United States Military vs ALL HP wizards

Originally posted by Silent Master
You have as of yet provided no feats so that we could determine the level of the shield.

Try not to troll, too hard, you might break your keyboard:

Originally posted by dadudemon
Because you guys are not getting, I'll be helpful:

Does detonating a bomb or missile (non-nukes, of course) stop the light from the sun? Of course not. That's not how it works. Two different energy systems. Sure, they can interact by you just cannot null the light coming from the sun (and don't try to pull the "in the shade" crap...that's not the point).

So what makes any of you think non-magical forces work on a magical shield that was only shown being destroyed by magical spells? Hmm? Where is your evidence? I have direct evidence that only magical spells can destroy the shields.

Also, you have not provided any evidence to suggest anything but magical shield breaking spells will damage the shield. Where is your evidence that a bomb can damage the shield? Last I checked, bombs were not magical.

Originally posted by Lestov16
I already did. It was asked.

I answered that in my post.

Mind quoting it or linking it to me just so I don't have to sift thru like 20+ pages of stuff? :-) thanks!

Originally posted by dadudemon
Try not to troll, too hard, you might break your keyboard:.

IOW, you have no feats for the shield.

Originally posted by dadudemon
So what makes any of you think non-magical forces work on a magical shield that was only shown being destroyed by magical spells? Hmm? Where is your evidence?

I have direct evidence that only magical spells can destroy the shields.

What makes you think only magic can stop a magical shield?

Were was this explicitly shown or stated? Cos we never saw god attack an HP magical shield either, does it stop god cos god's not a magic wielding wizard?

Originally posted by Robtard
What makes you think only magic can stop a magical shield?

Were was this explicitly shown or stated? Cos we never saw god attack an HP magical shield either, does it stop god cos god's not a magic wielding wizard?

What makes you think nonmagical forces can break a magical shield when it was never seen to be the case and when Voldemort had the options to use anything he wanted to break the shields?

Is this god suppose to be an omnipotent being? If so, then, yes, that god can destroy the magical shield because that's kind of the point of omnipotence, isn't it? 🙂 You didn't think that one through, too well, did you?

Originally posted by Silent Master
IOW, you have no feats for the shield.

You have not provided any evidence to suggest anything but magical shield breaking spells will damage the shield. Where is your evidence that a bomb can damage the shield? Last I checked, bombs were not magical.

IOW, you have no feats for the bombs against the shield.

This is like beating up kids. It is not very pleasant and is kind of sad. 🙁

Originally posted by Nibedicus
Mind quoting it or linking it to me just so I don't have to sift thru like 20+ pages of stuff? :-) thanks!

Originally posted by Lestov16
YouTube video
YouTube video

Don't forget, we got every wizard in the series amping this shield.

Look at that barrage at 6:12-6:22 in the second vid. You think an airstrike is going to stop that shield, when it's blocking shit like that from a few wizards and the shield in this match is being amped by [b]every wizard in the series. Wizards pwn and airstrikes fail. The areas too big and the shield will probably work, so yeah. L.A=wizards new home. [/B]

Originally posted by dadudemon
What makes you think nonmagical forces can break a magical shield when it was never seen to be the case and when Voldemort had the options to use anything he wanted to break the shields?

Is this god suppose to be an omnipotent being? If so, then, yes, that god can destroy the magical shield because that's kind of the point of omnipotence, isn't it? 🙂 You didn't think that one through, too well, did you?

Anything? Which other options did Voldermort have?

Lower case god. eg Jim Carrey god.

In order to claim that the shields can protect against bombs, you have to show them standing up to comparable force.

Now, do you have any feats where the shields stood up to comparable force?

Originally posted by Silent Master
In order to claim that the shields can protect against bombs, you have to show them standing up to comparable force.

Now, do you have any feats where the shields stood up to comparable force?

You won't get an answer, you'll get the expected trolling of "Zomg! You're limiting the shields, that's a limits fallacy", whatever that is.

The Death Star can now destroy the universe, cos it wasn't shown not destroying the universe.

Originally posted by Robtard
You won't get an answer, you'll get the expected trolling of "Zomg! You're limiting the shields, that's a limits fallacy", whatever that is.

The Death Star can now destroy the universe, cos it wasn't shown not destroying the universe.

It can destroy the universe, but not a HP shield....after all, the DS isn't magic.

Originally posted by Silent Master
It can destroy the universe, but not a HP shield....after all, the DS isn't magic.

Was it ever stated that the Death Star isn't magic?

Wow what a clusterfu*k.

So after tangoing, foxtrotting and lots of that desperate dancing that gets done when people are shooting at your feet, the HP side have basically admitted that they:

A) Don't know and can't quantify that makes the shield work

B) Cannot tolorate even the slightest bit of logic being used in analysis of the limits

C) Dont know if the shield is omnidirectional or not

D) Think that stopping moderate blunt trauma force is going to be equal to Hydrogen/Nuclear/Neutron bomb attacks "just cause" LOL

E) Still think that the Wizards are gonna know exactly how many bombs are dispatched and can coordinate in order and time to "Amp up the shield" adequately or inadequately.

F) Still think that (to utilise LestyQuanchwaffle) their magic will actually work outside of silly HP movies against US military tech, when no battles in history have shown a winning side that used HP magic.. Now Im not advocating this, as Im a fan of screenfeats, but just points out how gimping two-sets-of-standards and one sided bias is inherant with them.

*Yawn.*

Originally posted by Robtard
Was it ever stated that the Death Star isn't magic?

Wait, magic was never shown to work against the military in the Battlefield LA movie...doesn't that mean that they're immune to magic?

😈

It would mean that, by their own (and I use the word loosely here: ) 'logic'. 🙂

However stooping to their level is not the answer, man.
Theres always a better way than that. 😮‍💨

Originally posted by Robtard
Repeat: Quantify the power/force output of "hundreds of bolts". That is your claim, support it and prove 'hundreds of bolts' > bombs. Go!

Originally posted by Silent Master
IOW, you have no feats for the shield.

Originally posted by quanchi112
That was my opinion after you made the claim. You made the INITIAL claim.

Incorrect.

Page 4, you responded to KingD19 with: "The funniest part is they can create barriers to stop said missiles anyway." Which you have yet to prove.

You followed up your claim of 'shields stop bombs' on page 5 with your reply to Silent Master: "Protective barrier." Which you have yet to prove.

In page 1 I said "bombs kill wizards", which was in the general sense and you conceded that a wizard just couldn't tank a bomb on page 24.

Repeat: Quantify the power/force output of "hundreds of bolts". That is your claim, support it and prove 'hundreds of bolts' > bombs. Go! Now dance some more, Jojo.

Originally posted by Robtard
Incorrect.

Page 4, you responded to KingD19 with: "The funniest part is they can create barriers to stop said missiles anyway." Which you have yet to prove.

You followed up your claim of 'shields stop bombs' on page 5 with your reply to Silent Master: "Protective barrier." Which you have yet to prove.

In page 1 I said "bombs kill wizards", which was in the general sense and you conceded that a wizard couldn't tank a bomb on page 24.

Repeat: Quantify the power/force output of "hundreds of bolts". That is your claim, support it and prove 'hundreds of bolts' > bombs. Go! Now dance some more, Jojo.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes, the barriers stop physical force. That's a fact. If you believe the bombs easily kill the onus is on you. You agreed they stomp physical force which put the onus back onto you. LOL.

Repeat: Quantify the power/force output of "hundreds of bolts". That is your claim, support it and prove 'hundreds of bolts' > bombs. Go! Now dance some more, Jojo.

WgxKMUwfO9s&autoplay=1

Quanchi dances well...!
Thats pretty impressive.