Captain America vs Spiderman (h2h)

Originally posted by Digi
Yeah, that fight is the only reason anyone backing Cap has a leg to stand on, and it was so laden with context from the angst-ridden Pete that we can't really draw a conclusion from it. Why people can't understand that, in comics, emotions play an absurdly significant role in fights, is beyond me. If I had a nickel for every time Pete shuffles his feet around awkwardly, gets beat up, then takes the kid gloves off the 2nd time around and absolutely destroys a supposedly equal or superior opponent...I'd have at least a few dozen nickels.

And if their fight corroborated the other evidence we had, it wouldn't be a big deal. But it contradicts literally everything else we know about the characters.

^This. Cap is a soldier, when he's in a fight he's in a fight, fighting for what he believes in. That was the case during CW. Spider-man in that particular story wasn't sure if he should be fighting AT ALL, let alone Cap (someone he worshipped) he actually wanted to join him instead. Comparing that Spider-man to PIS off back-in-black-i'll-ripp-your-face-and-make-you-my-b!tch Spider-man is ridiculous.

Also, Spider-man DOES hold back and pull his punches even when fighting supervillains. It's common knowledge and been stated many times. That's the only reason Alyosha Kravinoff and many others are still alive.

Originally posted by OneDumbG0
Objection, bullsh1t. There was a specific reason Cap worked Spiderman over in that fight. There couldn't be any further possible way for the comic to hammer in that reason. And none of the excuses being offered here have anything to do with it. Reread the fight. Objection again your Honor, double bullsh1t.

Name one thing I said that wasn't true. It really should be obvious spider-man was holding back in this fight. Hell it wasn't even that much of a fight more like an altercation. I remember the events of the fight quite well because even upon reading it for the first time, it was OBVIOUS spiderman was holding back.

Even handicapping SpiderMan as is here, hes still MUCH faster, stronger, tougher and more agile than Cap. Cap will make him work for each and every win, but to me Spidey takes 9 / 10 without the shield for Cap, and 6 / 10 when Cap has his shield.

So, for the posters backing Cap:

Any scans/feats of how Cap deals with speedsters? I think that would be paramount here, over strength/durability feats..

Just look at every encounter that he has had with spider-man.

Originally posted by Caps Conscience
Just look at every encounter that he has had with spider-man.

All PIS or had Spidey fighting subpar.
Like Digi said it's a mountain vs. a molehill.
Taking the mountain Spidey beats CA soundly evertime.

Originally posted by cdtm
Flat, featureless arena. No webbing, wall crawling, or shield throwing.

1. No shield for Cap.

2. Shield for Cap.

Who wins?

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t483582.html