Originally posted by quanchi112
He's successfully courted death. What romance doesn't have it's ups and downs. Oh right you don't date. Sorry. I wish you all the best on eharmony.
I work my magic on http://www.christianmingle.com
Originally posted by abhilegend
Actually the black hole was a miniature black hole and thanos wasn't explicitly shown in the black hole. His ship was destroyed in an attempt to escape and I think that thanos is fast enough to teleport before sucked in the black hole.
media.animevice.com/uploads/0/6253/492326-black11bj.jpgi160.photobucket.com/albums/t173/EndlessMike9/Thanos/thanosblackhole3.jpg
A black hole that can instantly suck in everything within a radius of 2 light years is not a miniature black hole. It's a super massive black hole, with a mass/weight of god knows how many suns, to be able to have that type of reach (and instantly too). But I'm not surprised a comic writer would make that mistake, it's not like learning astronomy is a pre-requisite to write comics. Although, it probably would help if you're writing sci-fi or cosmic stuff.
Also, I don't see any narration or art depiction that would suggest Thanos teleported away just before the black hole sucked everything in.
Originally posted by abhilegend
^That's not how it works. What was defined on panel is proof whether its right or wrong in real life. Comics don't follow real life science.
It also states everything within a 2 light year radius was sucked in instantly, this is big enough to engulf countless solar systems. If Starlin wants to call it a "miniature" black hole it's fine by me. But, labeling it as such doesn't diminish it's destructive power shown on panel.
That's like saying if an explosion destroys a planet, and the author labels it a small explosion, it some how makes it less impressive. Like you said, "that's not how it works".
Originally posted by vince_slice
A black hole that can instantly suck in everything within a radius of 2 light years is not a miniature black hole. It's a super massive black hole, with a mass/weight of god knows how many suns, to be able to have that type of reach (and instantly too). But I'm not surprised a comic writer would make that mistake, it's not like learning astronomy is a pre-requisite to write comics. Although, it probably would help if you're writing sci-fi or cosmic stuff.Also, I don't see any narration or art depiction that would suggest Thanos teleported away just before the black hole sucked everything in.
Ok, follow up research.
Currently the largest black hole known has an event horizon "about five times the distance between our sun and Pluto."
Distance from Sun to Pluto = 0.000624133538 light years
5x distance from Sun to Pluto = 0.00312066769 light years
A black hole with an event horizon of 4 light years is still about 1,282 times larger than the largest black hole ever recorded, if I've done my math correctly./
Originally posted by Cogito
Ok, follow up research.Currently the largest black hole known has an event horizon "about five times the distance between our sun and Pluto."
Distance from Sun to Pluto = 0.000624133538 light years
5x distance from Sun to Pluto = 0.00312066769 light yearsA black hole with an event horizon of 4 light years is still about 1,282 times larger than the largest black hole ever recorded, if I've done my math correctly./
Apparently this is suppose to be a "miniature" black hole, yet it's 1,282 times larger than the largest black hole recorded so far. I don't think Starlin knows how big 2 light years is.
If the diameter of the solar system is 0.001248 light years (assuming the radius of the solar system is from the sun to Pluto), and the black hole Thanos tanked was 4 light years in diameter, it would mean it was big enough to swallow 3,205 solar systems. This makes Superman tanking the equivalent of 50 supernovas look pretty miniscule doesn't it abhiligend? 😉
This is why I originally refrained from using calculations, because it starts to get ridiculous when applied to comics. I'll just use to qualitative approach, and say the black hole is really, really big and powerful.
Originally posted by Blight
So I guess the question becomes "Was it really 2 light years we believe Thanos Tanked" or"The author embelished how big it was and really it was a miniature black hole"
Sounds like the author is an idiot either way...
It was stated on panel to be 2 light years in radius, and the author labeling it as miniature won't change that fact. He could call the black hole anything he wants, it still wouldn't change the fact that it swallowed everything within 2 light years radius.
Originally posted by abhilegendI can't date myself ya weirdo.
Are you sad about it? nutnut
Originally posted by CogitoGo get em, ace.
I work my magic on http://www.christianmingle.com
Originally posted by vince_slice👆
It was stated on panel to be 2 light years in radius, and the author labeling it as miniature won't change that fact. He could call the black hole anything he wants, it still wouldn't change the fact that it swallowed everything within 2 light years radius.
Originally posted by vince_sliceI suppose so.
It was stated on panel to be 2 light years in radius, and the author labeling it as miniature won't change that fact. He could call the black hole anything he wants, it still wouldn't change the fact that it swallowed everything within 2 light years radius.
Unless Starlin is like my friend who said "Dude, did you see Jeremy? He ate like a MILLION chicken nuggets last night!!"
That's how I feel about Starlin's writing of Thanos, hahaha! Thanos is my friend's friend Jeremy.
Originally posted by abhilegendIt was shown nothing remained of the ship expect a small debris field whicjh Thanos was not amongst, let later teleported aboard a Skrull ship that was at the exact location 2 HOURS LATER.
Actually the black hole was a miniature black hole and thanos wasn't explicitly shown in the black hole. His ship was destroyed in an attempt to escape and I think that thanos is fast enough to teleport before sucked in the black hole.
media.animevice.com/uploads/0/6253/492326-black11bj.jpgi160.photobucket.com/albums/t173/EndlessMike9/Thanos/thanosblackhole3.jpg
Originally posted by Nihilist
It was shown nothing remained of the ship expect a small debris field whicjh Thanos was not amongst, let later teleported aboard a Skrull ship that was at the exact location 2 HOURS LATER.
Originally posted by Nihilist
Yeah if only Team 2 had a attack that covers omni directions!
