What if WBH?

Since I arrive Here I read this notion of WBH being ubber powerful, because He melted Heralds, personally I think this is a silly idea, but I want to get what is the consensus around here, so in order to do this, WHAT IF We replace the victims of Hulk for established Heralds.

This is the scenario

Hulk and Betty are about to bust a planet in the Dark Dimension, but this time instead of Mindless ones, Wendigo, Arm'chedon, Bi-Beast and Fin-Fan-Foom watching the fight. We have Gladiator, GL John Stewart, GL Kyle Ryner, BRB and Galactus Heralds (Terrax, Silver Surfer, Morg, Star Dust)

What will it be the most likely result after the planet buster?

1.- The Heralds are melted due to the incredible power of the Hulk.

2.- The Heralds are fine and they say nothing to Hulk since they are aware Hulk can potentially can bust a planet since 1970

The more douchey guys go for option 2. The rest go #3, but not out of fear.

Originally posted by Cogito
The more douchey guys go for option 2. The rest go #3, but not out of fear.

That is a good point I should remove option 2

it was more than one planet by the way.

it was 3 large objects he busted ,and people assumed the other 2 were moons (i dont)

Originally posted by Colossus-Big C
it was more than one planet by the way.

it was 3 large objects he busted ,and people assumed the other 2 were moons (i dont)

I respectfully disagree, I took a hard look at the feat and I never saw the moons getting destroyed.

I see the atmosphere of the planet flying away from the planet, but I no where during the feat I see the moons getting destroyed.

I can tell you for sure the Planet is destroyed, but I can't tell you for sure the moons were.

but I want to know if the Heralds will get melted. We could argue about the moons on some other thread.

Do you believe the Heralds will get melted?

Hulk destroyed them with nothing but the backwash of an attack. It's nothing more than just an opening attack from WBH.

Originally posted by janus77
Hulk destroyed them with nothing but the backwash of an attack. It's nothing more than just an opening attack from WBH.

Are You talking about the moons? because if so, I will rather this to be focused on the heralds, not the moons.

Originally posted by biensalsa
Are You talking about the moons? because if so, I will rather this to be focused on the heralds, not the moons.

Who knows what damage WBH would do if he got madder/amped.

And as far as I recall, he destroyed the Dark Dimension, Umar even sates this, not just one planet.

Originally posted by janus77
I'm saying that however much you downplay it, the feat is even more spectacular when you consider that it was basically an opening punch.

Who knows what damage WBH would do if he got madder/amped.

And as far as I recall, he destroyed the Dark Dimension, Umar even sates this, not just one planet.

OK? I want to know if You think those heralds will get melted.

I did not open this thread to discuss about the moons, but even if You think the moons were destroyed or the whole dimension got destroyed. Just replace the victims with those heralds stated above and tell me if you believe they get melted.

So, same feat, but this time We replace the victims. You believe they get melted?

Some would be dead, some would be koed, all would be affected greatly. This equivocation about "planet busting" while glossing over how the planet is actually destroyed (and the vast differences in power they indicate) in order to downplay WBH is straight silly.

Originally posted by Naija boy
Some would be dead, some would be koed, all would be affected greatly. This equivocation about "planet busting" while glossing over how the planet is actually destroyed (and the vast differences) in order to downplay WBH is straight silly.

OK, Thank you for your response 🙂

Who do you think will be dead? and who do you think will be KO'ed?

All of them would die unless someone can show me something comparable to this...

We know that the heat of said blast was the reason everyone melted. Here we have beings, the Mindless Ones withstanding the temperatures and the pressure of a NEUTRON STAR...

http://i287.photobucket.com/albums/ll121/kingaholu/MindlessonesNeutron.jpg

Here we also have Nova Prime, someone that has high Herald+ energy attack being unable to even pinch the Mindless Ones skin.

http://m287.photobucket.com/albumview/albums/kingaholu/Hulk%20feats/Mindlessonesnearlyindestructible-1.jpg.html?o=120

They died from the impact of Hulk colliding. I can't see any Herald withstanding what is shown in the scans above, especially with no damage. Lord Marvell had to shield himself from Nova attacks.

You all using Bi Beast, Wendigo, and Armageddon as evidence...that wasnt all that was destroyed...some of the most durable races in comics was destroyed as well...beings that the great Umar and Dormammu can't stop.

Originally posted by carver9
All of them would die unless someone can show me something comparable to this...

We know that the heat of said blast was the reason everyone melted. Here we have beings, the Mindless Ones withstanding the temperatures and the pressure of a NEUTRON STAR...

http://i287.photobucket.com/albums/ll121/kingaholu/MindlessonesNeutron.jpg

Here we also have Nova Prime, someone that has high Herald+ energy attack being unable to even pinch the Mindless Ones skin.

http://m287.photobucket.com/albumview/albums/kingaholu/Hulk%20feats/Mindlessonesnearlyindestructible-1.jpg.html?o=120

They died from the impact of Hulk colliding. I can't see any Herald withstanding what is shown in the scans above, especially with no damage. Lord Marvell had to shield himself from Nova attacks.

You all using Bi Beast, Wendigo, and Armageddon as evidence...that wasnt all that was destroyed...some of the most durable races in comics was destroyed as well...beings that the great Umar and Dormammu can't stop.

I see your point Carver, but this tells me otherwise.

http://i647.photobucket.com/albums/uu200/biensalsa/Marvel%20Comics/AmazingSpider-ManV2057-12.jpg

http://i647.photobucket.com/albums/uu200/biensalsa/Marvel%20Comics/AmazingSpider-ManV2057-15.jpg

^Different portrayals and low feat just like every character has. The mindless ones in the issue were in totality mentioned as being too much for even Umar to survive on her own so they must have been operating at a powerful level. They were not being treated like fodder level characters and pak makes that point clear. I could show an example of most of the characters within the OP, getting koed by far less than the attack in the dark dimension. Im sure however that you would be up in arms about how that is not a true representation of them and what not so dont attempt to use reasoning that you would obviously not agree with regularly to denigrate WBH

Originally posted by biensalsa
I see your point Carver, but this tells me otherwise.

http://i647.photobucket.com/albums/uu200/biensalsa/Marvel%20Comics/AmazingSpider-ManV2057-12.jpg

http://i647.photobucket.com/albums/uu200/biensalsa/Marvel%20Comics/AmazingSpider-ManV2057-15.jpg

Lol...that's a low ft NUT. Their recent, (key word, recent) portrayal is what I am basing this off of. Doctor Strange, Umar, and Nova Prime recently being unable to stop them and them also.walking in the heart of.a NEUTRON star is proof enough of this. Every character have low showings...EVERY CHARACTER (including Superman).

Their average portrayal have them tanking attacks from the entire Xmen...have Gladiator fleeing for help, tanking blows frlm Savage Hulk, Dormammu, Classic Strange, Umar...etc, etc...

Originally posted by Naija boy
^Different portrayals and low feat just like every character has. The mindless ones in the issue were in totality mentioned as being too much for even Umar to survive on her own so they must have been operating at a powerful level. They were not being treated like fodder level characters and pak makes that point clear. I could show an example of most of the characters within the OP, getting koed by far less than the attack in the dark dimension. Im sure however that you would be up in arms about how that is not a true representation of them and what not so dont attempt to use reasoning that you would obviously not agree with regularly to denigrate WBH

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...that's a low ft NUT. Their recent, (key word, recent) portrayal is what I am basing this off of. Doctor Strange, Umar, and Nova Prime recently being unable to stop them and them also.walking in the heart of.a NEUTRON star is proof enough of this. Every character have low showings...EVERY CHARACTER (including Superman).

Their average portrayal have them tanking attacks from the entire Xmen...have Gladiator fleeing for help, tanking blows frlm Savage Hulk, Dormammu, Classic Strange, Umar...etc, etc...

Lest make this fair and put high ends for all the parties involved shall we?

Do they get melted?

Originally posted by biensalsa
Lest make this fair and put high ends for both side shall we?

Do they get melted?

Does the High Heralds have fts of withstanding attacks from skyfathers with no issue along with walking in the heart of a Neutron star or something greater with no damage or worry at all?

What Herald can tank an attack from Nova Prime? If you look at everything as a hole, no high Herald is surviving that attack...if you want to use the lowest showing of every character that was in the dark Dimension when this happen, then yes, some could but it would have to go both ways, we would have to use the lowest of showings for every character involved if you want to play that card.

Originally posted by carver9
Does the High Heralds have fts of withstanding attacks from skyfathers with no issue along with walking in the heart of a Neutron star or something greater with no damage or worry at all?

What Herald can tank an attack from Nova Prime? If you look at everything as a hole, no high Herald is surviving that attack...if you want to use the lowest showing of every character that was in the dark Dimension when this happen, then yes, some could but it would have to go both ways, we would have to use the lowest of showings for every character involved if you want to play that card.

The heralds have survived worse than that and You should know this.

Originally posted by biensalsa
Lest make this fair and put high ends for all the parties involved shall we?

Do they get melted?

Answer stays the same. Some die, Some are koed, all are greatly affected.

Originally posted by Naija boy
Answer stays the same. Some die, Some are koed, all are greatly affected.

Ok, I disagree, as I don't see any reason why the heralds should die, but like I say, this is to see what is the general consensus around.