Originally posted by quanchi112The love spell is a simple charm that countered it. One person had to die, sure, but that's how you cast the spell.
She used the love charm but it doesn't save the one who does it. Kill curse kills. No magical resistance for Imhotep.
Emotep is immortal, it's never killed an immortal, to say it can is a no-limit-fallacy.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Voldemort is immortal therefore magic he uses is immortal magic.No, he won here.
A mortal used it and the magic easily defeated him. Voldemort does it easier.
Nope. Clearly mortal.
He lost.
A mortal called forth immortal magic. Voldemort is a mortal with mortal magic. He loses
Originally posted by Lestov16
So Vold wins via airborne imperio/thread
Negative. But if you want the thread closed so badly just request it
Originally posted by Lestov16
Prove that Imhotep can withstand the imperioIt was a figure of speech. Why would I want to close the thread?
Prove Voldemort can withstand a tk assult from Tep. Or anything Tep will do in a fight well before Vold resorts to Imperio. Since he has never used it in a fight or at all on screen iirc so to assume he will open with it is faulty
EDIT: Also prove the undead(or an immortal for that matter) can be Imperio'd at all
Originally posted by Lestov16
You're trying to give Vold PIS/CIS. He's clearly capable of imperio, so why wouldn't he use it? If we're assuming Vold will get an AK shot, why not just replace it with a imperio?Prove that they can't.
Not at all. Giving him CIS/PIS would be him mocking his opponent and leaving himself open like he often does. He will go for the kill right off the bat. He does not know ahead of time that the killing curse will be useless so to assume he would not use it is you arguing what you would do with his power set and extra knowledge of the opponent that Vold does not have.
Can't prove a negative. If it's possible then state your reasoning as to why. It's never been shown or even hinted at. And we clearly see that no all spells work on all creatures. So why do you think Imperio will work on an undead immortal when it has only been shown to work on living mortal creatures?
Originally posted by Lestov16
I'm pretty sure this is pure powerset vs powerset. If we tried to argue what was in character, Superman would never participate in a thread.You can't prove Imperio doesn't work, and even if it doesn't, Vold turns Imhotep into his own personal Inferi slave.
Again it's a fight to the death so Imperio would not be considered. You can turn off PIS/CIS so that Supeman would kill but he would go for the fastest easiest kill available. Like it's in Superman's power to fly into space, grab a meteor, and crash it into his opponent but that doesn't mean he'll go for that 1st.
Again you cannot prove a negative. It was never shown nor hinted at so we cannot just assume it's possible. Possible but again there is no proof that you can turn an undead into an Inferi. Only dead bodies have been mentioned and Imhotep is far from just a dead body. Also we can't just assume it would work on an immortal. Also we still need to address the mortal weapon angle
Originally posted by ScreamPasteThe charm involved a self sacrifice. It's like saying to stop a bullet you just have to jump in front of it to save your friend. 😂
The love spell is a simple charm that countered it. One person had to die, sure, but that's how you cast the spell.Emotep is immortal, it's never killed an immortal, to say it can is a no-limit-fallacy.
Imhotep has been defeated by magic. Prove magic wont work against him. Your claim to onus is on you.
Yes he will. In a pure match, he'll do that which produces the most efficient win.
You have yet to show this immunity to Imperius that you think undead immortals have. You also have yet to prove the immunity of undead immortals to the Inferi spell. Imhotep may be a powerful corpse, but at the end of the day, he's a corpse, and thus he could be very susceptible.
As far as mortal weapons, I took it to mean that Imhotep was immune to physical attacks from tangible weapons. He is susceptible to magic, as both films prove. IDK if AK will work. since it didn't work on the Phoenix, but other spells should.
Originally posted by juggermanVoldemort is immortal. Already been proven but try to disprove it.
Nope. Clearly mortal.He lost.
A mortal called forth immortal magic. Voldemort is a mortal with mortal magic. He loses
Negative. But if you want the thread closed so badly just request it
Voldemort was against a lot of prep which took years and multiple people and sheer luck going their way.
A mortal easily beat him every time he showed up.
I don't want anything closed I'm winning. I can see you do though.