Which universe is more powerful; Harry Potter or Lotr ?

Started by quanchi11214 pages
quanchi112 Disney

As yet another

Originally posted by Silent Master
LOL!!!
concession.

Silent Master Senior Member

LOL!!!

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Silent Master
LOL!!!
Three in a row go for one more.

Lestov16 CTU Field Agent

Dead Men of Dunharrow>>>Every HP Wizard

/thread

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Lestov16
Dead Men of Dunharrow>>>Every HP Wizard

/thread

They aren't powerful just formidable but they can be petrified. This is about who is more powerful not formidable.

Robtard Senor Member
Originally posted by quanchi112
They aren't powerful just formidable but they can be petrified. This is about who is more powerful not formidable.

is embarrassed for you.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Robtard

is embarrassed for you.

So you also don't know the difference between power and combat formidability. Expected as much.

Intrepid37 Restricted

Harry Potter. I think

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Harry Potter. I think
Trust me I know and the naysayers have committed thread abandonment thus conceding.

elrond72 Member

How do you know the army of the dead can be petrified? Where in LOTR does it say this?

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by elrond72
How do you know the army of the dead can be petrified? Where in LOTR does it say this?
Do so to other ghosts. Can imperio can control the king.

elrond72 Member

But it doesnt say it in LOTR only Harry Potter.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by elrond72
But it doesnt say it in LOTR only Harry Potter.
Ghosts are the same save Potter magic can petrify them.

That Lotr Fan Member

Ok, Orc war machines, and there are lots, all target the basilisk and kill it.
Then army of the dead are unleashed and clean up shop.

Whatcha gonna do?

KingD19 Shai-Gen's Enigmatic Wong

I hope you're not as biased for LotR as Quan is for HP.

That Lotr Fan Member

Not usually, I will accept defeat, for example in a straight up one-on-one Dumbledore would beat Gandalf as he has more versatile magic. In the same vein, if they didn't realise its power then the basilisk would kick ass. But once they worked it out I don't think it would stand a chance, as we see in the films it can clearly be harmed by weapons.

KingD19 Shai-Gen's Enigmatic Wong

But it was hiding. If it was out in the open there's a chance it could have frozen a large portion of the school.

KuRuPT Thanosi Senior Member
Originally posted by That Lotr Fan
Not usually, I will accept defeat, for example in a straight up one-on-one Dumbledore would beat Gandalf as he has more versatile magic. In the same vein, if they didn't realise its power then the basilisk would kick ass. But once they worked it out I don't think it would stand a chance, as we see in the films it can clearly be harmed by weapons.

No he wouldn't.. Gandalf is the equivalent of an angel.. His might is vastly superior to Dumbledore. Gandalf had cuffs on because of higher ups so to speak... but make no mistake.. in a forum setting with no restraint... Gandalf crushes D with a gesture

That Lotr Fan Member

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
No he wouldn't.. Gandalf is the equivalent of an angel.. His might is vastly superior to Dumbledore. Gandalf had cuffs on because of higher ups so to speak... but make no mistake.. in a forum setting with no restraint... Gandalf crushes D with a gesture

Yes, but we never actually see what he is capable of without those restraints, at least not in the movies.

I don't disagree its likely that without those restraints he would win. I was merely working off the Gandalf and Dumbledore we are presented with in the movies.

Reflassshh Devil On Your Shoulder

Lotr imo.