TSA (The Sith Apprentice AKA Starkiller AKAGalen Marick) Experiement

This is like Gauntlet but he just does each round regardless of win/lose and he starts fresh each round. Would like to see where people rate him.

1. Darth Maul (no Force Use allowed)
2. Darth Maul
3. Darth Bane (DoE)
4. Exar Kun
5. Darth Zannah.
6. Kyp Durron.
7. Prime Luke Skywalker.
8. Traya.
9. Atris.
10. Darth Sion (Sion does not come back after receiveing ten killing blows).
11. General Grievous (no Force Use allowed)
12. Durge.
13. Jango Fett, Boba Fett, Canderous ordo and HK-47
14. Supreme Overlord Shimarra.
15. 50 Magnagards.
16. 5 Tarentaks.
17. People like Nihilus, Vitiate, The Ones, FP Anakin Skywalker.
18. The Jedi Council in RotS
19. Jedi Temple i RotS (so without Yoda, Mace Windu, Obi-Wan and other jedi like that that were absent at time).
20. Darth Krayt

Bonus Round: Revan

Why is Prime Luke only number 7? He dies there, terribly.

What is the location? For people like Zannah and Kun, that matters.

Also, he MAY lose as early as 3. Its 50-50 to me. Maybe even worse, in favor of Bane.

This is not usual gauntlet it is not in order of difficult and if he loses in round one he moves on to next anyway with full health resotred, this is just exeriment to see how he generally fares in all the scenario.

Location you can pick, one that does not give anybody unfair advantage so no darkside/lgihtside nexus nore anywhere that gives someone homefielf advantage.

I would say Random-Planet V. We all know it is just a flat, featureless plain 😛

Though just about everywhere is a force nexus at this point, or SOMEBODY gets a home field advantage.

Originally posted by Pwned
I would say Random-Planet V. We all know it is just a flat, featureless plain 😛

lol 😂

I see him losing to 3, potentially 4, 7, potentially 8, 17, 18, and 19. Probably wins in the rest.

You guys think he takes 1? Remember it is just lightsaber battle.

Oh I'd like to add another bonus round:

BONUS ROUND 2: kASIM

I think he may lose at 13. Boba and Jango could probably take him down, imo. And with HK, they just have to many gadgets. What time period is Canderous from, KOTOR 1 or 2?

Prime Canderous, so even from the book revan if he is at his best there. Maybe incarnation where he gets to use basilisk war dorid.

1. Lose
2. Win
3. Lose
4. Toss up (Lose, if Kun is better with lightsaber combat)
5. Lose
6. Win
7. Lose
8. Win
9. Win
10. Win
11. Win
12. Direct combat he loses. But if it is a hunt, then it's a toss up.
13. Direct combat - toss up. Hunt - lose
14. Toss up. Lose with lightsaber, he needs to learn to fight with Yuuzhan Vong first. But still can win with Force lightning.
15. Win
16. Win
17. Lose to Nihilus, if unable to resist Force drain, win otherwise. Vitiate - toss up, if on Vitiate's planet, otherwise win. Lose to any of the Ones. FP Anakin is same as RotS - lose
18. Lose
19. Win
20. Lose

Revan - toss up. Revan wins, if he is better with lightsaber but there is no good comparison.

How the hell is he winning 19? There was a shit ton of Jedi in the temple in RotS and if he doesn't have the 501st backing him up he goes down hard.

Also he beats Krayt.

1. Win
2. Win
3. Lose
4. Lose
5. Win
6. Win
7. Lose
8. Lose
9. Win
10. Win.
11. Uncertain
12. Win
13. Win.
14. Win.
15. Win.
16. Win.
17. People like? The hell does that mean?
18. Lose.
19. Lose.
20. Win.

Bonus Round: Win.

Seriously wierd round progression btw.

Remember this is just a lightsaber duel... Not sure how good Starkiller is in terms of lightsaber prowess. He wins most (if not all) of his battles against his Jedi enemies and Vader using the Force to an extremely high degree.

Originally posted by ares834
How the hell is he winning 19? There was a shit ton of Jedi in the temple in RotS and if he doesn't have the 501st backing him up he goes down hard.

Also he beats Krayt.

I wouldn't be that certain with Krayt. While he is not particularly impressive in lightsaber combat, if he wears Vonduun crab armor, then he's got way too big advantage.
And come on. Strongest Sith of his time and fought together with Luke against Abeloth like they are equals. We must give him some weight.

Yeah, but Force Hurricane.

Originally posted by Major Valerian
Remember this is just a lightsaber duel... Not sure how good Starkiller is in terms of lightsaber prowess. He wins most (if not all) of his battles against his Jedi enemies and Vader using the Force to an extremely high degree.

You mean the first round? Meh, I really don't rate Maul that highly. Starkiller can beat himin a lightsaber fight imo. He is far superior to him in terms of power and probably about equal in terms of skill (the words 'near perfect' spring to mind).

1. Not sure. Could go either way.
2. Win.
3. Lose.
4. Lose.
5. Win.
6. Win.
7. Lose.
8. Not sure.
9. Win.
10. Win.
11. Not sure.
12. Win.
13. Win.
14. Win.
15. Win.
16. Win.
17. Lose. Btw, 'Prime Luke', as you put it, = FP Anakin.
18. Lose.
19. Lose.
20. Win.

Bonus round: Not sure.

Originally posted by Nephthys
You mean the first round? Meh, I really don't rate Maul that highly. Starkiller can beat himin a lightsaber fight imo. He is far superior to him in terms of power and probably about equal in terms of skill (the words 'near perfect' spring to mind).

Yeah, I mean the first round. It's just that I'm not sure how truly skilled TSA is in terms of lightsaber combat. He's very good, surely, but just how much? Who does he compare with?

Remember guys the second bonus round with Kasim

Btw, 'Prime Luke', as you put it, = FP Anakin.

Is this for sure?

Originally posted by Arhael
I wouldn't be that certain with Krayt. While he is not particularly impressive in lightsaber combat, if he wears Vonduun crab armor, then he's got way too big advantage.

Ah I forgot about thui. Would crab armour give him same kind of advantage that orbalisks give bane?

Originally posted by Nephthys

Seriously wierd round progression btw.

That is pourely the order in which i thought uo each scneario it is not order of difficulty.

Originally posted by Darth Ray Park
Remember guys the second bonus round with Kasim

Is this for sure?

Second Bonus Round: Not sure.

Yes, I believe it's stated that FP Anakin is equal to FP Luke.