Manga comparison thread

Good:

Naruto: Reveal of the real Madara.
One Piece: Ace's death.
Bleach: "Whoever said the Espada go from 1-10?" 131

Bad:

Naruto: Nagato bringing all of Konoha back.
One Piece: Conis's dad being alive.
Bleach: Deicide. All of it.

Naruto: Madara kicking down the coffin's door and being a hilarious d***.
Bleach: Aizen forces Hitsugaya to stab his girlfriend, and to then have an orgasm.
One Piece: Who gives a **** about OP?

awesome

Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
Oh.....welll um let's try again

Bleach: Ichigo's first time using Bankai
Naruto: Sakura smashing the 3rd Kazekage puppet.

Did I really put Sakura as a WTF momment? Okay, I'm substituting that for the Madara reveal behind the coffin.

Shut up loser.

bawling

So I read HSDK for the sole fact Saiga makes his appearance. Well he has that insanely nice persona the rest of Yami guys start out with. Also he does this:

http://www.mangastream.com/read/hsdk/83185428/5
http://www.mangastream.com/read/hsdk/83185428/6

Saiga did turn out to be quite the badass (And that speed feat of his, with the jacket floating in mid-air in the time he did that, looks quantifiable).

... I sort of wish Miu's dad turned out to look like John though. That would be hilarious.

So. This is suppose to be a thread where we make justifications for why our opinions supersedes others's?

You don't have the ability to justify your opinions, ever. So you're banished from this thread. Banished!

Originally posted by Astner
So. This is suppose to be a thread where we make justifications for why our opinions supersedes others's?

If you want. It's mostly just a weekly manga discussion thread.

1. Bleach
2. Naruto
3. One Piece

One Piece spent too much time with stupid Centaurs and I wasn't a fan of Tashigi getting loloneshot. Not that I doubt Law could do it, I would just rather her have not fought Law. Still, seems to be setting up for some wacky hijinks. Naruto and Bleach were fairly close but I think I liked Bleach more. The reveals were more edgy. And hey, it's just so nice to see Nel again. Hopefully she'll amount to more than a filler character this time. ^_^

Bleach deserves the top spot in celebration of their first actual good-guy death.

I was amazed at how good Bleach was this week despite my complaints about it. Naruto was kind of decent though it's good to see Kabuto not be pwned so easily I supposed...the dude's still lame.

I like One Piece for the fact that Robin got to be in a hot pose while we get to see Law in action.

I don't know if there was an actual bad chapter this week but Bleach and Naruto tie IMO.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Bleach deserves the top spot in celebration of their first actual good-guy death.

Also Mangareader ****ing sucks. Half the pages don't load unless I refresh the page a few times.

My rating-

1) Bleach -Dude's pretty evil, and some major negative vibes, and it did have an actual death. Though I didn't like that we have another captive character thing.
2) One Piece- A couple cool bits, like Law doing stuff. It's pretty much tied at first.
3) FT- New character, some exposition
4) Naruto- Mostly exposition

Both 3 and 4 were exposition with a little fighting. I expect Naruto'll be better next week.

Overall, weak week.

I thought that the new sage mode was rather impressive. I always wondered if Orochimaru had something to rival Jiraiya's technique. Now I know what he didn't but also that Kabuto supposedly does.

I wanna see the new Sage Mode do something before I call it impressive 🙂

I do expect next week to do well based on that.

Originally posted by Q99
I wanna see the new Sage Mode do something before I call it impressive 🙂

Originally posted by Q99
I wanna see the new Sage Mode do something before I call it impressive 🙂

I do expect next week to do well based on that.

Giving Kabutomaru the ability to dodge Sasuke's arrow through just sensing.
Kakashi couldn't dodge it despite having the Sharingan.