DAMN!!!!! I posted in the IC Thread. HATE when I do that.......
But
Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
"....The wind went into a frenzy circling around them....."".....Austin began to calm the wind and....."
Just to play Devil's Advocate (I hope I'm using the term correctly and in the correct context) GCS didn't state that the changing of the wind was a subtle thing. In fact, he said it "went into a frenzy..." So Starry didn't meta-game when it came to this little facet. At least, that's my opinion.
But like I said before, depending on how GCS responds to her post, I think Athena (Starry) and Austin (GCS) are good to go.
Originally posted by The Big O
DAMN!!!!! I posted in the IC Thread. HATE when I do that.......But
Just to play Devil's Advocate (I hope I'm using the term correctly and in the correct context) GCS didn't state that the changing of the wind was a subtle thing. In fact, he said it "went into a frenzy..." So Starry didn't meta-game when it came to this little facet. At least, that's my opinion.
But like I said before, depending on how GCS responds to her post, I think Athena (Starry) and Austin (GCS) are good to go.
Allow me to counter.
Originally posted by starryknight
Athena took notice of the wind changing suddenly and felt it had cruel intent behind it, however, the wind changed as the boy spoke again something was not at all right.
This sounds more like a line that should come with Clive or Gregory, being the resident empaths. Even if just noticing the sudden change of wind, why is it clearly of bad intent?
The point here is there are inconsistencies that break the verisimilitude, and it's constructive criticism to better people as players when they're brought up. Don't get mad. Don't take sides. That's what makes people leave and kills games. I'm guilty of the same mistakes, and I consider myself a top notch role player when I'm not putting myself down constantly. It just means I still have opportunities to learn.
Pheo, you're not dropping. You already have us all stoked for the coming changes. Leaving now won't help anything.
Originally posted by Phoenix3068
It'll help Starry.
No it won't. Think about it. If you leave, you think she'll feel good about that?! No one here wants you gone. We all make mistakes as players, and it's best we simply acknowledge them ourselves. That's all this was: a couple of honest mistakes. To paraphrase 'The Lion King', don't run from this; learn from it.
Phoenix, you're trying to leave? I WON'T HAVE IT!!!! I'm with Xan and Scene. We ALL make mistakes. Hell, I personally think I'm a know it all and I don't always think things through before I post. What does that say about the things I DO post and some might go, "Huh?"
There are bound to be differences of opinions and of course we are all going to look at things and take things differently. I'm now realizing that I probably should have stayed out of it but I try to be a peacekeeper. (How's that working out?)
I don't want you to go because you bring a lot to everything you take part in.
You know this is so pointless, I want to tell a damn story with all of you because after all these years I find myself caring about our little roleplay group and rping anywhere else with any other people is just out of the question. So please I'm begging all of you to stick with it and lets have fun again or else what's the point.
I think its the fact that we all have our own ways of doing things. That is going to clash sometimes. If we can work it out with each other - ie, ask for more clarity if we don't understand something or use the PM system so as to avoid a public spectacle such as this particular one - we would all be okay and things would run a lot smoother.
I, for one, will work on my know-it-all-itis.
I also think that we should let Phoenix inform us of what she meant before we all jump to conclusions.
Look, I was upset by how Starry reacted and I don't think that anyone should say that she was out of line in how she reacted. So long as everything's okay, I suppose I can stick around -- I won't be taking part in anything for a bit anyways, until you guys finish your episode now. If it makes others feel better, know that I won't come out and say anything unless I'm actually trying to help with constructive criticism. If that's still bad, I just don't know what to do.
So I'm back in I guess.