Phoenix (x-men movies) VS Thor (marvel movies)

in a fight between these two powerhouse's, who wins? (Both characters are from the Marvel movies)

Phoenix Jean Grey

VS

Thor

Imo Jean Grey

As a matter of fact I believe overall main mutants were portrayed as more powerful as the heroes in Marvel.

I'm going to say Thor.

Jean was essentially a sentient bomb but even in her biggest display of power I didn't see her do anything I don't think Thor would have been able to survive nor match.

While Jean was still as physically fragile as a normal human being.

Originally posted by biensalsa
Imo Jean Grey

As a matter of fact I believe overall main mutants were portrayed as more powerful as the heroes in Marvel.

Really? I thought the potrayal of heroes in Marvel movies vary greatly from character to character.

IMO Thor is more powerful than Phoenix, but he doesn't really have any defense against her powerset, and I can see her pulling his body apart.

Originally posted by Lord Feron
Really? I thought the potrayal of heroes in Marvel movies vary greatly from character to character.

I have the impression of mutants being really really powerful compared to metas.

Like Professor X being capable of killing everybody in the planet or Jean being even a level 5 mutant even more powerful than Professor X

Though I watched the Thor movie again yesterday and the Avengers Movie didn't give him any love at all.

But I believe mutants were treated as very powerful and very dangerous.

Not saying Thor is not powerful or Jean as Phoenix isn't but I am going for the movies showings.

Professor X requires Cerebro for that feat.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Professor X requires Cerebro for that feat.

Yes You are correct, I forgot about Cerebro.

Now, I am rethinking about Thor and He was treated very unfair in the Avengers movie. Compared to his own Movie where at the beginning He looked pretty good.

I guess Marvel wanted to inject new life into the Hulk franchise, which I guess they did it completely, because everybody is talking about the Hulk and How Hulk was one of the favorites.

it gives me the impression they basically sacrificed Thor for Hulk

I say Thor only because was very Fragile and I don't think it would take more than 1 hammer strike to do the trick.

Jean couldn't rip apart Wolverine. I don't think she could atomize Thor either then.

I can see Thor blasting her with lightning, which her TK shields will block, and then throwing his hammer at her face, which I'm not sure she'd be able to block.

I'd side with Thor for the majority.

Originally posted by Glorificus
Jean couldn't rip apart Wolverine.

She wasn't trying to.

Phoenix. She could block a hammer toss with TK, and likely disintegrate Thor. She turned buildings, tanks, hummers, jets and people to dust effortlessly (corny scene with Wolverine notwithstanding), blocked Cyclops optic blasts from emitting using her tk, held off a flood while simultaneously blocking Nightcrawler's teleportation attempt and controlling the Blackbird, and as a kid levitated every car on her block. IMO she has the offense and multitasking ability to beat Movie Thor.

Originally posted by MF DELPH
held off a flood while simultaneously blocking Nightcrawler's teleportation attempt and controlling the Blackbird

You missed one more - she telepathically took control of Xavier to talk to Scott.

Thor decapitates Jean with a hammer throw.

The End.

Originally posted by Zack Fair
Thor decapitates Jean with a hammer throw.

The End.

Thor can't even move if DP doesn't allow it.

Thor gets disintegrated.

The End.

Originally posted by Placidity
Thor can't even move if DP doesn't allow it.

Thor gets disintegrated.

The End.

Like Wolvie right?

Jean intentionally didn't kill Wolverine. Prior to that cornball scene she'd dusted Arclight and a bunch of other mutants/soldiers, as well as the Blackbird and the building. She wanted Wolverine to stop her. She could have tk'd him into space or ripped him apart if she wanted.

Intentionally didn't kill Wolverine? I don't know about that. She still burnt him to his very bones, but she couldn't destroy the adamantium and he healed at a pace that makes Bana Hulk a crybaby.

Originally posted by biensalsa
Yes You are correct, I forgot about Cerebro.

Now, I am rethinking about Thor and He was treated very unfair in the Avengers movie. Compared to his own Movie where at the beginning He looked pretty good.

I guess Marvel wanted to inject new life into the Hulk franchise, which I guess they did it completely, because everybody is talking about the Hulk and How Hulk was one of the favorites.

it gives me the impression they basically sacrificed Thor for Hulk

Originally posted by psycho gundam
the church of gamma is taking in a lot of new followers 🙂

*Bornagain Hulkster*