Hulk vs Superman: fighting for love

Started by OneDumbG035 pages
OneDumbG0 Find Your Own Fire

Originally posted by CosmicComet
There is no theory here. Simply fact.

Hulk's energy projection is shown doing damage to the environment even while he's simply in one spot roid raging up.

Thus, logically, it contributes. Who's asking for a divorce? I'm asking for an acknowledgement of a consolidation of two factors clearly at work.

Yeah, that's what people said about nearly all of Superman's impressive strength feats which almost invariably involve flight save for one or two feats. Forgive my disbelief.

Let's change "Hulk strongest there is!!!" to "Hulk most energy projectiony there is!!!"

🙄

Sr J-Bieb Dead

GREEN ENERGY!!!
http://i1099.photobucket.com/albums/g386/psychogundam1/hulk6.jpg
http://i1099.photobucket.com/albums/g386/psychogundam1/hulk7.jpg

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Show the entire scene.

He's not doing anywhere near the kind of damage he is when he's leaking energy like a broken pipe.

He's taking several steps in that scan and all I see is some ambiguously loud sound effect and a little rubble around his feet, and then only in the final panel.

Where do you see several steps? That was one step.

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Yeah, that's what people said about nearly all of Superman's impressive strength feats which almost invariably involve flight save for one or two feats. Forgive my disbelief.

Let's change "Hulk strongest there is!!!" to "Hulk most energy projectiony there is!!!"

🙄

😆

CosmicComet Senior Member

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Yeah, that's what people said about nearly all of Superman's impressive strength feats which almost invariably involve flight save for one or two feats. Forgive my disbelief.

Let's change "Hulk strongest there is!!!" to "Hulk most energy projectiony there is!!!"

🙄

You certainly are bitter.

But just to clarify where I stand and have always stood, I absolutely agree that flight adds an ambiguous element to some of Superman's physical feats.

Logically, it HAS to;

Superman pulling the Earth with Hal's construct harness...obviously he's not standing on solid ground pulling the Earth. And his flight comes from some other mysterious part of Kryptonian biology, not his muscles. So what is going on here? Obviously on a purely physical level it is at least a durability feat that his body can withstand the strain of the harness on him pulling the Earth.

The thing about Superman is, he has amazing strength feats outside of simply pushing or pulling shit in space with the horsepower of his flight behind him. 😄

Sr J-Bieb Dead

Originally posted by CosmicComet
You certainly are bitter.
Stopped reading

CosmicComet Senior Member

I'm sure there's some Iron Fist thread out there that would be better served with your meager attention, bruh.

Sr J-Bieb Dead

Originally posted by CosmicComet
I'm sure there's some Iron Fist thread out there that would be better served with your meager attention, bruh.
At least I'd have a shred of knowledge on both combatants.

I just find it ironic that ODG is the bitter one, when you have a sig of Superman ripping off Hulk's head in your sig, and have a great general hatred of him... matched by how little you know of him.

OneDumbG0 Find Your Own Fire

Originally posted by CosmicComet
You certainly are bitter.

But just to clarify where I stand and have always stood, I absolutely agree that flight adds an ambiguous element to some of Superman's physical feats.

Jebus christ on a stick. facepalm
Originally posted by CosmicComet
Logically, it HAS to;

Superman pulling the Earth with Hal's construct harness...obviously he's not standing on solid ground pulling the Earth. And his flight comes from some other mysterious part of Kryptonian biology, not his muscles. So what is going on here? Obviously on a purely physical level it is at least a durability feat that his body can withstand the strain of the harness on him pulling the Earth.

Well, you're certainly committed to these types of theories. So at least you're not being blindly hypocritical about it...
Originally posted by CosmicComet

The thing about Superman is, he has amazing strength feats outside of simply pushing or pulling shit in space with the horsepower of his flight behind him. 😄
... except when you are being blindly hypocritical about it. carver9 already showed you one of WBH's footsteps shaking the entire North American continent without gamma energy splashing everywhere. Nice try.

CosmicComet Senior Member

Why would I be bitter?

Superman has better feats in all mediums, and has a perfect record against the Hulk to the general public. Being a Superman fan is refreshing like that. 😄

I'd be bitter if I was a Thor fan with him holding the Hulk's severed head. 😄

Sr J-Bieb Dead

I don't know why, but you are.

Look at how mad you got when you heard Hulk was going to be a big deal in the Avengers for example.

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by CosmicComet
Why would I be bitter?

Superman has better feats in all mediums, and has a perfect record against the Hulk to the general public. Being a Superman fan is refreshing like that. 😄

I'd bitter if I was a Thor fan holding the Hulk's severed head. 😄

No he doesn't.

CosmicComet Senior Member
Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Jebus christ on a stick. facepalm Well, you're certainly committed to these types of theories. So at least you're not being blindly hypocritical about it... ... except when you are being blindly hypocritical about it. carver9 already showed you one of WBH's footsteps shaking the entire North American continent without gamma energy splashing everywhere. Nice try.

It seems to me you're just further bitter now since you can't use that line of logic against me. So, you're trying to further find reasons to be mad. I applaud the begrudging respect from it though.

And no, Carver showed me a scene where Hulk is taking several steps. And only in the final panel is there any sort of ambiguously loud sound apparent in the scene, and some crackling in the ground. And the damage was nowhere near what he was doing when he was hulking up with energy around him as well.

And seeing as I said his collateral damage potential is part strength *and* part ambient energy flow, it contradicted absolutely nothing I said.

CosmicComet Senior Member

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
I don't know why, but you are.

Look at how mad you got when you heard Hulk was going to be a big deal in the Avengers for example.

That had nothing to do with Superman though.

That just had to do with my major dislike for the Hulk as a character on his own.

There's nothing bitter about being able to say something along the lines of Superman being able to blitz the shit out of the Hulk. That's just comfortably knowing feats.

Sr J-Bieb Dead

Originally posted by CosmicComet
That had nothing to do with Superman though.

That just had to do with my major dislike for the Hulk as a character on his own.

There's nothing bitter about being able to say something along the lines of Superman being able to blitz the shit out of the Hulk. That's just comfortably knowing feats.


So you're incredibly bitter about Hulk and Hulk related things...

Way to show me!

Zack Fair Fanboy

Totally see them fighting with this background music
YouTube video

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
So you're incredibly bitter about Hulk and Hulk related things...

Way to show me!

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=563909&pagenumber=2

OneDumbG0 Find Your Own Fire

Originally posted by CosmicComet
It seems to me you're just further bitter now since you can't use that line of logic against me. So, you're trying to further find reasons to be mad. I applaud the begrudging respect from it though.
I'm frustrated that you think Superman's flight somehow detracts from Superman's strength. It's a retarded theory. It doesn't even matter unless we're speaking of some KMC contest where Superman must lift things and he cannot fly. Of course, considering your half-stepping hypocrisy, doubt you'd be the first to jump in that thread and point out this moron theory.
Originally posted by CosmicComet
And no, Carver showed me a scene where Hulk is taking several steps. And only in the final panel is there any sort of ambiguously loud sound apparent in the scene, and some crackling in the ground. And the damage was nowhere near what he was doing when he was hulking up with energy around him as well.
Nowhere near the damage being done like in World War Hulk except the same lil old couple in Greenwich, Connecticut was commenting on the same tremors again (only this time Hulk was in Washington D.C. and not in Manhattan). You're trying to convince me that the damage WBH did in World War Hulk was not similar to the damage done in World War Hulks? They got John Romita Jr to come back for a single page to illustrate the similarity:

World War Hulk #5:

Incredible Hulks #610:

Originally posted by CosmicComet
And seeing as I said his collateral damage potential is part strength *and* part ambient energy flow, it contradicted absolutely nothing I said.
Except where pure strength did what so-called part-strength and part-energy projection did. Do yourself a favor. Give it up.

carver9 Senior Member
Originally posted by Zack Fair
Totally see them fighting with this background music
YouTube video

Lol...I can see that.

CosmicComet Senior Member

Originally posted by Sr J-Bieb
So you're incredibly bitter about Hulk and Hulk related things...

Way to show me!

I'm still confused at what you think you're even attempting to do here.

I called ODG's post bitter, because he provided a sarcastic post that didn't address anything that I had said, but simply commented on some feeling of disparity he feels he has seen with the scrutiny of Superman's feats being waved off.

But unfortunately for him, he didn't trap me in some back-peddling contradiction for the scenario and I fairly acknowledged his critique and agreed with it.

So, how am I being bitter exactly? I didn't deny Hulk any feats, and I acknowledged criticism towards certain Superman feats as well using the same sort of scrutinizing that I am applying for the Hulk.