The League of Extraordinary Gentleman Vs The Avengers · Movie Versus Forum

NemeBro Senior Member

Reported.

Lord Lucien Lets all love Lain

Deported.

Impediment Endless

The fact that Dorian can't be killed means jack shit because he can still be subdued, therefore not being able to fight and win.

Hulk can solo the entire League.

Why is this even past page one?

Badabing Gym rat

Originally posted by Impediment
The fact that Dorian can't be killed means jack shit because he can still be subdued, therefore not being able to fight and win.
Hulk can solo the entire League.
Why is this even past page one?

I think we have a rogue poster in this thread. biscuits

Mr. Tibbs Senior Member

Originally posted by Impediment
The fact that Dorian can't be killed means jack shit because he can still be subdued, therefore not being able to fight and win.
Hulk can solo the entire League.
Why is this even past page one?

I just assumed that each combatant must be killed in order to achieve a win.

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by Mr. Tibbs
I just assumed that each combatant must be killed in order to achieve a win.

Why?

Mr. Tibbs Senior Member

Originally posted by Silent Master
Why?

No idea. Some matches it can be decreed that victory only comes when the opposition is destroyed, right?

Silent Master Senior Member

If the thread starter wanted that to be a condition of victory, yes.

However the thread starter never set that as a condition and you were told several times that death wasn't needed to win, yet you kept arguing that them being "immortal" meant that they couldn't lose.

Mr. Tibbs Senior Member

I argued only that the Avengers not having Grey's painting meant that the Avengers have no way of destroying him.

Newjak I am Beyond Power

What if they threw him into space, his body wouldn't be able to regenerate.

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by Mr. Tibbs
I argued only that the Avengers not having Grey's painting meant that the Avengers have no way of destroying him.

You argued that the League won because of Nina and Dorian.

Originally posted by Mr. Tibbs
League. Everyone dies except for Nina and Dorian.

Mr. Tibbs Senior Member

Originally posted by Silent Master
You argued that the League won because of Nina and Dorian.

At first yes, but then I changed up. Problem?

Impediment Endless

The LXG have nothing that can beat the Avengers.

Hulk stomps Hyde.

Iron Man sees Skinner and zaps him.

Cap, Hawkeye, and Widow KO Quatermain, Nemo, and Sawyer.

Thor KOs Mina.

Dorian is the wild card that can't be KOd or killed, but can easily be subdued, thus ensuring a victory for the Avengers.

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by Mr. Tibbs
At first yes, but then I changed up. Problem?

You changed it to the fight being a draw because Dorian couldn't be destroyed(which is a no limits fallacy).

BTW, did you forget that Asgardians are also "immortal" seeing as the Thor movie showed Odin being alive back in 965AD?

Mr. Tibbs Senior Member

Originally posted by Impediment
The LXG have nothing that can beat the Avengers.
Hulk stomps Hyde.
Iron Man sees Skinner and zaps him.
Cap, Hawkeye, and Widow KO Quatermain, Nemo, and Sawyer.
Thor KOs Mina.
Dorian is the wild card that can't be KOd or killed, but can easily be subdued, thus ensuring a victory for the Avengers.

I can go with this. As I said, I didn't know subduing someone could count towards a victory.

Somehow I feel the need to type that in bold text......

Robtard Senor Member

^
^
That doesn't mean the Asgardians are immortal, they could have extremely long lifespans compared to humans. Even in The Avengers its hinted that they could not be immortal.

Mr. Tibbs Senior Member

Originally posted by Silent Master
You changed it to the fight being a draw because Dorian couldn't be destroyed(which is a no limits fallacy).

Gee, did I really? *crosses eyes and tries to hump a doorknob*

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by Robtard
^
^
That doesn't mean the Asgardians are immortal, they could have extremely long lifespans compared to humans. Even in The Avengers its hinted that they could not be immortal.

I suppose you mean the comment Loki made before ejecting the cage, Thor survived that fall with zero injures.

It's not like Dorian was really immortal either, seeing as he died at the end of the movie.

Robtard Senor Member

Originally posted by Silent Master
I suppose you mean the comment Loki made before ejecting the cage, Thor survived that fall with zero injures.
It's not like Dorian was really immortal either, seeing as he died at the end of the movie.

Being durable isn't being immortal.

Immortal in the sense that Dorian doesn't age and won't die due to aging or conventional means; not "can't be killed ever". Which [the former] is how immortal is more often used, at least in films. Vampires, werewolves etc.

True immortality means being completely exempt from death. Asgardians aren't, as Odin hinted that the war with the Frost Giants cost Asgard dearly, I doubt he was talking about financials.

Mr. Tibbs Senior Member

Originally posted by Silent Master

It's not like Dorian was really immortal either, seeing as he died at the end of the movie.

He was immortal as long as he did not look at his painting. If he had not looked at it at the end, he would have lived.

This is why I said the Avengers cannot destroy him unless they have his painting.