed to be a more mature, seasoned, powerful Superboy?

Originally posted by Justforaminute
so u agree that green scar is stronger then world breaker? cool, then u agree that captain america would beat world breaker since he beat green scar

check and mate

When did Captain America beat green scar? Scans.

OneDumbGo:

I'm talking historically.

But yes, DC's stance has been that Kal L is the original, golden age Superman, even though there's continuity holes there..

In any event, the connection between Earth 1 Superman and Superboy with the Legion of Super Heroes is pretty firm, with flashback memories and crossover stories firmly establishing which Superman that Superboy is supposed to be.

Kal L was a Justice Society member, happily married to his Lois, and didn't really do any time traveling stories or even display the ability to travel through time under his own power.

^ In your opinion then, PC Superman's best feats (which are typically PC Superboy feats) must be somewhat diminished... since by the time Crisis on Infinite Earths rolled around... Kal-El was basically, at best, on par with Kal-L? Taking into accounts their full histories anyway...

A gang of mexicans with sledgehammers show up and beat them both to death.

Originally posted by abhilegend
If it were carver saying these things, I couldn't care less. It bothers me when galan007, one of the most respected poster and creator of pc superman respect thread lefts context

He just left a small detail

http://i1113.photobucket.com/albums/k508/abhilegend/Superman/DC_Comics_present032.jpg

I could care less about half of those things. I was just goofing around in that thread as I admitted but you even made a bait thread for me and challenged me for a battlezone and you are lecturing me on taking this too zealously. Real nice jake, real nice. Oh and doom would lose 10/10 to PC lex. He may take 1/10 against post crisis lex.😏

So take that up with Galan, then. And for the record, most of the forum would agree that Galan knows his shit without being bias anyway. And even then, he's not infallible. Regardless, if you feel it's like your personal mission to police the forum on behalf of Superman, you're going to do what you feel like doing anyway. It's just hard to take you seriously when you're painfully transparent about it.

I made a bait thread for you? Really? What was that?

I know because Lex Luthor is Superman's archenemy you feel you must back him up in some capacity (for whatever reason) but I'd suggest you read up on Dr. Doom before you jokingly or seriously attempt to contend that Luthor has anything on him at all. PC Lex's super MacGuvyer gimmicks still fall short of the numerous times Doom's obtained damn close to omnipotent power if you want to take them at their absolute best. Post Crisis Lex isn't worth Doom's time at all.

What ODG was forgetting or ignorant is "Kryptonite nevermore".