The Blue Oyster Bar

Started by The Scenario239 pages
Originally posted by quanchi112
She is neither.

What has Midna done that is evil?


Game makes it clear its about evil and there are no instances of it repelling good magic.

It actually has repelled good, you know. Plus Hyrule Historia says it dispels magic, why are you ignoring that?

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Ur, what? No, the magic of the Twilight Realm that reduces people to souls is inherent to the Twilight Realm. It is not evil. Link is protected. This is simple.

That's funny, the sword could by feats end True Blood with one stab. A downward one, time stop, bitches. Which reminds me, it protects Link from non-evil time magic in SS, too.

So, the sword, which is sentient, allowing something to happen, on purpose, because the wielder wants it to, makes it a bad sword? Lol.

Taking the light away is evil. 😂

Against evil to a point but he can be killed by evil characters.

It won't ever stab a TB vamp and it wouldn't kill them with just a stab.

TP only.

Midna easily bfr'd Link. Link can be easily bfr'd just like Dorf.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Taking the light away is evil. 😂

Against evil to a point but he can be killed by evil characters.

It won't ever stab a TB vamp and it wouldn't kill them with just a stab.

TP only.

Midna easily bfr'd Link. Link can be easily bfr'd just like Dorf.

All right, fine, if you're just going to say doing bad things makes magic evil...

-Using magic against Link is evil, because he is good.

What now? That's the reasoning you're slipping into, after all.

We've seen the sword protect Link from Twilight (not evil) Time (not evil) The Sacred Realm/Triforce (Not evil) etc.

A TB vamp would explode just from nearing the sword, and Fi is sentient and more than likely simply allowed Midna to teleport Link since she'd been allowing her to for the entire game. and the sword has allowed Zelda to do the same.

Originally posted by The Scenario
What has Midna done that is evil?

It actually has repelled good, you know. Plus Hyrule Historia says it dispels magic, why are you ignoring that?

Her selfish desires for her own realm. She Didnt care about them until Zelda did something selfless.

It does dispel magic or curses. The game makes it clear. I won't ignore the game.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Her selfish desires for her own realm. She Didnt care about them until Zelda did something selfless.

7. After Zelda's scarifice, Midna remains evil. (T/F)


It does dispel magic or curses. The game makes it clear. I won't ignore the game.
It does dispel magic or curses.
It does dispel magic

Thank you.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=569859&pagenumber=41#post14380391

You're wasting a lot of time avoiding this, Quan. And remember, answers that do not indicate T or F get no marks.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
All right, fine, if you're just going to say doing bad things makes magic evil...

-Using magic against Link is evil, because he is good.

What now? That's the reasoning you're slipping into, after all.

We've seen the sword protect Link from Twilight (not evil) Time (not evil) The Sacred Realm/Triforce (Not evil) etc.

A TB vamp would explode just from nearing the sword, and Fi is sentient and more than likely simply allowed Midna to teleport Link since [b]she'd been allowing her to for the entire game. and the sword has allowed Zelda to do the same. [/B]

That magic subverting their realm was evil.

No, it isn't.

Tp only. It only dispels evil magic. Game makes it pretty clear.

Based on what ?

Fi isn't in Tp. Only tp is allowed.

Originally posted by quanchi112
No, just dispelling magic.

Weak sword if you ask me.

Is this you stating that all creatures that the MS does more damage to is the sword dispelling their magic only?

Compared to?

The Twilight Realm, the source of the effects in question, is not evil.

This is the logic you're using. Doing bad things = Evil. Attacking Link is evil. Whether you think the sword cares about evil or not anymore is no longer valid.

Implying I care about what games you feel like discussing. We're discussing the canon. Something you're not very familiar with, I guess.

Sunlight weakness.

Fi is in every game the Sword is in, it's displayed it's sentience in multiple games and is explicitly stated to be able to choose it's wielder, in TP it accepts Link as its master, something that cannot think or judge cannot accept someone as worthy.

Discussion moved:

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=581817

It will get us out of the crosshairs of other posters 😛

Indeed, I originally set out not to argue with Quan in the Off Topic Thread, but it's becoming one of the only places he'll actually reply.

False. You have 25 minutes to copy and paste not in quote from there before I respond in kind there.

Tough shit?

Originally posted by BloodRain
Tough shit?
Ok, I will continue then to respond here.

If you feel like running from the debate, go ahead. No one is going to continue shitting up the Off Topic Thread. Except, I guess, you.

Let's celebrate my sexy new sig and avatar.

YouTube video

Originally posted by quanchi112
Ok, I will continue then to respond here.

Bro if you can't reply to the responses in that thread thats your call, because we're done with it in this one. Grow up and move on.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
Let's celebrate my sexy new sig and avatar.

YouTube video


I demand acknowledgement.

/Blatant attention whoring.

Originally posted by ScreamPaste
If you feel like running from the debate, go ahead. No one is going to continue shitting up the Off Topic Thread. Except, I guess, you.

Let's celebrate my sexy new sig and avatar.

YouTube video

So you openly concede, I accept.

Originally posted by BloodRain
Bro if you can't reply to the responses in that thread thats your call, because we're done with it in this one. Grow up and move on.
Since you all concede I will let it go.