Jack Bauer vs John McClane

Started by Robtard51 pages

"Movie Feats", brah.

Originally posted by Lestov16

If you are choosing to ignore his feats becausethey are too much, then it's okay. I'll accept your concession

Well fortunate for the McArgument that thats not even remotely the case, then.

Still waiting on those movie feats....

See 24: Redemption

And what were Bauer's box office feats compared to McClane's...?

Tell us....

Like I said, if you wish to ignore his feats that's fine with me. I'l accept that as your concession. You're still saying that you need to gimp his feats in order for McClane to take him

Bauer Wins 🙂

Like I said, what does BO prove? Transformers Dark of the Moon was better than DH4, according to you 😂

Not quite. But it does prove that they were released movies.
So I'll take your total, complete and utter lack of citation of moviefeats as concession.

McClane wins. 🙂

(The Waltons had a TV movie. John Boy was a member of the exclusive, mad, bad dangerous to know "JB club" too, I take it...)

Originally posted by Lestov16
List his feats. Okay:

Saved LA from a Nuclear weapon/Halted Thermonuclear WWIII

Saved the Country from a pandemic

Saved the Country from SecDef being assassinated live, 106 nuclear meltdowns, and a nuclear weapon being detonated on the East Coast

Saved country from nerve gas attacks (in a hospital, mall, and a natural gas station that would have killed tens of thousands) and Trident missile attack (which would ahve killed hundreds of thousands)/ Took on The POTUS

Saved the coutnry from suicide bombers and 4 suitcase nuclear detonations

Saved 16,000 from pesticide plant/ Saved US from missiles loaded with bioweapons/ Halted Thermonuclear WWIII

You can also watch some of them in a video located in my signature

If you are choosing to ignore his feats then it's okay. I'll accept your concession

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Not quite. But it does prove that they were released movies.
So I'll take your total, complete and utter lack of citation of moviefeats as concession.

McClane wins. 🙂

Sorry, not based on screenfeats, which you are hypocritically both whining for and ignoring in the same post 😂

Now now now...

You've flouted MVF rules all the way...lets not render yourself a hypocrit for the 316,000th time by now expecting that you can accuse others somehow of underhanded tacticry....!!

🙂

SADLY........................

No.

There have been numerous Star Wars threads on this forum which have allowed characters to retain their EU feats. And it was already stated that TV-Movies count as movies (which is why Bauer is allowed in the first place) So, nice try...

So when did McClane stop Thermonuclear WWIII last? 😂

24 is a TV show; not a film. See?

I've already stated at numerous times that I'm willing to dismiss Bauer's television feats if you conceded that if Bauer retained those his television feats, he would outclass McClane, which is true.

Your argument is that even with Bauer's television feats, McClane still outclasses him, which, with empirical evidence in the form of videos and posts listing his feats, I have proven incorrect. You, however, illogically still believe otherwise, and refuse to concede due to not an intelligent argument based on the evidence, but instead a bias.

Lestov, I asked nicely and I have no quarrel. What were Bauer's movie feats?

The 2 hour specials count as movies, for me. So...any 24 episode that was 2 hours, I'll take into consideration.

Saving the east coast from a thermonuclear bomb is not a feat, by the way. The feat would be juggling 15 different experts on the phone while dodging bullets, while killing bad guys with a hand gun that only has 8 bullets, while strangling people, and while disarming the nuke with no prior knowledge of the nuke's design.

That would be the feat/s. Just saying, "he saved the east coast from a bomb" is not a feat...unless you meant he was like Mr. Fantastic with invulnerability and covered up the bomb and absorbed the whole blast.

Originally posted by Lestov16
I've already stated at numerous times that I'm willing to dismiss Bauer's television feats if you conceded that if Bauer retained those his television feats, he would outclass McClane, which is true.

Your argument is that even with Bauer's television feats, McClane still outclasses him, which, with empirical evidence in the form of videos and posts listing his feats, I have proven incorrect. You, however, illogically still believe otherwise, and refuse to concede due to not an intelligent argument based on the evidence, but instead a bias.

Originally posted by dadudemon
[B

That would be the feat/s. Just saying, "he saved the east coast from a bomb" is not a feat...unless you meant he was like Mr. Fantastic with invulnerability and covered up the bomb and absorbed the whole blast. [/B]

i can easily replace that with "stopped thermonuclear world war"

Originally posted by Lestov16
SADLY........................

No.

There have been numerous Star Wars threads on this forum which have allowed characters to retain their EU feats. And it was already stated that TV-Movies count as movies (which is why Bauer is allowed in the first place) So, nice try...

So when did McClane stop Thermonuclear WWIII last? 😂


Happily, yes.

The moderation staff were quick to close or mod those threads.
And the rules were amended since. Check out the MVF rules, if you choose not to believe.

That'll probably be DH5. 🙂 Probably why he is in Russia.

You still have yet to explain how McClane beats Bauer in anything, based on screenfeats, so....

Bauer Wins 🙂

I think this thread detracts from what makes the Movie Vs Forum fun.