WBH vs Bricks (2nd try)

Originally posted by Parmaniac
Obviously these are pre-crisis stones, their durability easily exceeds the duablity of magically enchanted and artifically amped primary adamantine.

Originally posted by carver9
Why would I listen to a guy who made a bait thread and then handicapped Hulk in the same thread.

As for your post, let me know when you are ready to compare fts.

That's libel Carver and if you have to resort to personal attacks with no basis in fact, than you've already lost the discussion unless you're just trolling.

That was in no way a bait thread, which is why Bada re-opened it after Mask was banned for all his bait threads for Quan.

I reiterate, Gamora's sole teacher at the beginning of her career was Thanos. This means Thanos taught her all of her fighting technique. QED, Thanos must have some level of Martial Arts skill approaching Gamora's.

I reiterate also that having agility and speed equal to any Earth Eternal is part of Thanos' established powerset. All Earth Eternals have at least Enhanced to Superhuman speed and agility, which is the claimed levels of both Wolverine and Blade.

Just because I chose to make a thread that didn't ignore two mostly untouched parts of Thanos' power set doesn't make my thread a bait thread and any insinuations as such are baseless and as I said, libel. But far be it from me to take away your prerogative to be the first one to devolve to base internet barbarism with your unwarranted insults and attempted defamation of character.

Originally posted by carver9
Hulk is far stronger than Shaggyman and their healing factor is comparable.

Hulk cannot regenerate an entire body from a severed head. Say what you will about their strength, but their Healing Factors are not in the least bit comparable except that they both heal.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
And the two Shaggymen were imprisoned because of the fact they were more interested in killing each other than escaping and that is Pre-Crisis regardless.

Shaggyman is still head and shoulders above any Hulk's base Strength and his Healing Factor out performs any Hulk's except for when Maestro regenerated from Atomic dust.

i don't have to post the equivalent hulk feat that corresponds to that

have a nice day 🙂

Originally posted by psycho gundam
you said any shaggyman and the point is that [b]those stones can negate all the earthquakes those two would create as they fight forever in that pit.

i don't have to post the equivalent hulk feat that corresponds to that

have a nice day 🙂 [/B]

No, you don't, since you prove your own fault for posting those scans. The rocks, by your own admission and the scans, could suppress the effects of two Superman class beings fighting each other indefinitely. So either you have to realize the flaw in this logic and see it for the PIS it is or you admit that these rocks were durable enough to keep Superman class beings (and thus Hulk until sufficiently angered) contained, which is not a low feat for The Shaggyman.

And sarcasm is hardly warranted and very childish.

I'd also like to see a Hulk who could take a square blast from Orion's Astro Harness and shrug it off like it didn't matter and then proceed to knock Superman into the ground using Orion as a club.

It's pre-crisis the golden era for shitty writing in all aspects.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
It's pre-crisis the golden era for shitty writing in all aspects.

They'll still use it and ignore that fact of course. But it's hardly the first time that PIS was ignored when using scans to disprove another side's standpoint on the internet.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
They'll still use it and ignore that fact of course.

Originally posted by Parmaniac
This applies for both sides, let's just agree that PC shit should be banned from the vs section 😉

Gundam is the one who brought in PC actually, I was discussing from a Post Crisis, Pre-DCnU standpoint for Shaggy, specifically using Eiling as my example. But I apologize if that wasn't exactly clear.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
I'd also like to see a Hulk who could take a square blast from Orion's Astro Harness and shrug it off like it didn't matter and then proceed to knock Superman into the ground using Orion as a club.

Lol...so that is what you are basing it off of? Did Orion even use the full Astro on him? Hulk has been fighting teams of Heralds consistently. Based off of fts, Hulk is superior.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
Gundam is the one who brought in PC actually

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
Gundam is the one who brought in PC actually, I was discussing from a Post Crisis, Pre-DCnU standpoint for Shaggy, specifically using Eiling as my example. But I apologize if that wasn't exactly clear.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...so that is what you are basing it off of? Did Orion even use the full Astro on him? Hulk has been fighting teams of Heralds consistently. Based off of fts, Hulk is superior.

I'm basing it off the fact that Eiling manhandled both Superman and Orion and had to be BFRed both times he showed up. The JLA in the first instance weren't even making Eiling sweat or slow down and in the second case he was beating down two top dog characters who would give a base Hulk of any version a damn hard fight if not a loss. Then if you factor in the flashbacks that update the original Shaggyman encounter, it still was holding it's own/beating the assembled JLA and had to be BFRed.

I never said that Shaggyman >>> Hulk in Strength, I said Shaggyman >>> Any Base Hulk in Strength. Of course Hulk would eventually be the stronger of the two, that's his schtick.

And I never said Shaggyman would win in a feat war. Of course Hulk wins in a feat war. Comparing Shaggyman's appearances to Hulk's is like comparing a mote of dust to a Blue Whale in just sheer numberage and the sheer variety of feats. Hulk has his share of insane, high end feats that aren't afforded to a minor character.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
you brought up shaggyman/eiling, so what? he's not in this thread at all

No, Carver did actually.

Originally posted by carver9
But Superman gets worked by a less powerful brick, Doomsday and Shaggyman.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
I'm basing it off the fact that Eiling manhandled both Superman and Orion and had to be BFRed both times he showed up. The JLA in the first instance weren't even making Eiling sweat or slow down and in the second case he was beating down two top dog characters who would give a base Hulk of any version a damn hard fight if not a loss. Then if you factor in the flashbacks that update the original Shaggyman encounter, it still was holding it's own/beating the assembled JLA and had to be BFRed.

I never said that Shaggyman >>> Hulk in Strength, I said Shaggyman >>> Any Base Hulk in Strength. Of course Hulk would eventually be the stronger of the two, that's his schtick.

And I never said Shaggyman would win in a feat war. Of course Hulk wins in a feat war. Comparing Shaggyman's appearances to Hulk's is like comparing a mote of dust to a Blue Whale in just sheer numberage and the sheer variety of feats. Hulk has his share of insane, high end feats that aren't afforded to a minor character.

WWH beating Rulk with a mere thunderclap, the same Rulk that ripped through OF Thor and other skyfathers is better than any ft I have seen from Shaggyman.

By the way, there is no such thing as "base" Hulk anymore.

Originally posted by Mr.Mxyzptlk
No, Carver did actually.

Originally posted by carver9
WWH beating Rulk with a mere thunderclap, the same Rulk that ripped through OF Thor and other skyfathers is better than any ft I have seen from Shaggyman.

You really want to use Rulk as your proof Carver?

The guy who jumps from bitchsmacking the Watcher and killing the Grandmaster to being punked in most of his recent appearances?

Edit: And I thought that Thor was stripped of the Odinforce when he fought Rulk. Wasn't that after all the Bor stuff?

Originally posted by psycho gundam
okay, carver is the cause of everything anyway

I didn't start that. Read the post before I posted that.