I want to say team 2, because I'm totally a sucker for Hulk, but I have to give it to team 1, only because of Sinestro.
In my mind, the biggest gun on the field are both Hulk and Thor, but Hulk is cruelly lacking in versatility, while Sinestro can replicate almost everything Thor can do.
I see Black Adam and Sinestro both beating Thor, then beat Hulk
Originally posted by quanchi112
How is Hulk a weak link ?
Hulk is in no way weak, but I think I understand where he's going.
Hulk can't flight, can't teleport, and don't posses ranged attack, while the three other can do everything I just listed. Sinestro can easely bfr Hulk far away too.
Basically, Hulk lacks versatility, not power. And it's the downfall of the team.
Originally posted by BouboumasterBlack Adam can be bfr'd by Thor.
Hulk is in no way weak, but I think I understand where he's going.Hulk can't flight, can't teleport, and don't posses ranged attack, while the three other can do everything I just listed. Sinestro can easely bfr Hulk far away too.
Basically, Hulk lacks versatility, not power. And it's the downfall of the team.
I saw what Mongul did to Sinestro. If Hulk gets his hands on him he'd do worse.
Originally posted by NewjakBlack Adam will engage him physically. Hulk is always a problem with those characters who have flight. Look at the sentry and Gladiator. Bricks in comics don't need versatility to be effective.
The OP did mention no BFR.I would say Team 1, mostly because Hulk is the weak link in this fight do to his lack of versatility.
The others can keep to the air and gang up on Thor. Adam would be a fight for Thor Sinestro tips the scales then they both finish of Hulk.
Originally posted by Newjak
The OP did mention no BFR.I would say Team 1, mostly because Hulk is the weak link in this fight do to his lack of versatility.
The others can keep to the air and gang up on Thor. Adam would be a fight for Thor Sinestro tips the scales then they both finish of Hulk.
Yeah, if Sinestro plays it smart, he has it.
Originally posted by quanchi112Black Adam has the strength to prove problematic plus he has his lightning fists to add that much more power to his attacks, and Sinestro backing him up. Hulk is tough but unless you start getting into Classic Juggernaut level durability you're not just tanking that kind of firepower.
Black Adam will engage him physically. Hulk is always a problem with those characters who have flight. Look at the sentry and Gladiator. Bricks in comics don't need versatility to be effective.
Originally posted by NewjakHulk has a healing factor on top of dynamic strength. Hulk's built to tank attacks. he's fought Thor for hours so yes he can take these guys best and come back swinging for more. Black Adam is the heavy hitter here I see Sinestro as the weak link.
Black Adam has the strength to prove problematic plus he has his lightning fists to add that much more power to his attacks, and Sinestro backing him up. Hulk is tough but unless you start getting into Classic Juggernaut level durability you're not just tanking that kind of firepower.
Originally posted by quanchi112Sinestro has the versatility to attack Hulk besides the physical. He's far from the weak link.
Hulk has a healing factor on top of dynamic strength. Hulk's built to tank attacks. he's fought Thor for hours so yes he can take these guys best and come back swinging for more. Black Adam is the heavy hitter here I see Sinestro as the weak link.
And I'm not saying Hulk will go down easy nor Thor for that matter but Team one has the advantages that count to make this 2 on 1 and there isn't anything team 2 can do about it. Hulk can't fly that's a big drawback here.
2 vs 1 Team 1 is taking down Hulk.
2 vs 1 Team 1 is taking down Thor.
Originally posted by NewjakDid you read how he fared against Mongul Jr. ? Yeah, he's the weak link here.
Sinestro has the versatility to attack Hulk besides the physical. He's far from the weak link.And I'm not saying Hulk will go down easy nor Thor for that matter but Team one has the advantages that count to make this 2 on 1 and there isn't anything team 2 can do about it. Hulk can't fly that's a big drawback here.
2 vs 1 Team 1 is taking down Hulk.
2 vs 1 Team 1 is taking down Thor.
Doomsday nor could Konvikt fly yet they were huge problems. Not being able to fly doesn't mean much in comics. If it did then Gladiator wouldn't have an issue with the Hulk nor would Thor nor would the Sentry.
Originally posted by quanchi112You mean a Mongul JR who was using Yellow Rings? It's not exactly an apples to apples comparison.
Did you read how he fared against Mongul Jr. ? Yeah, he's the weak link here.Doomsday nor could Konvikt fly yet they were huge problems. Not being able to fly doesn't mean much in comics. If it did then Gladiator wouldn't have an issue with the Hulk nor would Thor nor would the Sentry.
And Thor normally lowers himself to fight on Hulk's level, he could just as easily BFR Hulk if he wanted to or pelt Hulk with high damage attacks from afar until Hulk gets put down.
The other people are generally plot driven. People in danger kind of scenarios generally.
This isn't the case once Thor gets taken down cause he's the only person who can actually go engage them in that air. Team 1 can take their sweet time dealing with the Hulk.
Originally posted by NewjakMongul was physically above him. The only reason Sinestro won was due to his power over the rings which superceded Mongul's.
You mean a Mongul JR who was using Yellow Rings? It's not exactly an apples to apples comparison.And Thor normally lowers himself to fight on Hulk's level, he could just as easily BFR Hulk if he wanted to or pelt Hulk with high damage attacks from afar until Hulk gets put down.
The other people are generally plot driven. People in danger kind of scenarios generally.
This isn't the case once Thor gets taken down cause he's the only person who can actually go engage them in that air. Team 1 can take their sweet time dealing with the Hulk.
Bfr is out here. You said he can't take that kind of firepower than respond with a post agreeing he does tank Thor's firepower.
Comics are plot driven. We argue based off of comics not powersets.
This is just silly. Hulk can jump and used thunderclaps to engage them. Black Adam will punch him in the face. That's how he fights.
Originally posted by quanchi112The point was that Mongul was physically above him in addition to the power the rings gave him. He had the added bonus of being versatile enough to go engage Sinestro. Sinestro couldn't just keep Mongul at a distance like he can with Hulk.
Mongul was physically above him. The only reason Sinestro won was due to his power over the rings which superceded Mongul's.Bfr is out here. You said he can't take that kind of firepower than respond with a post agreeing he does tank Thor's firepower.
Comics are plot driven. We argue based off of comics not powersets.
This is just silly. Hulk can jump and used thunderclaps to engage them. Black Adam will punch him in the face. That's how he fights.
Hulk won't be able to take that kind of fire power for prolonged times. And where did I say he tanks Thor's firepower. I said Thor generally fights down to Hulk's level which is purely physical and still holds his own.
BA also has the added bonus of probably being the fastest person in the thread so if he doesn't want Hulk to touch him Hulk won't be touching him.
Did you really suggest Hulk is going to be getting to lightspeed capable fliers by jumping and thunder clapping?
Originally posted by NewjakNeither can Sinestro. Like I said look at Thor, Gladiator, and the Sentry.
The point was that Mongul was physically above him in addition to the power the rings gave him. He had the added bonus of being versatile enough to go engage Sinestro. Sinestro couldn't just keep Mongul at a distance like he can with Hulk.Hulk won't be able to take that kind of fire power for prolonged times. And where did I say he tanks Thor's firepower. I said Thor generally fights down to Hulk's level which is purely physical and still holds his own.
BA also has the added bonus of probably being the fastest person in the thread so if he doesn't want Hulk to touch him Hulk won't be touching him.
Thor bashes him in the head and Hulk takes it. He has taken it for hours yet here he can't take their kind of abuse. You admit he can. Black Adam will fight him physically. Guess who that benefits ? it ain't Black Adam.
We argue how they fight in character. Not how you ignore everything and pretend bfr is on for this thread.