Bane vs The Joker

Started by COG Veteran4 pages

1. Joker, Bane's "plan" was actually Talias.
2. Talia/Bane, almost turned Gotham to ashes.
3. Joker, Waynes body is almost broken by TDKR, Joker turned the city against him (mostly).
4. Joker, mainly personality and psychologically.
5. Joker, one man against pure chaos = better story.
6. Joker, Bane was altered big time to fit the realism.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Facts :T And a proven one with the Joker. He doesn't fear loss. He doesn't fear capture from the law. He doesn't fear death.

Why? Explain your points. Can you show me Joker be done in by order, or is this another guess?

He feared order. He is directly opposed to it.

I can't force you to see reason. How I have tried before.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He feared order. He is directly opposed to it.

I can't force you to see reason. How I have tried before.


When did he show this fear?

Stating your inability to debate a point? Hey thats fine by me.

Originally posted by quanchi112
He created order. Joker would shit his pants. Bane is on another level and physically will just kill him.

Bane liked to handle things/people h2h. Joker could just shoot him

Anyway let's not derail any longer. Let's stay on topic

Originally posted by BloodRain
When did he show this fear?

Stating your inability to debate a point? Hey thats fine by me.

If you think he is beyond fear then prove it. He never met Bane so its completely theoretical.

Originally posted by juggerman
Bane liked to handle things/people h2h. Joker could just shoot him

Anyway let's not derail any longer. Let's stay on topic

Bane doesn't just charge into battle with his men.

Bane is greater than Joker. You already admitted as much.

Originally posted by quanchi112
If you think he is beyond fear then prove it. He never met Bane so its completely theoretical.

Yeah, see you were the one who first brought up Joker being scared of order as your point.. so I assume this is something you can prove.

Do so.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Yeah, see you were the one who first brought up Joker being scared of order as your point.. so I assume this is something you can prove.

Do so.

its theoretical like all these matchups who have never met.

Originally posted by quanchi112
its theoretical like all these matchups who have never met.
Yeah, no. If you think Joker would fall to fear due to 'order', not just Bane himself, then you'd have to prove it or we have nothing.

If you ask me about Joker's fear I can point to scenes where he laughs in the face of extreme danger to prove that if this psychopath has fear is small and hard to come by.

Forgot to to this:

1. Bane. Joker was in it for the lulz
2. Bane but not by much. Small gap because I believe a large part of Bane's success was due to Batman's condition, that a TDK Batman would have sorted things out much sooner.
3. Joker by a bit. Death of his squeeze, corruption and death of Dent, having the city turn against him Vs beating and back breaking and mentally defeated.
4. Not sure.. As said with Bane's success coming from Bats condition.
5. Joker. With the whole opposites thing, tested him and got him to test his code.
6. Joker.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Yeah, no. If you think Joker would fall to fear due to 'order', not just Bane himself, then you'd have to prove it or we have nothing.

If you ask me about Joker's fear I can point to scenes where he laughs in the face of extreme danger to prove that if this psychopath has fear is small and hard to come by.

Forgot to to this:

1. Bane. Joker was in it for the lulz
2. Bane but not by much. Small gap because I believe a large part of Bane's success was due to Batman's condition, that a TDK Batman would have sorted things out much sooner.
3. Joker by a bit. Death of his squeeze, corruption and death of Dent, having the city turn against him Vs beating and back breaking and mentally defeated.
4. Not sure.. As said with Bane's success coming from Bats condition.
5. Joker. With the whole opposites thing, tested him and got him to test his code.
6. Joker.

I never said he feared death. Bane would break his spirit like he broke the Batman. New kind of über villain unlike Joker.

Originally posted by quanchi112
I never said he feared death. Bane would break his spirit like he broke the Batman. New kind of über villain unlike Joker.

You said order scares him, but nothing hints to that at all.

Joker would pop the champagne for the city being wrecked and wouldn't let himself get into physical confrontation like Bats did unless he had a plan, like the grenade belt. Though there's little to no reason he would approach Bane in this situation.

The only thing that was close to getting to him was when people didn't end up killing each other. Is Bane going to make sure people are safe and sound? 😐

Originally posted by quanchi112
Bane doesn't just charge into battle with his men.

Bane is greater than Joker. You already admitted as much.

Negative stay on topic

The Joker is a far better villain than Bane. And I loved Bane, but Bane (and Talia) were trying to destroy Gotham just to phuck with Bruce for killing Ras. The Joker actually represented and personified the abstract concept of chaos and came very close to proving it.

👆

Bane was purely a physical threat only going after Bruce for petty revenge. And not even his own revenge.

Joker on the other hand was Batmans complete antithesis and was a threat to his very soul and sense of morality. The worst thing about him was that he was almost right, and arguably won in the end. As a villain he was truly on another level when compared to Bane, engaging Batman on the physical, logical, spiritual, moral and emotional levels all at once.

The Joker would screw things up big time for Bane. Bane would need to kill the Joker instantly to win. The problem would be the Joker would have bomb or something on him. Lets remember the grenade jacket. I honestly think the Joker win. Except in a fist fight. Bane would kill Joker, and the Joker would die happy because someone was this corrupt and evil.

This isn't a fight between Joker and Bane. Read the OP