Superman Vs Silver Surfer Vs Thor

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Are you coming up with these numbers based on how much it takes to cause them damage or how much they can withstand overall?

The OP said on a scale of 100.
My scale is using percentages with the highest of the three starting at 100.
So if Superman has X amount of resistance againt piercing then Thor has 35% less resistance than Superman.

The actual percentages where made up by opinion since it's impossible to assign exact real values to comparative durability. But again, I was going by the OP. The purpose of the OP is to see the opinions of others.

Originally posted by h1a8
The OP said on a scale of 100.
My scale is using percentages with the highest of the three starting at 100.
So if Superman has X amount of resistance againt piercing then Thor has 35% less resistance than Superman.

The actual percentages where made up by opinion since it's impossible to assign exact real values to comparative durability. But again, I was going by the OP. The purpose of the OP is to see the opinions of others.

What are you taking into account with your numbers?

An energy blast from some random villain blasts the contestants at 40 percent power. Superman/Surfer are unhurt while Thor has damage. He ramps it up continuosly and while Thor may be easier to hurt, he ultimately falls last to the assault.

There's a difference between how easy a being is to hurt, and how hard they are to put down. Which is why I'm asking you if your numbers are based on the ability to withstand superficial damage or being taken out.

Maybe an example for thor's damage soak would be suffice. I don't think he's equal to superman in how much damage he can take before falling.

This can go either way. Looking at fts from all, they have fallen/been hurt by things that shouldn't be able to hurt them and they have withstood high end attacks. This thread is pointless. Without looking at low end fts, all of them are equal. I would love for someone to show me Surfer being koed or cut since his rebirth...especially by blunt force. The only time I can think of him being damaged is during his run against the annihilators when he was sliced by something that was ripping through time and the time Thor head butted him. Surfer after his rebirth gets the edge significantly imo but again, an argument can be made for all.

Originally posted by carver9
This can go either way. Looking at fts from all, they have fallen/been hurt by things that shouldn't be able to hurt them and they have withstood high end attacks. This thread is pointless. Without looking at low end fts, all of them are equal. I would love for someone to show me Surfer being koed or cut since his rebirth...especially by blunt force. The only time I can think of him being damaged is during his run against the annihilators when he was sliced by something that was ripping through time and the time Thor head butted him. Surfer after his rebirth gets the edge significantly imo but again, an argument can be made for all.

That headbutt from Thor briefly denting the Surfer's head is pretty ridiculous. A headbutt? Really?

Originally posted by Dampyre
That headbutt from Thor briefly denting the Surfer's head is pretty ridiculous. A headbutt? Really?

I honestly don't think its that bad...it was a headbutt from Thor...Surfers peer. Also, Thor was damaged as well. The good showing about that fight is Surfer withstanding a hammer shot without damage. His blunt force is insane.

I think he meant that Thor headbutt him at all was just retarded.

Originally posted by Damborgson
I think he meant that Thor headbutt him at all was just retarded.

Don't understand why though.

Fraction Thor is beyond reproach.

So, nobody is giving examples. I'd be the first to go then.

Superman survives the collision of two planets

Superman shrugs off the persuader's axe.

Superman survives a sun-eater collapsing on himself

Surfer wins.

Originally posted by carver9
Surfer wins.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Give examples then.

Him withstanding a beating from Tenebrous and his partner (both are equal to Galactus) long enough for him to defeat both is proof enough. Nothing you've shown or could show will top that. Sorry bro.

lol

Originally posted by carver9
Him withstanding a beating from Tenebrous and his partner (both are equal to Galactus) long enough for him to defeat both is proof enough. Nothing you've shown or could show will top that. Sorry bro.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Lulz. Surfer nearly being killed by a lesser than moon destroying attacks are proof enough? Superman hasn't even blinked by a moon destroying in his face.

Lol...are you really looking at collateral damage? You will not win this looking at that bro. Lol. They dropped Galactus and the planet they was fighting on was still intact.

Near Galactus equals operate on a moon level basis.

Also, Shadow Moon.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...are you really looking at collateral damage? You will not win this looking at that bro. Lol. They dropped Galactus and the planet they was fighting on was still intact.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Near Galactus equals operate on a moon level basis.

Also, Shadow Moon.

Infinity Crusade.

Originally posted by abhilegend
A peer of hungry galactus maybe. 😛

Infinity Crusade.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Superman hasn't even blinked by a moon destroying in his face.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Of course I'm talking about collateral damage here. They dropped a hungry galactus by taking him by surprise and in the same fight Aegis oneshotted surfer.
A peer of hungry galactus maybe. 😛

Infinity Crusade.

I guess you forgot the scene when Superman was stopping the ship Doomsday slayer was guiding. Wasn't it stated on panel that a continent buster would have killed Superman?