Originally posted by quanchi112
Everyone who is mortal has a soul so what else left him ?
He wasn’t mortal tho so this point is moot.
Originally posted by quanchi112
We see his immortality taken in part 2 in an entirely different manner. Taking the soul away also does so. Connect the dots and think for yourself.
That proves his immortality wasn’t tied to his soul at all. You’ve proven my point.
Originally posted by quanchi112
1. The reason he doesn't die when his soul is taken is simple. That's what is connected to his immortality so that was taken not his life. That simply makes him mortal since the only part of anyone that is immortal on its own is its soul outside weird exceptions.
Yeah this makes no sense. If your soul leaves you die in The Mummy which is proven more than once. If he lost his soul he would have lost his life at the same time. He did not therefore it was not his soul that was removed. Surely you can follow this.
Originally posted by quanchi112
2. Wrong. It attacks both. Every time you kill someone a Horcrux isn't created. Due to the odd circumstances of the sacrifice and it rebounding onto himself this created one. Other than that you need to perform certain dark magic to create one. The killing curse attacked Voldemort's soul that was in Harry. In the Potterverse you can take a soul without killing someone thus proving my point ala Dementors kiss. I'm so ****ing good. 💃
I never said “killing someone makes a Horcrux”. Try not to strawman me. I said “killing tears the soul” and it was confirmed that the piece torn off attached itself to Harry due to Voldemort’s body being destroyed. The Killing Curse kills, there were two things that could be killed, it killed one of them. What are you not understanding here? Yes they can survive soulless which proves the curse does not remove the soul but only kills. The soul then leaves on its own.
Originally posted by quanchi112
3. I'm right. In Potterverse you can survive and live minus a soul. The av does both. It causes exit of soul and death.
You are horribly wrong. The Curse does one. It causes death. The soul leaves as an after effect.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Consider yourself served.
Still waiting on my order miss.