Avengers vs Death Eaters · Movie Versus Forum

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by Silent Master
Right, but we'd need to know how it kills in order to make an argument about whether or not it'd work on someone like Thor or the Hulk.
I mean Odin's spear disintegrated Laufey, but Thor was hit with it twice and didn't appear to be injured.

Wouldnt that be explained by the fact that odin wasnt trying to kill thor....

Edit: Oh you meant when LowKey was using it.

Placidity Chief Executive Officer

It's like saying Xavier's TP wouldn't work on Thor because of durability, or only ever shown to work on humans. Probably just me, it seems more likely it would work rather than not.

Is this still Avengers-wanking or just anti-HP? I'm not even saying Avengers wouldn't win, but some of the arguments...

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by omgchos
Wouldnt that be explained by the fact that odin wasnt trying to kill thor....
Edit: Oh you meant when LowKey was using it.

Yes, I was talking about when Thor was blasted by Loki.

Robtard Senor Member

Originally posted by Placidity
Magic bypasses durability - see Superman.

It can or it can't, really depends.

Would fire created magically suddenly harm someone immune to fire just cos the fire came from magic, even though said magical fire just burns?

What about a magically created flying dagger, would that cut some one like Colossus just cos it's magic?

Really depends how exactly the Death Spell kills, imo.

marwash22 HELL YEAH.

Bad example since that is a specific weakness for Superman.

ares834 Senior Member

Frankly, I'd assume if the death curse hit Thor (and not this armor) he would die. The curse simply kills, durability doesn't seem to have anything to do with it. And since movie Thor doesn't seem to be some supernatural being then I'd assume it would kill him.

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by ares834
Frankly, I'd assume if the death curse hit Thor (and not this armor) he would die. The curse simply kills, durability doesn't seem to have anything to do with it. And since movie Thor doesn't seem to be some supernatural being then I'd assume it would kill him.

Magical blasts from Odin's spear disintegrated Laufey, but Thor survived just fine.

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by ares834
Frankly, I'd assume if the death curse hit Thor (and not this armor) he would die. The curse simply kills, durability doesn't seem to have anything to do with it. And since movie Thor doesn't seem to be some supernatural being then I'd assume it would kill him.

Idk about supernatural, but he is a very evolved and powerful being nonetheless. It comes down to magic. The killing curse is just that, a killing curse. Not even powerful wizards can stop it from killing them with any spell. All you can do is get out of its way, or put an object in the way. Theres just not enough info about it to know whether it affects people differently or not. So for the purposes of this thread it can't really be used.

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by Silent Master
Magical blasts from Odin's spear disintegrated Laufey, but Thor survived just fine.

I was just thinking, that might be due to his asguardian armor.

marwash22 HELL YEAH.

Odin doesn't have a curse explicitly stated to kill living things.

Thor is a living thing... Avada Kedavra kills living things... Avada Kedavra would kill Thor.

deal with it.

Robtard Senor Member

So it'd kill Galactus, since Galactus is both a thing and is alive.

Bit of a no-limit, imo.

Silent Master Senior Member

Originally posted by marwash22
Odin doesn't have a curse explicitly stated to kill living things.
Thor is a living thing... Avada Kedavra kills living things... Avada Kedavra would kill Thor.
deal with it.

That's called a no limits fallacy, going by that logic the AK would kill anybody from a random person on the bus to the Living Tribunal.

marwash22 HELL YEAH.

on screen feats, bro.

killing curse only failed once it that was due to other factors.

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by marwash22
Odin doesn't have a curse explicitly stated to kill living things.
Thor is a living thing... Avada Kedavra kills living things... Avada Kedavra would kill Thor.
deal with it.

By the standards of the book i agree. But since the movies dont show it all that much theres not much to go off of. And it never killed a being on thors level, or a super powered gamma radiation fueled beast with undefined regenerative capabilities. Its just not enough.

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by Robtard
So it'd kill Galactus, since Galactus is both a thing and is alive.
Bit of a no-limit, imo.

Precisely.

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by Silent Master
That's called a no limits fallacy, going by that logic the AK would kill anybody from a random person on the bus to the Living Tribunal.

Haha fool could curbstomp the HP universe 10 times over. Second only to god(stan lee)forget what he was called.

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by marwash22
on screen feats, bro.
killing curse only failed once it that was due to other factors.

Well twice.... actually three times. And just that fact right there does put limitations on it.

Robtard Senor Member

Originally posted by omgchos
By the standards of the book i agree. But since the movies dont show it all that much theres not much to go off of. And it never killed a being on thors level, or a super powered gamma radiation fueled beast with undefined regenerative capabilities. Its just not enough.

We have an idea of Hulk's healing factor. He can heal himself from a bullet delivered to brain via the mouth.

marwash22 HELL YEAH.

Originally posted by omgchos
Well twice.... actually three times. And just that fact right there does put limitations on it.

i forget, name the other times please.

omgchos The Man From Ireland

Originally posted by Robtard
We have an idea of Hulk's healing factor. He can heal himself from a bullet delivered to brain via the mouth.

I was talking more about the limitations of it, not that he doesnt have one. For all we know he can heal from anything with that much radiation backing him up.