Rogue Vs Superboy Prime

Originally posted by Sundipped
It almost sounds like you're applying a no limits fallacy to Rogues powers?

Not really.

If Rogue merely possessed these 6 characters abilities in her normal capacity she'd clearly get destroyed.

I havent kept up to date with SBP's appearances in about 3 years but even i know that. 😬

Would you like there to only be threads where you can drop in and post a one liner "SBP ftw" is that what you'd like?

If the characters overpowered then say so and how.

If SBP can win then say so and how.

This is all about giving me a better idea of what he can do and picking up some issue references so i can check him out for myself.

yeah, my first thought was he could overload her, but with the flexibility she has here, can't see how he can win this fight tbh.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Given you havent seen me involved in any SBP threads i think it was a hasty conclusion to come to in the first place to be honest.

Why would i make a spite thread for a character i havent demonstrated any interest in whatsoever? 😕

I dont know a lot about SBP at all, so ive created a thread to help me gauge his abilities.

The 2nd comment you quoted should hopefully trigger a response from someone well versed in DC and if SBP can take out this version of Rogue then they'll be able to reference instances on panel why. I can then go off and get hold of said comics and expand my knowledge in the process.

See the logic now?

I wish you a Happy New Year 🙂

If you don't know a lot about him, though, why would you say he can't overload her?

Just curious; not trying to start anything. Happy New Year.

Originally posted by carver9
With Hulks damage soak, Surfer durability, and Shaw absorption powers...I don't see Prime overloading her.

*fistbump*

You and me against the world, bro.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
*fistbump*

You and me against the world, bro.

😕 I'm disagreeing with you though. WTF.

Originally posted by -Pr-
If you don't know a lot about him, though, why would you say he can't overload her?

Just curious; not trying to start anything. Happy New Year.

I said i cant see how he could and then listed this Rogues abilities to back up my point.

If he can then thats the trigger for more well versed readers to chip in and provide references that i can then happily go and read up on and learn.

If the thread dies then i know im right and i leave with a slightly better idea of the level of SBP.

It's just that, for the highs he has, he has lows too, so some people's exagerrated opinion of him won't hold up when it comes down to it.

Originally posted by carver9
😕 I'm disagreeing with you though. WTF.

Read again. We both said that Prime cannot overload her.

Originally posted by -Pr-
It's just that, for the highs he has, he has lows too, so some people's exagerrated opinion of him won't hold up when it comes down to it.

Well thats what im hoping to find out.

Ive read some high end feats, his torturing of Mxy, surviving that Guardians attack, surviving a universal scale explosion etc, but i dont know how consistent he is.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Shaw CAN be overloaded, this is true.

But what happened if you gave Rogue the Hulk's ability to amp his durability? On top of the Surfer's energy absorption abilities, plus the Runner's/Surfer's reflexes so Rogue could continually discharge excess energy, or even worse, get more powerful?

Having the Hulk and Surfer's stacked abilities removes Shaw's cap.

D***

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Not really.

If Rogue merely possessed these 6 characters abilities in her normal capacity she'd clearly get destroyed.

I havent kept up to date with SBP's appearances in about 3 years but even i know that. 😬

Would you like there to only be threads where you can drop in and post a one liner "SBP ftw" is that what you'd like?

If the characters overpowered then say so and how.

If SBP can win then say so and how.

This is all about giving me a better idea of what he can do and picking up some issue references so i can check him out for myself.

I already posted and said that she would benefit greatly from Runner and without that power she gets stomped.

The issue I have is with you saying all powers boost the others. Somebody mentioned overloading Rogue but you have the "amp amps amp" justification. If we can't put a cap on just how much of a boost her amps give her in tandem, then it's really unquantifiable and subject to a no limit fallacy.

Prime.

Originally posted by Bentley
Prime utterly destroys her.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Well thats what im hoping to find out.

Ive read some high end feats, his torturing of Mxy, surviving that Guardians attack, surviving a universal scale explosion etc, but i dont know how consistent he is.

Rogue wins.

I don't see any of you remembering heat vision. Prime is not only capable of hitting her with it, he's also as vicious as any villain, and wouldn't mind melting her to a heap with it.

No touch = no drain. No punch = no amp.

Rogue dies.

Prime uses that heat vision which cuts through Superman like butter, Rogue would have only Runner's and Surfer's durability to tank that, so Prime can beat her using Heat Vision alone. She having "mastered" Hulk's power still doesn't make her an uber genius like Banner, and I just don't see her getting overly mad and juggling all those abilities at the same time.

You know what I really want to see Prime do? Just punch his way through a dimension and bust his way into the new 52 universe. "YOU STUPID LOSERS THOUGHT ONE PUNY REBOOT COULD GET RID OF ME?!"

Prime.

Going with Rogue here, the STACKED powers at her disposal I see being too much for even SBP to beat more than not.