Manga comparison thread

You should put a link to your review page in your sig.

Teach me oh wise one!

1. Toriko
2. Naruto
3. Bleach
4. One Piece

Originally posted by AuraAngel
Teach me oh wise one!

Just, y'know, make a link as usual, then go to your profile on the control panel and put it in 🙂

Seems easy enough.

And nice, now I can check it whenever I want without having to search the link up 🙂

Any opinions on ze reviews this week?

Lesse, OP- agree with it, not much to add.

Bleach- I liked Kenny crying more than you did.

Naruto- I'll note that when Kakashi did Gyuki, Gyuki was doing the 'hide in the tentacle' thing, not full-size. Anyway, that one nitpick aside, good observations

I like Aura's opinion on Tashigi in One Piece. So I guess I'm the only one annoyed by the "Giant Bird of Companionship" in Naruto.

No comment on Bleach though.

I'm not annoyed by it since it's well drawn and symbolic and shit. But it is so freaking silly that I can't imagine Kishimoto drawing it with a straight face because he doesn't realize how perfect the formation of this army has to be in order to resemble a bird lol.

Originally posted by Q99

Naruto- I'll note that when Kakashi did Gyuki, Gyuki was doing the 'hide in the tentacle' thing, not full-size. Anyway, that one nitpick aside, good observations

Gyūki was full-sized when Kakashi teleported him. Kakashi ended up missing the tentacle when he used Kamui the first time.

Originally posted by wakkawakkawakka
I like Aura's opinion on Tashigi in One Piece. So I guess I'm the only one annoyed by the "Giant Bird of Companionship" in Naruto.

No comment on Bleach though.

I didn't mind it. Aura's right in it being stupidly silly though from a certain standpoint. Moreso because these other random dudes that never knew Neji suddenly decided to be pissed about it and choreograph their movements in honour of him.

Would have been kewl if it had been a super special mega awesome team ultra combo bird construct that physically clashed with the Ten Tails though. dur

Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Gyūki was full-sized when Kakashi teleported him. Kakashi ended up missing the tentacle when he used Kamui the first time.

Oh, my mistake, but still, this looks like it's Bee turning into Gyuki.

Not the whole biju form.

It's a bit vague and later on it seems like Kakashi implies that he ported it all.

Originally posted by Q99
Oh, my mistake, but still, this looks like it's Bee turning into Gyuki.

Not the whole biju form.

Can't tell for certain, but based on this, I don't think he returned Bee who then transformed into Gyūki.
He still ported nearly the entirety of Gyūki into the other dimension the first time around though.

Kakashi could probably port the Ten-Tails into the other dimension with Kurama's current amp.

Originally posted by Demonic Phoenix
Can't tell for certain, but based on this, I don't think he returned Bee who then transformed into Gyūki.
He still ported nearly the entirety of Gyūki into the other dimension the first time around though.

Again, did he, or did he just 'port Bee?

I don't remember the scene of him going in.

Originally posted by Q99
Again, did he, or did he just 'port Bee?

I don't remember the scene of him going in.

Gyūki is fully transformed before Kakashi uses Kamui and a tentacle is left behind afterwards. So yeah, it's safe to say Bee never transformed back when Kakashi used Kamui on them.

Hm, maybe, but it didn't actually show the warp-out graphic. Bee could've at least partially retracted/shrunk down for the trip.

Originally posted by Q99
Hm, maybe, but it didn't actually show the warp-out graphic. Bee could've at least partially retracted/shrunk down for the trip.

His full-sized tentacle wouldn't be left behind if that were the case, and I don't think Bee's *that* fast at transforming.

Ah well. Naruto doesn't actually mess up that often, but it does occasionally.

Hm, the best I can think of is that a tripling of kamui's power triples not the area, but the diameter. Kakashi could do a person before, so 6 feet, but that might not even have been his max if he was slower about it.

Kinda a reach, admittedly.

Originally posted by Q99
Ah well. Naruto doesn't actually mess up that often, but it does occasionally.

Hm, the best I can think of is that a tripling of kamui's power triples not the area, but the diameter. Kakashi could do a person before, so 6 feet, but that might not even have been his max if he was slower about it.

Kinda a reach, admittedly.

It doesn't really bother me anyway. Kakashi's Kamui has been growing in power during this fight. While the fight itself has been fairly cool to watch, it has also been riddled with PIS.